Pirates Face A Brandon Lowe Decision That Could Define Their Winter

While Brandon Lowe declined the Pirates' historic $23.15 million offer, he seeks a more enduring contract to cap off his career as one of baseball's elite second basemen.

The Pittsburgh Pirates took their first swing at keeping Brandon Lowe, and it didn’t land.

Lowe formally declined the qualifying offer the club extended for 2027 before the 4:00 p.m. deadline on Nov. 17, according to Jon Morosi of MLB Network. That leaves the Pirates still in the hunt for their top offseason target, but now they’ll be competing with the rest of the market for a player they want back badly.

The offer would have paid Lowe $23.15 million for the 2027 season, with another chance at free agency after that. It was a one-year path, and Lowe is clearly aiming higher than that. He’s looking for a longer deal, not just a short-term payday.

That figure would have been the highest salary in Pirates history, and it was a massive jump from the $11.5 million he made last season on the second club option of the six-year, $24 million extension he signed with the Tampa Bay Rays in 2019.

Now the 33-year-old is headed into free agency, and this may be his best shot at landing the kind of contract that can define the rest of his career. He turns 33 next July.

Lowe has every reason to command that kind of attention. He’s coming off a huge season in which he was a Silver Slugger Award and Gold Glove Award finalist in the National League. He kept proving he’s the best power-hitting second baseman in baseball, and he also flipped the script defensively, going from a shaky glove to one of the top defenders at his position.

That combination - left-handed power and strong defense - makes him one of the more attractive free agents on the board. He also brings value beyond the box score, with leadership in the clubhouse and strong work in the community.

The Pirates still have a chance to bring him back on a longer deal, but they won’t be alone. Bigger markets are expected to be in the mix, especially in the American League East, where Lowe spent most of his career with the Rays and regularly faced the Boston Red Sox, New York Yankees and Toronto Blue Jays.

There’s also a timing issue hanging over the market. The owners will almost certainly lock out the players when the current collective bargaining agreement expires on Dec. 1, which would shut down further moves, including free agent signings and trades.

Because of that, Lowe will likely try to get something done by the end of November rather than wait through the uncertainty. MLB teams spent heavily before the 2021 lockout, committing $2 billion in free agent deals, and this winter is expected to bring another aggressive push.

For Pittsburgh, the next decision is simple to say and hard to make: how far are they willing to go to keep Lowe, and what comes next if he walks?

In Other News...

Pirates May Have An Opening In Brandon Lowe Battle

The Pirates are still treating Brandon Lowe as a priority target, but the market around him is starting to look a little more favorable for Pittsburgh. New York has been tied to Lowe as well, yet the Yankees are juggling a few different offseason needs and have also been linked to a possible reunion with Jazz Chisholm Jr., which adds another layer to their infield picture.

The bigger question may be how aggressively the Yankees want to spend once they get through their bullpen shopping. Their budget-conscious approach and reported interest in multiple relief arms could leave less room to push hard on Lowe, and that is the kind of opening the Pirates have to be hoping for as they try to bring him back. [Read more 🡒]

Pirates Just Sent A Clear Message About Two Young Prospects

The Pirates made their intentions clear ahead of the Rule 5 Draft deadline, adding outfielder Mitch Jebb and catcher/first baseman Axiel Plaz to the 40-man roster to keep both young players out of reach for other clubs. It was a straightforward move, but one that says plenty about how the organization views two prospects who have each put themselves on the radar in different ways.

Jebb, a 2023 draft pick, has spent most of his time in center field and recently worked back from a thumb injury, while Plaz boosted his stock with a strong season at High-A Greensboro as a right-handed power bat. For a Pirates system that continues to lean on internal development, protecting both players was as much about preserving depth as it was about rewarding progress. [Read more 🡒]

Pirates Face A Tough Young Talent Decision They Can't Afford To Miss

The Pirates are approaching one of the quieter but more consequential dates on the offseason calendar, with a November 17 deadline to decide which minor leaguers belong on the 40-man roster and which ones they are willing to leave exposed to the Rule 5 Draft on December 9. It is the kind of roster crunch that forces a front office to weigh present depth against future upside, and for Pittsburgh, the list of possible protections includes a handful of names that have pushed themselves into the conversation.

Outfielders Lonnie White Jr. and Mitch Jebb, right-hander Derek Diamond and catcher Axiel Plaz are among the prospects being considered, each for different reasons tied to recent performance and long-term potential. The Pirates have to balance those evaluations against their own roster needs, and the next few days will reveal how aggressively they plan to shield that young talent from other clubs looking for an opportunity in the Rule 5 Draft. [Read more 🡒]