The Pirates can point to a lot of encouraging things from 2026, but the biggest number on the board tells the real story: this pitching staff piled up strikeouts like never before, and still left room for more.
Pittsburgh finished fifth in the league with 1,496 strikeouts, smashing the franchise’s previous single-season mark of 1,493 set in 2019. That kind of swing-and-miss volume is the backbone of a staff that helped the Pirates post a winning record for the first time since 2018, even if the season still ended without a playoff berth for the ninth straight year.
There was real value in that group, too. The Pirates’ pitching staff produced the sixth-most fWAR in the league at 21.0, an impressive haul even with Paul Skenes going through what qualified as his worst big-league season so far. “Worst” is doing a lot of work there: he still finished with a 3.33 FIP and 4.2 fWAR.
The strikeout total was a full-team effort. Skenes led the way with 200, marking the second straight year he reached that number, and Braxton Ashcraft turned in a breakout season with 173.
After those two, nobody else on the roster got to 150. The workload was spread across the staff, with starters combining for 795 strikeouts and relievers adding 701.
In all, 30 different Pirates pitchers recorded at least one strikeout, and outfielder Tyler Callihan even chipped in three in blowout work. Ten pitchers reached at least 50 strikeouts.
That’s the part that should excite Pittsburgh. The stuff is clearly there. The question now is how much more damage that stuff can do when the rest of the operation catches up.
Because the strikeouts alone didn’t make the Pirates a truly elite run-prevention team. Among the five clubs that finished with the most strikeouts, Pittsburgh’s 4.15 ERA was the worst by a wide margin. Their 3.82 FIP looked better, but it still wasn’t where you’d expect a staff built around this much swing-and-miss.
The defense didn’t give the pitching staff much help, either. Pittsburgh was exactly average in Defensive Runs Saved and finished 25th in the majors with a -20 Fielding Run Value. And if the Pirates want this staff to turn more of those punchouts into wins, they’ll need a bullpen that’s sturdy from April through September, not one that only settles in after a deadline makeover.
In Other News...
Pirates Are Already Sending A Worrying Brandon Lowe Offseason Signal
Brandon Lowes first year with the Pirates gave the club plenty to like, both on the field and in the clubhouse, and general manager Ben Cherington made clear the organization noticed. Cherington praised Lowes performance and the way he fit in with the group, which is exactly the sort of internal endorsement a player wants heading into free agency for the first time.
Still, Pittsburgh is not treating a return as a given. Cherington also suggested the Pirates need to keep exploring other options before deciding whether to bring Lowe back, a sign that the club is weighing the relationship against financial reality and whatever the market brings. Lowe and the Pirates have mutual interest in a reunion, but the next step may come down to whether the numbers line up. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Have An Internal Answer To A Costly Offensive Problem
The Pirates spent much of 2026 chasing fixes for an offense that too often stalled against left-handed pitching, and the issue lingered as one of the more costly flaws in an uneven season. Even with injuries undercutting the clubs postseason hopes, there were still pockets of promise, as a few hitters stayed healthy and productive enough to give the front office a clearer picture of where the lineup might improve.
The encouraging part for Pittsburgh is that the answer may already be in the organization, with Konnor Griffin, Oneil Cruz, Esmerlyn Valdez, Bryan Reynolds and Rafael Flores Jr. among the players who showed the kind of potential that could matter most in 2027. The challenge now is turning that upside into consistent production against lefties, because the Pirates do not need a theoretical solution as much as a lineup that can finally hold up when the matchup turns unfavorable. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Still Have One Roster Hole They Cant Ignore This Winter
The Pirates took a step forward in the standings this past season, but the bigger picture is still hard to ignore: October remains out of reach, now for the 11th straight year. Even with the progress, the roster still showed some of the same flaws that have lingered through much of the rebuild, especially when it came to matching up with left-handed pitching and generating enough impact from the right side of the plate.
There is also a more specific concern hanging over the offseason: third base does not yet look settled, and the defensive side of the position remains a question. Pittsburgh could try to address that through a trade or in free agency, and it feels like one of those spots that can quietly shape how competitive the club is next year, even if it does not grab as many headlines as the power issue. [Read more 🡒]