The Pirates have a rotation that looks solid enough heading into 2027, but that doesn’t mean they’re done searching for upgrades. If Pittsburgh wants to add another arm, the bigger question is whether Dustin May is the right fit.
May is drawing plenty of attention on the free-agent market. Jim Bowden of The Athletic reported that eight teams are in on him, with the Baltimore Orioles, Chicago Cubs, Chicago White Sox, Cincinnati Reds, Cleveland Guardians, Miami Marlins, San Francisco Giants and Washington Nationals all listed as suitors.
That kind of market makes him a tough add for Pittsburgh, especially when the Pirates don’t exactly need to force a move just to say they added a starter. They’re in a strong spot already, and May doesn’t look like the answer for them in 2027.
The right-hander has worked as a full-time starter over the last two seasons after missing most of the previous four because of injuries. In 2025, he pitched for the Los Angeles Dodgers and the Boston Red Sox.
In 2026, he split time between the St. Louis Cardinals and the Milwaukee Brewers, then won the World Series with Milwaukee.
The results, though, weren’t especially sharp. Over 54 starts, May went 14-20 with a 4.82 ERA across 278.0 innings and a 1.37 WHIP. He also ranked among the most hittable pitchers in baseball, posting a 44.3% hard-hit rate, which sat in the seventh percentile and was the 25th-highest mark, along with a 90.0 mph average exit velocity that landed in the 14th percentile and was the 50th-highest.
His pitch mix had some bright spots. Statcast gave his four-seam fastball, cutter and sinker a combined +5 run value in 2026. But the rest of his arsenal didn’t hold up nearly as well, with his sweeper, curveball and changeup combining for a -12 run value.
May’s postseason run with the Brewers wasn’t much cleaner. He posted a 5.73 ERA in five games and two starts, allowing 11 hits over 11 innings with a .262 batting average against.
For the Pirates, the issue goes beyond performance. May would likely require a sizable contract because of the demand around him, and that makes him a questionable target for a team that already has a strong rotation.
Pittsburgh’s current group is all right-handed: Paul Skenes, Braxton Ashcraft, Jared Jones, Mitch Keller and Bubba Chandler. Each brings something to the table, and all of them turned in good seasons in 2026, but the lack of a left-handed starter gives opposing lineups a clear advantage.
That’s why the Pirates have reportedly been looking for left-handed pitching. They’ve gone that route before, signing Andrew Heaney in 2025, Martín Pérez in 2024, Rich Hill in 2023, José Quintana in 2022 and Tyler Anderson in 2021.
There are other names they could chase for that role, including Robbie Ray, Trevor Rogers and Foster Griffin. Now it comes down to how much Pittsburgh wants to spend and whether the better path is free agency or the trade market.
In Other News...
Pirates Have 3 Affordable Fixes For Their Biggest Offseason Needs
The Pirates are heading into the winter with a projected payroll of $100 million and a real chance to build on their first winning season since 2018, which makes the margins in free agency especially important. Rather than chasing splashy names, the front office appears to be eyeing affordable additions who could patch obvious holes and deepen a roster that still needs help in a few key spots.
Bryan Abreu, Edmundo Sosa and JoJo Romero have emerged as the kind of practical targets that fit that approach. Abreu would bolster the late-inning mix, Sosa could give the club infield versatility, and Romero would add another left-handed bullpen option, giving Pittsburgh a few different ways to improve without straining its budget. [Read more 🡒]
Paul Skenes Keeps Putting The Pirates In One Tough Spot
Paul Skenes has already become one of the central figures in the Pirates long-term plans, and not just because of what he does on the mound. Since his MLB debut, he has been the subject of trade rumors, yet Pittsburgh has kept him in place as it tries to build toward postseason relevance around a pitcher who looks like a franchise cornerstone.
The problem is that the clock keeps moving. Skenes is headed toward arbitration in 2027, where the salary numbers figure to climb quickly, and he is scheduled to reach free agency by the end of the decade. For the Pirates, that leaves a familiar and uncomfortable question hanging over every season he stays in black and gold: whether they can afford to keep him, or whether they will eventually have to make a decision they would rather avoid. [Read more 🡒]
Konnor Griffin Is Raising The Stakes For Pittsburgh This Offseason
Konnor Griffin has become one of the more intriguing reasons to keep an eye on Pittsburgh this winter. The Pirates already have a young core that gives the organization a real sense of potential, and Griffin only adds to that optimism after signing a nine-year contract extension in April. Even with injuries affecting his 2026 season, he still flashed the kind of promising trends that make him look like a high-value rookie and a player the club can build around for a while.
For the Pirates, though, the bigger question is how they turn that promise into a roster that can actually contend. They have other notable pieces in place, but they also have clear needs and what feels like a limited window to make the most of this group. That puts extra pressure on the offseason to bring in the right additions, because Griffins rise only raises the stakes for a team that wants to move from interesting to relevant in the postseason race. [Read more 🡒]
