The Pirates are staring down a Rule 5 decision with a smaller-than-usual group of prospects to weigh, and four names stand out as the most likely candidates to land on the 40-man roster.
Pittsburgh has until 6:00 p.m. on Nov. 17 to make those calls before the Rule 5 Draft at the Winter Meetings on Dec. 9. Any player left off the 40-man roster can be exposed to other clubs, so this is the kind of deadline that can quietly reshape a farm system.
One of the clearest cases is outfielder Lonnie White Jr., who put together the kind of season that forces a front office to pay attention. Across 114 games between High-A Greensboro and Double-A Altoona, he hit .270/.376/.520 with an .896 OPS, piling up 110 hits, 18 doubles, 26 home runs, 67 RBI, 68 walks to 144 strikeouts and 21 stolen bases on 25 attempts.
White’s season mattered because he needed it. Injuries had slowed him over the previous few years, and in 2026 he set career highs in almost everything.
He brings speed, can handle all three outfield spots and showed real power, which matters as he turns 24 before next season. The strikeouts are still a concern, though - he fanned 32% of the time at Double-A, a number that sits in the ninth percentile and could also make other teams hesitate.
Pittsburgh has outfield depth, so it could wait and see what he does at Triple-A before making the move.
Right-hander Derek Diamond is another name that fits the protection conversation. The Pirates always need bullpen help, and Diamond gave them a strong case in 2026, earning the Kent Tekulve Reliever of the Year honor. He went 7-0 in 37 outings with a 2.48 ERA over 58 innings, struck out 57 and walked nine, and posted a .231 BAA with a 1.02 WHIP.
He was just as effective at Triple-A Indianapolis, where he went 5-0 in 29 appearances with 39 strikeouts, eight walks, a .259 BAA and a 1.19 WHIP. Diamond began his pro career as a starter after Pittsburgh took him in the sixth round of the 2022 MLB Draft out of Mississippi, but the move to the bullpen has changed his trajectory.
He has had trouble with hard contact, but his 4.5% walk rate and his extension help him keep hitters off balance. With two open 40-man roster spots, protecting him would not come as a shock.
Mitch Jebb gives the Pirates another outfield option to consider, even if his case looks a little different. He missed three months with a fractured thumb, but when he was on the field, he hit .286/.364/.475 with an .839 OPS in 55 games at Triple-A. He also added pop, going from zero home runs in 2025 to eight this season with Indianapolis.
Jebb mostly plays center field and brings speed, with 101 stolen bases over four minor league seasons. The Pirates could add him, but they already have similar players on the 40-man roster, including Jake Mangum. Even so, outfield depth is always useful, and Jebb probably gets added.
Axiel Plaz is the catching prospect in the mix. He turned in a big year at Greensboro, batting .305/.389/.513 with a .902 OPS in 94 games, along with 109 hits, 20 doubles, 18 home runs and 74 RBI.
Among South Atlantic League hitters, he finished second in batting average, third in OPS, fifth in slugging percentage and ninth in on-base percentage. He also ranked sixth in hits, ninth in total bases with 183, tied for 15th in doubles and tied for 18th in home runs.
There’s plenty to like about his bat, especially the possibility that he develops into a right-handed power threat behind the plate. But he has not played above High-A yet, and he still needs work defensively as he moves through the system. Pittsburgh currently has three catchers on the 40-man roster - Henry Davis, Rafael Flores Jr. and Endy Rodríguez - so adding a fourth would help, though the club may decide Plaz is not quite ready.
The wrinkle here is the larger labor picture. The Rule 5 Draft could wind up getting canceled because an impending lockout threatens the offseason.
A labor fight between the owners and the MLBPA is expected to lead to a lockout once the current CBA expires at midnight on Dec. 2, which would freeze transactions until a new agreement is reached. The Rule 5 Draft did not happen during the last lockout in 2021, so that possibility is very real again.
That creates an extra layer for Pittsburgh, because putting a player on the 40-man roster also means he can’t be sent to the minors if the labor battle stretches into the regular season. For a player like Plaz, that matters. If he’s stuck on the roster without everyday at-bats, the Pirates lose the development value that makes him worth protecting in the first place.
General manager Ben Cherington addressed the situation at the General Managers’ Meetings in Las Vegas last week, saying the club will do what it needs to do, even if the list is shorter than usual.
"Yeah, I think again, just be as prepared as we can, and look for as much information as we can between now and the time we have to make those decisions, basically.
"The past is informative and not perfect. You know, whatever happened last time doesn’t mean it’s exactly going to happen that way again. So we’ll see.
"... We’ve already added some of the players, probably, we would have been talking about.
So we have some to consider. It’s not quite as big of a list as it has been in some other years."
In Other News...
Pirates Just Added To An Outfield Battle Fans Should Watch
The Pirates have added another name to an outfield mix that already has some intrigue, signing Chas McCormick to a minor league deal with an invitation to Spring Training. McCormick brings big league experience from his time with the Astros, and the move gives Pittsburgh another veteran option to look at as camp opens and roster spots start to sort themselves out.
He is not on the 40-man roster, which keeps the path to a job from being simple, but the addition does add more depth to a group that already includes Akil Baddoo, whom the Pirates claimed off waivers earlier this offseason. For a team still sorting through its outfield picture, McCormicks presence gives the spring competition another layer worth watching. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Decision Could Show What They Really Think Of Henry Davis
The Pirates have a roster call coming up by the November 17 deadline that could say plenty about how they view their catching depth, and especially Henry Davis. Axiel Plaz is one of the organizations top prospects, but he has only reached High-A, which makes the decision more complicated for a club that already has three catchers on the roster and a former No. 1 pick still trying to find his offensive footing.
Plaz is the kind of player teams usually try to protect when the Rule 5 Draft looms, yet carrying him would force Pittsburgh to weigh present depth against future upside. If the Pirates decide to leave him exposed, it would suggest they believe more strongly in Daviss ability to improve at the plate and settle in as part of the answer behind it. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Take A Chance On Former Astros Outfielder With Something To Prove
The Pirates are taking a low-risk look at a familiar name, signing veteran outfielder Chas McCormick to a minor league contract with an invitation to major league spring training in 2027. McCormick, who was part of Houstons 2022 World Series run, arrives in Pittsburgh as a depth addition after a difficult stretch in which injuries and declining production slowed his momentum.
A year in Triple-A with the Cubs organization helped him rebuild some value, and that was enough for the Pirates to give him another chance. For a club that is always trying to uncover useful outfield depth without spending heavily, McCormick fits the profile of a player with big-league experience, a recent reset, and something to prove as he tries to work his way back into the conversation. [Read more 🡒]
