The Pirates have a Rule 5 decision coming that could say a lot about where they stand on Henry Davis.
The deadline to shield players from the Rule 5 Draft by putting them on the 40-man roster is November 17, and catcher Axiel Plaz sits right at the center of the issue. Pittsburgh’s No. 7 prospect per MLB Pipeline, Plaz put together a big year in Greensboro, hitting .305/.389/.513 with 18 homers. He’s also eligible to be picked in the Rule 5 Draft this winter.
That creates a real dilemma. Plaz has not played above Hi-A, so he wouldn’t be expected to help the 2027 roster right away. But the catcher market is thin, and if the draft happens, another club could still grab him and try to force him into action.
Pittsburgh already has three catchers on the 40-man roster, and none of the choices are simple. Rafael Flores Jr. has looked like a possible future piece if his small-sample production holds.
Endy Rodriguez brings plenty of talent, though injuries have been a constant problem. That leaves Davis as the other name in the mix.
Davis is a strong defender, which matters a lot behind the plate. But the bat has not come close to matching the glove.
The 27-year-old hit just .172/.272/.313 in 2026 and has a career .565 OPS. That kind of offense makes it hard to carry him if the Pirates decide Plaz is worth protecting.
If Pittsburgh adds Plaz, it likely means Davis is the one squeezed out. And that would also signal something bigger: the organization is leaning hard into Flores Jr. and Rodriguez as its catching options for 2027.
There is still a case for Davis. He was the No. 1 overall pick in 2021, and the tools are still there.
His bat speed averages 74.2 miles per hour, which is well above average, and his 90.3 miles per hour average exit velocity also stands out. The issue is that he doesn’t make enough contact, and when he does, the angles have not helped him do real damage.
The Pirates have to decide whether they think that can change. The comparison here is Patrick Bailey, a glove-first catcher who was far below average offensively with the San Francisco Giants before becoming a roughly league-average hitter with the Cleveland Guardians, posting a 99 OPS+ after his trade, including the playoffs.
If the Pirates believe Davis can still find that kind of offensive turnaround, they may be willing to risk losing Plaz because of Davis’s veteran value and the strength of their catching depth. If they don’t believe it, then they have a few days to try to trade Davis to a team that does - or eventually designate him for assignment when they need a 40-man spot.
However it plays out, the Plaz decision will reveal plenty about how much faith the Pirates still have in Davis.
In Other News...
Pirates Have 3 Affordable Fixes For Their Biggest Offseason Needs
The Pirates are heading into the winter with a projected payroll of $100 million and a real chance to build on their first winning season since 2018, which makes the margins in free agency especially important. Rather than chasing splashy names, the front office appears to be eyeing affordable additions who could patch obvious holes and deepen a roster that still needs help in a few key spots.
Bryan Abreu, Edmundo Sosa and JoJo Romero have emerged as the kind of practical targets that fit that approach. Abreu would bolster the late-inning mix, Sosa could give the club infield versatility, and Romero would add another left-handed bullpen option, giving Pittsburgh a few different ways to improve without straining its budget. [Read more 🡒]
Paul Skenes Keeps Putting The Pirates In One Tough Spot
Paul Skenes has already become one of the central figures in the Pirates long-term plans, and not just because of what he does on the mound. Since his MLB debut, he has been the subject of trade rumors, yet Pittsburgh has kept him in place as it tries to build toward postseason relevance around a pitcher who looks like a franchise cornerstone.
The problem is that the clock keeps moving. Skenes is headed toward arbitration in 2027, where the salary numbers figure to climb quickly, and he is scheduled to reach free agency by the end of the decade. For the Pirates, that leaves a familiar and uncomfortable question hanging over every season he stays in black and gold: whether they can afford to keep him, or whether they will eventually have to make a decision they would rather avoid. [Read more 🡒]
Konnor Griffin Is Raising The Stakes For Pittsburgh This Offseason
Konnor Griffin has become one of the more intriguing reasons to keep an eye on Pittsburgh this winter. The Pirates already have a young core that gives the organization a real sense of potential, and Griffin only adds to that optimism after signing a nine-year contract extension in April. Even with injuries affecting his 2026 season, he still flashed the kind of promising trends that make him look like a high-value rookie and a player the club can build around for a while.
For the Pirates, though, the bigger question is how they turn that promise into a roster that can actually contend. They have other notable pieces in place, but they also have clear needs and what feels like a limited window to make the most of this group. That puts extra pressure on the offseason to bring in the right additions, because Griffins rise only raises the stakes for a team that wants to move from interesting to relevant in the postseason race. [Read more 🡒]
