The Pirates’ winter catcher decision has a lot riding on one familiar question: how much patience is left for Endy Rodríguez?
Rodríguez is heading into arbitration for the first time, and Pittsburgh has to decide whether to keep him in the fold or cut bait and make him a free agent. The choice is complicated by the same thing that has followed him for years - real offensive upside, paired with injuries that keep yanking him off the field.
When Rodríguez was available in 2026, he looked like a legitimate bat. In 45 games, he hit .267/.373/.467 with an .840 OPS, collecting 36 hits in 135 at-bats, six doubles, seven home runs, 20 RBI and 23 walks against 41 strikeouts. For a Pirates offense that also dealt with Henry Davis continuing to struggle and Joey Bart getting off to a rough start, Rodríguez gave the lineup a much-needed spark.
He had a couple of moments that stood out, too. In his MLB season debut, he went 2 for 2 with two RBI in the Pirates’ 7-2 win over the Colorado Rockies at PNC Park on May 14. Later, he delivered a three-run homer in the ninth inning against the Philadelphia Phillies at Citizens Bank Park on June 29, putting Pittsburgh ahead 11-7 in a game the Pirates eventually won.
The problem, as always, was getting enough of him. Rodríguez’s last three seasons have been wrecked by injuries.
After reconstructive surgery on his ulnar collateral ligament and flexor tendon on Dec. 12, 2023, following a right elbow injury during winter ball, he missed the 2024 season. He returned in 2025, but then suffered a laceration to his right index finger after taking a curveball from Paul Skenes against the Washington Nationals at PNC Park on April 14.
That cost him 52 games, and after appearing in three games in June, he went back on the injured list and had season-ending surgery on Aug. 13 - an ulnar nerve transposition on his right elbow.
In 2026, the elbow was finally under control, but the lower half of his body became the issue. Rodríguez missed 15 games in July with a left glute strain, came back for 10 games, then landed back on the injured list and had season-ending surgery on his left hip labrum. He won’t resume baseball activities until March-May 2027.
That leaves Pittsburgh with a tough call, but not necessarily a pricey one. MLB Trade Rumors projected Rodríguez for a $1.2 million salary, just about $400,000 above the MLB minimum in 2026, which was $780,000. For a catcher who can hit from both sides and does most of his damage from the left side, that’s a modest number if the Pirates believe the bat and speed are worth the gamble.
There’s also another layer here: the depth chart. The Pirates have Rafael Flores Jr., who hit .264/.331/.527 with an .858 OPS and 11 home runs in 47 games, as another productive option behind the plate. They also have three catchers in the mix for the starting job in 2027, and no other catcher on the 40-man roster.
Even with the injury history, the argument for keeping Rodríguez is clear. Pittsburgh knows what he can do when healthy, and the Pirates need offense from the catcher spot. The issue is whether they can realistically count on him to be available.
He has played only 63 games over the past three seasons, about 13%, and that’s the number hanging over this decision. The talent is obvious.
The availability is the problem. Still, the Pirates may decide the price is low enough to keep him around and see if they can finally get the most out of him in 2027.
In Other News...
Astros Trade Looks Different After What Pittsburgh Got Out Of It
The three-team deal with the Astros and Rays has taken on a much different look for Pittsburgh after the Pirates pulled real value out of it on both sides of the ball. Brandon Lowe gave the lineup a steady boost and held up defensively, Mason Montgomery developed into a late-season bullpen weapon, and Jake Mangum filled in as a dependable fourth outfielder when injuries opened the door.
For a club trying to build on an improved stretch, that kind of return matters because it goes beyond one quick fix. Lowe looks like a player who can matter again next season, Montgomerys emergence gives the relief corps another late-inning option, and Mangums role showed how useful depth can be over a long year, even if the bigger question still hangs over how the Pirates will sort out all three moving forward. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Face Two Tough Replacements In A Risky Offseason Reset
The Pirates offseason already has a familiar feel to it, with two important spots sitting on the board before the winter really gets moving. Brandon Lowes left-handed bat gave them a steady presence at second base, while Gregory Soto added a power arm from the left side out of the bullpen, and both are now free agents after solid seasons in Pittsburgh. That leaves the front office balancing short-term stability against the reality that both jobs may have to be filled from a market that is never especially generous.
Finding replacements at second base and in the relief corps is never simple, but the Pirates have a few ways to attack it. They can look inward for internal options, browse the free-agent market for fits, or explore trade possibilities if they want to reshape the roster more aggressively. However they approach it, the challenge is the same: replacing two useful players without weakening a team that cant afford many missed bets. [Read more 🡒]
Don Kelly Just Added To A Pirates Frustration That Wont End
Don Kellys first full season in charge gave the Pirates something they have not had in a while: a winning record. Pittsburgh finished 82-80, its first winning season since 2018, but it still fell six games short of a Wild Card berth and ended the year with the same familiar feeling of being close without getting where it wants to go.
Now the focus shifts to how the front office tries to break that cycle, and Ben Cherington is already signaling change. The general manager said the Pirates plan to move on from Brandon Lowe, their key offensive player, as the club keeps searching for enough lineup support to turn a decent season into a playoff one. [Read more 🡒]