The Pirates don’t usually dive headfirst into free agency, so when a low-cost name shows up on their radar, it gets attention fast. Daulton Varsho fits that mold. He also comes with a lot more uncertainty than the price tag suggests.
In Jim Bowden’s ranking of the top 40 MLB free agents for the 2026-27 offseason, the Athletic analyst listed six players who could make sense for Pittsburgh. Varsho was the cheapest of the bunch, with Bowden projecting him at one year and $8 million.
On paper, that looks like the kind of value play the Pirates tend to chase. In reality, it may be the kind of move that says more about budget than fit.
Varsho’s appeal starts with the glove. The 30-year-old won the American League Gold Glove Award in center field in 2024, and that kind of defensive reputation is exactly why he lands on a team-fit list for a club that could use more stability in the outfield. But the rest of the picture is much murkier.
His 2026 season ended early after arthroscopic surgery on his left wrist on September 29, and the production before that point was rough. After being traded from Toronto to Houston in 2026, Varsho hit just .172 with a .535 OPS in 41 games for the Astros.
For the full season, he finished at .221/.281/.355 with 12 home runs and 40 RBI in 140 games. Even his defensive metrics slipped from the elite level that made him such an attractive name in the first place.
That’s the catch with Varsho: the upside is obvious, but so are the risks. If he gets healthy and finds his old form again, $8 million could look like a steal. If not, Pittsburgh is left with an injury question and a bat that hasn’t produced much lately.
The fit gets even trickier when you look at the Pirates’ outfield picture for 2027. Oneil Cruz is already set in center, Bryan Reynolds is locked into left, and Esmerlyn Valdez is coming off a promising rookie season that could earn him a bigger role.
Jake Mangum adds defensive flexibility, and Ryan O’Hearn is another corner-outfield option. That’s a crowded group before Varsho even enters the conversation.
Yes, Varsho could improve the defense, and he might even help reduce O’Hearn’s time in right field. But the playing-time puzzle is real.
Would Cruz have to shift to a corner? Would Varsho cut into Valdez’s opportunities?
Those are not small questions for a team trying to sort out its next step.
And then there’s the bigger issue: offense. The Pirates were the worst team in baseball against left-handed starting pitchers in 2026, finishing with a .229 batting average, a .300 on-base percentage and a .359 slugging percentage in those games.
They went 18-33 in those matchups. Varsho, a left-handed hitter who is coming off a down year himself, doesn’t exactly jump off the page as the fix.
Pittsburgh already has enough players who can run, defend or project forward. What it needs more urgently is dependable offense, especially from the right side. That’s why Varsho makes sense only as a secondary piece, not as one of the main answers.
If the Pirates use him as part of a broader effort to patch holes elsewhere, the gamble is easy to understand. If the $8 million commitment to an injury-recovering outfielder becomes one of their biggest offseason moves, that’s where the conversation changes.
This is a team coming off its first winning season since 2018, with a young core that gives it a real chance to build on that progress. The Pirates’ offseason choices should reflect that.
Another bargain hunt might be tempting. It also might be the wrong lesson to take from where they are now.
In Other News...
Ben Cherington Just Raised The Stakes For Pittsburgh's Offseason
With the Pirates coming off a winning season, the front office is already shifting into a faster offseason gear. General manager Ben Cherington said the club wants to sort out its priorities early so it can move before the calendar gets crowded and, potentially, before labor uncertainty makes the market harder to navigate. Pittsburgh is trying to build on progress, but the work ahead still looks familiar in a few key spots.
The roster still has holes that matter, especially against left-handed pitching, at third base and in the pitching depth that can carry a team through a long season. Cheringtons point is less about making noise than being ready, because an expiring collective bargaining agreement could shorten the window to do business. For a club trying to keep momentum, the pressure is now on the Pirates to have a real plan in place well before winter settles in. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Face A Costly Lefty Decision With Real Rotation Risk
As the Pirates look for help on the left side of their rotation, Jim Bowden has put two very different names in the conversation: Robbie Ray and Foster Griffin. Both would represent a meaningful financial commitment, and both would come with their own questions, which is exactly why the decision feels so delicate for a club trying to add pitching without boxing itself into a bad deal.
Ray brings the appeal of a former Cy Young winner, but the injury history and uneven recent performance make him a difficult bet. Griffin is the younger option and comes off a strong season after returning from Japan, which gives Pittsburgh a more sensible long-term path even if there are still concerns about consistency. For a Pirates rotation that needs stability, the choice is less about star power than about how much risk the front office is willing to absorb. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Face A Costly Rotation Question They Cant Ignore
The Pirates long-range rotation picture has a glaring shape to it, and it is one the front office can already see coming. As things stand, Pittsburgh projects toward a 2027 starting staff made up entirely of right-handers, which is why the club may need to add left-handed depth before that becomes a more obvious problem. It is the kind of roster imbalance that does not always show up in the short term, but can matter a great deal once the calendar turns and the matchups get tighter.
One name that fits the need is Trevor Rogers, a left-handed free agent with a track record that makes him appealing even with some injury questions attached. The fit is easy to understand from Pittsburghs side, but the harder part is the price and the risk, especially with payroll always part of the conversation for this team. Whether the Pirates actually make that kind of commitment remains uncertain, but the need for another lefty is not going away anytime soon. [Read more 🡒]