Major League Baseball’s proposed postseason changes could make life even harder for a Pirates club that is still trying to turn promise into something deeper.
The most striking part of the plan is simple and a little brutal: beginning in 2027, the No. 3 seed in each league would get to pick whether it wants to play the No. 5 or No. 6 seed in the Wild Card Series. Then the No. 1 seed would choose its Division Series opponent from the Wild Card winners. If that sounds like another layer of punishment for teams trying to sneak into October, that’s because it is.
For Pittsburgh, the timing matters. The Pirates just posted an 82-80 season in 2026, their first winning record since 2018, and finally gave some real shape to a rebuild that has leaned heavily on pitching.
Paul Skenes, Jared Jones, Braxton Ashcraft and Bubba Chandler now look like the kind of rotation core that can carry a team through a short series. That’s the upside.
The concern is what happens when the series gets longer and the margin for error shrinks.
MLB’s proposed changes would eventually make the road even more demanding. In 2029, the league has floated trimming the regular season from 162 games to 154 and stretching the Division Series from best-of-five to best-of-seven.
Longer series can expose flaws that a shorter sprint hides. Lineups with holes get exposed.
Bullpens get stressed. Depth suddenly matters in a way it can’t in a three-game set.
The Pirates do have some reasons to believe their pitching can play in October. Skenes is the kind of arm teams build around.
Jones, Ashcraft and Chandler add more upside. Mason Montgomery also emerged as a real late-inning option.
But the bullpen remains unsettled, Gregory Soto is nearing free agency, Kirby Yates has retired, and there are still several relief jobs that need answers.
That’s why the proposed system is more than just a formatting tweak for Pittsburgh. It adds another obstacle for a team that is still trying to climb toward the top tier.
Under this setup, the Pirates could finally get into the field only to be identified as the opponent a higher seed wants most. That’s the new reality the proposal creates.
Pittsburgh also has a few meaningful pieces beyond the pitching staff. Konnor Griffin stands out as a potential offensive cornerstone, and the offense as a whole took a step forward in 2026.
Even so, the roster still has gaps. Brandon Lowe’s impending free agency could take away one of the lineup’s more productive bats, and the bullpen still needs more dependable depth.
MLB says the shorter season would provide a standard weekly off day and help player health. That may be part of the argument, but from the Pirates’ side, the bigger issue is what comes after the regular season ends.
The changes are not guaranteed, and they are tied to broader collective bargaining talks that include a salary cap the players’ union has strongly opposed. Still, the direction of the proposal is clear: the league is looking to reward the teams at the top even more.
For the Pirates, that leaves the same essential task, no matter what format MLB eventually settles on. An 82-win season showed progress, but it did not finish the job.
Pittsburgh still has to build a team that can win in October, not just reach it. If the league’s proposed overhaul becomes reality, that distinction only gets sharper.
In Other News...
Pirates Fans Just Got Another Painful Reminder About The Archer Trade
The Chris Archer deal has become one of those trade reminders Pirates fans cannot quite escape. When Pittsburgh sent Tyler Glasnow to Tampa Bay in 2018, the hope was that Archer would stabilize the rotation, but the long view has looked far different. Glasnow grew into a frontline starter with the Rays before moving on to the Dodgers, while Archers time in Pittsburgh never matched the expectations that came with the move.
It also fits a larger pattern that has made Tampa Bay so difficult to keep pace with. The Rays have built a reputation for targeting talent in trades and then getting more out of it, while the Pirates have spent the years since trying to sort through the fallout of roster decisions that have not always aged well. For Pittsburgh, the Archer trade remains a painful example of how one big swing can echo for a long time. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Rotation Suddenly Hinges On Mitch Kellers Long Road Back
Mitch Kellers season is already over, and for the Pirates that shifts the focus from a late-year rotation piece to a long recovery that will stretch deep into the offseason. The right-hander was moved to the 60-day injured list after a shoulder injury that did not require surgery, but still figures to keep him off a mound for quite a while as Pittsburgh plots its plans for next year.
The club is expecting Keller to resume throwing late in the offseason and eventually rejoin the rotation, though the path back is the story now. Young outfielder Esmerlyn Valdez also finished the year on the injured list with a hamstring strain, but he says he is healthy and plans to sharpen up in the Dominican Winter League before the next season begins. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Already Face A Brandon Lowe Question They May Not Like
The Pirates are already staring at a lineup question that goes beyond the next season, because second base is far from settled for 2027. Brandon Lowe is penciled in as the power bat at the position for 2026, but he is headed for free agency and there is no guarantee Pittsburgh can or will bring him back, which puts a key infield spot back on the board sooner than the club would like.
Gleyber Torres has surfaced as one possible name in the free-agent market, but the bigger issue may be whether the Pirates want to spend elsewhere or keep a path open for what they already have in house. If Lowe departs, Nick Gonzales would be the internal fallback, leaving Pittsburgh with a choice between paying for another veteran bat or trusting its own depth to handle the position. [Read more 🡒]