The Pirates’ decision on Endy Rodríguez is about a lot more than the money.
Ahead of Friday’s non-tender deadline, Pittsburgh has to weigh whether to keep the 26-year-old catcher on the books or cut him loose and try to work out a cheaper deal later. MLB Trade Rumors projects Rodríguez for about $1.2 million next season, which is hardly a back-breaking number. But his injury history and uncertain timetable make the choice more complicated than a simple salary calculation.
Rodríguez had season-ending surgery in August to repair the labrum in his left hip, and the expected recovery window is seven to nine months before he can get back to baseball activities. That timeline points to a return that could spill into the early part of the 2027 season. For a player who has already gone through Tommy John surgery, a flexor tendon repair and another procedure involving his ulnar nerve, the durability questions are impossible to ignore.
Normally, that would be the whole conversation. This offseason, it isn’t.
With Major League Baseball potentially headed for a lockout on December 2 when the current collective bargaining agreement expires, the Pirates have to think about what happens if the sport shuts down. During the 2021-22 work stoppage, players on 40-man rosters were barred from communicating with their teams or using club facilities for rehab. Players on minor league contracts who were not on the 40-man roster, by contrast, were generally still able to work with team personnel and keep their rehab programs moving.
That creates an unusual incentive for Pittsburgh. If the Pirates non-tender Rodríguez and then re-sign him to a minor league deal before a lockout, they could keep helping guide his recovery without using a 40-man spot on a player who won’t be ready for Opening Day.
But that plan comes with a big catch: once Rodríguez is non-tendered, he becomes a free agent immediately. The Pirates would lose exclusive negotiating rights, and he would have no reason to simply come back on their terms. Another team could step in with a major league contract, a better opportunity, or a clearer path to playing time once he’s healthy.
And there is enough upside here for that to matter.
In 45 games during the 2026 season, Rodríguez hit .267/.373/.467 with seven home runs and an .840 OPS. At one point, he looked like he might pass Henry Davis as Pittsburgh’s top catcher before injuries derailed that momentum. The health concerns are real, but so is the talent.
Pittsburgh has already committed years to Rodríguez’s development, and there’s also the roster angle to consider after the club protected Axiel Plaz and Mitch Jebb before the Rule 5 deadline. Still, the savings from swapping a major league deal for a minor league contract would be relatively small compared with the risk of losing a controllable catcher who could still matter to the team.
That’s the dilemma: preserve flexibility now, or protect the player and the control that comes with him. For the Pirates, the cheaper path could end up being the far more expensive one.
In Other News...
Pirates May Have A Real Third Base Answer If They Pay Up
A potential answer at third base has surfaced on the trade market, and it comes with the kind of versatility the Pirates have been missing. Jeff Passan of ESPN reported that Giants infielder Casey Schmitt is available in a deal for pitching, which immediately puts Pittsburgh in the conversation because the club has several young arms that could fit that ask. Schmitt would give the Pirates a right-handed option at a position where they have been searching for more certainty, especially with an eye toward the 2027 season.
Schmitts appeal goes beyond the bat. He put together a strong 2026 season, though a knee injury cost him two months, and his defensive flexibility only adds to the intrigue. He can handle multiple infield spots and even left field, which makes him the sort of player front offices tend to value when they are weighing whether to part with pitching depth. For the Pirates, the question is whether they are willing to pay the price to turn that possibility into a real solution. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Outfield Crunch Just Sent A Familiar Name To Cincinnati
Dominic Fletcher is on the move again, and this one sends a familiar name from the Pirates recent orbit to a division rival. After spending the previous season in Pittsburghs system and also seeing time with Triple-A Louisville, Fletcher has signed a minor league deal with the Cincinnati Reds that comes with an invitation to MLB Spring Training.
Fletcher last appeared in the majors in 2025, and now hell get a chance to fight for a roster spot in Cincinnati when camp opens. For the Pirates, it is another reminder of how quickly outfield depth can churn this time of year, with players who were in the organization one season ago already trying to carve out a new path elsewhere. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Seem Ready To Make A Telling Offseason Roster Choice
The Pirates are heading into the non-tender deadline with a roster decision that says plenty about how they want to build this winter. According to a Pittsburgh Post-Gazette report, the club is expected to offer contracts to most or all of its 11 arbitration-eligible players, a sign that the front office may be leaning toward stability as it tries to sort through both payroll and roster fit.
One name to watch is Jared Triolo, who appears likely to stay despite limited offensive production. Pittsburgh seems to value his defensive versatility and Gold Glove-caliber work enough to keep him in the mix, even as the lineup still needs more punch. Akil Baddoo is the possible exception in the group, leaving at least one spot on the bubble as the Pirates weigh offense against reliability. [Read more 🡒]
