The Pirates have work to do this winter, and the bullpen sits near the top of the list. But one projected move could leave them paying a premium for something they already know all too well: Gregory Soto’s talent, and his volatility.
Jim Bowden of The Athletic included Pittsburgh as the lone best fit for Soto in his ranking of the top 40 MLB free agents for 2026-27, forecasting a two-year, $22 million deal. That would be a major jump from the one-year, $7.75 million contract the Pirates gave the left-hander last offseason.
Soto’s first year in Pittsburgh came with both the good and the shaky. The 31-year-old finished 2026 with a 3.63 ERA, 79 strikeouts and 16 saves over 67 innings, and opponents hit just .199 against him. But he also coughed up six saves in 22 chances, with command problems surfacing at the worst times.
For a bullpen that spent much of the season trying to find its footing, that kind of inconsistency is exactly what the Pirates should be trying to avoid. A two-year commitment at an average of $11 million per season would be a steep price for a reliever whose dependability is still very much in question.
There is a case for bringing Soto back. He can miss bats, keep contact weak and pitch in leverage spots, and Pittsburgh still needs left-handed relief help beyond Mason Montgomery, who emerged as one of baseball’s most effective closers in the second half. Luke Weaver’s role as a veteran setup arm also gives the club some flexibility.
The Pirates’ bullpen was better after the trade deadline, dropping from a 4.34 ERA to 3.49. That matters, because it shows improvement was possible without leaning only on the arms that struggled earlier in the year.
Even so, Soto is not the only place where Pittsburgh needs to spend. Kirby Yates’ retirement leaves another hole, and Brandon Lowe’s uncertain future, the questions at third base and catcher, and the need for another reliable starting pitcher all deserve attention too. Bowden’s projections also have Lowe, who may be Pittsburgh’s most important pending free agent, at just $15 million per year.
That’s what makes Soto such a tricky fit. The issue isn’t whether he merits another big-league deal. It’s whether the Pirates should be the club willing to give him a raise and a second guaranteed season.
Pittsburgh needs to spend more this offseason. That part is obvious. The real challenge is making sure the money actually pushes the roster forward, because $22 million for a familiar but inconsistent reliever could be an expensive reminder that spending and improving are not the same thing.
In Other News...
Pirates Fans Should Be Worried This Problem Goes Far Beyond Ben Cherington
The Pirates had a chance to go in a different direction when they were searching for a general manager in 2019, and Matt Arnold was among the names in the mix before Ben Cherington got the job. That decision has taken on a different light now, because Arnold has become part of the Brewers front office success story while Pittsburgh is still looking for the kind of sustained progress fans expected when Cherington arrived.
Arnolds rise in Milwaukee is a reminder that personnel choices are only part of the equation. The Brewers have built with continuity, structure and organizational support, while the Pirates have too often looked like a club still trying to establish the same foundation. Even with Cherington in place, the bigger concern for Pittsburgh is how much of the gap between these franchises comes from the man at the top, and how much comes from everything around him. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Are Stockpiling Shortstops And One Big Question Follows
The Pirates have made a clear habit of loading up on shortstop talent, adding first-round pick Konnor Griffin, second-round picks Wyatt Sanford and Aiden Ruiz, and other young infielders such as Johan De Los Santos and Darrell Morel. It is the kind of pattern that says as much about organizational thinking as it does about individual prospects, with Pittsburgh treating shortstop as both a premium defensive spot and a source of athleticism that can ripple across a roster.
There is also a more practical side to it: good shortstops tend to hold value, and even the ones who do not stay at the position forever can still become useful pieces somewhere else. For the Pirates, the real question is not whether they have invested in the spot, but how many of these players will remain there as they move through the system and whether one of them eventually becomes the long-term answer the club has been hunting for. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Face A Costly Spencer Horwitz Question For 2027
Spencer Horwitz is in line to become an arbitration case for the Pirates this winter, and it is a little earlier than the usual timetable. Because of his Super Two status, he is eligible for arbitration despite not yet reaching three years of service time, putting Pittsburgh in position to make a financial decision on a player who looked like part of the long-term picture after a productive first half of 2026.
The issue gets trickier because Horwitz did not finish the season anywhere near that level. After returning from a left hamstring injury and a concussion on his rehab assignment, he struggled badly down the stretch, leaving the Pirates with a projected salary around $2.5 million and a real question about how much they want to commit to a bounce-back bet for 2027. [Read more 🡒]