Denny Heindl and Stephen Wong spent Monday night doing what they seem to love most: watching Pirates history come alive in front of real people.
As they moved through Legacy Hall, the room itself did the heavy lifting. Willie Stargell’s bat.
Roberto Clemente’s jacket. Chuck Tanner’s hand-written notes.
For Heindl and Wong, though, the artifacts were only part of the reward. The real payoff was seeing fans react to them, especially the season-ticket holders who were taking it all in with the kind of wonder that only comes from standing inches away from baseball history.
The Pirates honored both men with a special event that included a question-and-answer session with team historian Jim Trdinich. Greg Brown moderated, and Pirates president Travis Williams opened with remarks. It was a fitting setup for two collectors who have spent years building some of the finest baseball collections in North America, then sharing pieces of those collections to help make Legacy Hall what it is.
“I think it’s awesome to see fans come here like this, to tell the history of the Pirates," Heindl said. "They have some awesome things here.
If you have a favorite player, you’ll see them here. There are a lot of stories behind every piece.
“I always wondered how I could share my collection with the fans. This is my way of doing it. I enjoy it.”
Legacy Hall, which opened on June 24 at the base of the left-field rotunda, gives those stories a home. It’s a space built for meetings, cocktail receptions and events, but it also functions as something more valuable: a place where the Pirates’ past can be touched, studied and felt instead of simply read about.
That idea came through clearly in Wong’s remarks. He said the display offers “a much more profound meaning of not only the team and franchise but the whole experience at a stadium,” and that it helps connect the players on the field to the long line that runs from Fred Clarke and Honus Wagner to the Waner brothers, Ralph Kiner, Roberto Clemente, Willie Stargell and Dave Parker, and on to Paul Skenes and Andrew McCutchen.
“It’s important to give people that sense of tangible-ness to history. Not reading it, but seeing it.”
The pair’s stories gave the evening its texture. Heindl talked about a baseball signed by Pope John Paul II, and about spending time with Stargell in his final days, when Pops signed a bat and apparently told him, “That’s the last one.”
He also recalled his friendship with Tanner, including a moment when the manager spread collectibles across a pool table, and he described a scorecard that Pirates Chairman Bob Nutting’s father, Ogden, bought at auction to mark the first game he attended with his father.
For Heindl, the objects matter because of what they carry with them.
“Whatever you can pick up,” Heindl advised those attending, “put it away and enjoy it.”
Wong brought a different layer to the conversation, pointing to the letter in Legacy Hall from President Dwight D. Eisenhower to Honus Wagner on Wagner’s 80th birthday in February 1954. He and Heindl also talked about the way autographs used to look, when players took time to write their names in perfect cursive.
“Mickey Mantle wanted you to know that it was from him,” Heindl said. “Every autograph was perfect.”
They made clear that this wasn’t about criticizing players today. It was about how collecting has changed, and how much more care now has to go into protecting against counterfeit signatures and inauthentic items.
Both men offered advice on storing autographs properly, getting items authenticated and understanding what goes into verifying game-used memorabilia. Wong even pointed to details such as blood stains on the shoulder of a Jackie Robinson jersey.
“Things like blood stains on the shoulder of a Jackie Robinson jersey,” Wong said. “I don’t mean to get too weird with you on this, but game-used collectors, this is the type of thing you look into that gives it special meaning.”
Heindl, a Ridgway resident and limited partner of the Pirates since 1997, grew up rooting for the Yankees before developing a connection to the Pirates through his father-in-law, who was blind and listened to Rosey Rowswell on the radio. Wong, who lives in Hong Kong, has also helped curate a similar exhibit at Dodger Stadium and has written three books on baseball collectibles.
Both men spoke like people who have spent a lifetime chasing more than objects. They’ve chased memory, context and the kind of history that becomes easier to understand when it’s sitting right in front of you.
That, in the end, is the point of Legacy Hall. And it’s why Heindl and Wong’s collections have helped turn it into a place Pirates fans can’t just pass through - they have to stop and look.
In Other News...
Pirates Own Up To A Costly Mistake Fans Wont Forget
A scoring chance slipped away against the Brewers when the Pirates put together a play that should have put pressure on Milwaukee, only to have the moment unravel on the bases. Nick Gonzales and designated hitter Ryan O'Hearn were involved in the miscue, with third base coach Tony Beasley at the center of the decision that led to Gonzales being held at third.
Beasley owned the mistake after saying he did not see the ball clearly, and Gonzales said he simply followed the instruction he was given. It was the kind of miscommunication that can linger because it cost the Pirates a real chance to add a run, and it left a familiar frustration for a team trying to squeeze every bit out of tight games. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Face A Real Brandon Lowe Test They Usually Avoid
Brandon Lowe has been one of the quieter success stories of the Pirates' recent roster churn, and this season has only raised the stakes around how long he stays in Pittsburgh. Acquired in a three-team trade last offseason, Lowe has turned in one of the best years of his career, with 30 home runs and an .803 OPS, giving the Pirates the middle-order production they have been chasing.
The harder part comes after the season, when Lowe is set for free agency and the Pirates may be forced to decide whether to extend a qualifying offer they are likely to see rejected. There is already speculation that Lowe could be looking for a two- to three-year deal, which would put him on a collision course with a club that usually prefers one-year contracts and makes this more than a simple keep-or-let-go decision. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Fans Are Bracing For Another Ben Cherington Decision
The Pirates are drifting toward another long winter with little to show for a season that never got far off the ground. Injuries have played their part, but the larger problem is the same one that has followed Ben Cherington through seven seasons in charge: a club that keeps arriving at September with more questions than answers, even after a few offseason moves hinted at a more encouraging direction.
Pittsburgh still sits seven games back in the NL Wild Card race with 11 games left, which leaves the club little margin to create any late drama. So the attention is already shifting beyond the standings and toward Cheringtons future, with fans and observers wondering whether the front office will keep the same voice guiding what comes next. [Read more 🡒]