Nick Gonzales gave the Pirates one of their better bats in 2026, but his defensive home is still very much up in the air.
That uncertainty starts with the fact that Pittsburgh asked him to do something new and difficult. Gonzales spent the season at third base, a spot he had barely touched before, and the results were rough enough that the Pirates are still sorting out what comes next. General manager Ben Cherington said the club and manager Don Kelly are still working through exit meetings and don’t have a final answer yet.
"I don't know," Cherington said in his final press conference on Sept. 26. "Donnie and I are making our way through exit meetings with players, and in our conversation with Nick, that was the answer is we don't know yet, and we might not know until later in the offseason.
"Believe in him as a player. Believe that every time his back has been against the wall, he's fought back and found a way to improve.
He was asked to do something really hard this year. He was asked to play third base, which he really hadn't done much of.
"So we just need more information on what the roster looks like, I think, before we can answer that question. But as soon as we have more clarity, we'll deliver it to him. And when he's had clarity, he's usually done good things when he has clarity."
The Pirates shifted Gonzales to third after trading for Brandon Lowe, who started 133 of 138 games at second base. Gonzales, a former second baseman, was moved to the hot corner to get his bat into the lineup and ended up starting 101 of 112 games for Pittsburgh in 2026.
But the defensive numbers were brutal. Gonzales finished at minus-15 defensive runs saved and minus-11 outs above average, both the worst marks among third basemen in 2026, with a minimum of 850 innings played. His usage at third also tapered off late in the year, as he made 10 starts in 14 games over Pittsburgh’s final 42 contests.
Second base is still his primary position, but that hasn’t been a clean answer either. Gonzales has struggled there too, including minus-17 DRS and minus-11 DRS in 2025, the last season in which he was mainly a second baseman.
Offensively, though, Gonzales had his best year yet. He hit .303/.367/.388 with an OPS of .755, finished fourth in the National League in batting average, and ranked sixth in MLB in that category.
That production gives the Pirates something to think about as they map out the infield. If Lowe doesn’t return, Gonzales could slide back to second, but that would mean giving up Lowe’s 35-home-run power and a much stronger defensive profile after Lowe’s own improvement in the field.
Pittsburgh also has Jared Triolo as an option at third base. Triolo isn’t a better hitter than Gonzales, but he brings far more value defensively and already owns a Gold Glove Award from 2024 as a utility player.
The Pirates could also look outside the organization for a power-hitting third baseman, which would put Gonzales in a tougher spot for playing time. For now, the club appears to believe he has a future in Pittsburgh. The question is whether his glove improves enough to make that future easy to map out.
In Other News...
Former Pirate Joe Musgrove Just Got A Painful October Reminder
Joe Musgroves return to a major league mound finally arrived Tuesday night in San Diego, and it came with the kind of October stage that can make every pitch feel heavier. In the Padres 8-0 win over the Cubs in the National League Wild Card Series, the former Pirate got into the game in the ninth inning and finished off a scoreless frame, striking out the final batter while working around two hits and a walk.
For Pittsburgh fans who watched Musgrove develop into a dependable arm before moving on, the appearance was a reminder of how long his road back had been. Nearly two years had passed since his last major league pitching appearance, and the comeback has taken him through Tommy John surgery and more than one setback before he could get back in front of a postseason crowd. [Read more 🡒]
Ben Cheringtons Pirates Problem Is Showing Up On Playoff Rosters
Several familiar names from recent Pirates lineups are still around October baseball, just not in the same roles they had in Pittsburgh. Rowdy Tellez, Tommy Pham, Bryan De La Cruz and Isiah Kiner-Falefa have all surfaced on MLB playoff rosters, but as bench or reserve pieces for contenders that can afford to use them in supporting roles rather than leaning on them every day.
For the Pirates, that difference goes to the heart of Ben Cheringtons roster-building problem. Pittsburgh spent recent seasons asking too much of players who, on better teams, fit more naturally as complementary depth, and the result is a club that finished with a winning record in 2026 but still stayed home when the postseason began. The drought rolls on, and the sight of those former regulars in October only sharpens the question of whether the Pirates have been miscast by the very pieces they were counting on. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Fans Just Got An October Reminder That Stings
Postseason baseball can expose the gap between a good regular season and a true October stage, and Houstons opening game in the American League Wild Card Series offered a reminder of how quickly the mood can turn. The Astros drew a crowd of 34,011 at Daikin Park for their matchup with the White Sox, but some fans still let the home team hear it, a jarring scene for a club that has spent years expecting deep October runs.
For Pittsburgh, it is the kind of scoreboard comparison that stings a little more than usual. The Pirates finished the regular season with a better record than Houston, yet they are watching the playoffs from home because of the realities of divisional standings, while the Astros are still playing in October despite their own uneven moment with the crowd. It is a clean example of how one team can end up in the tournament and another can miss out, even when the records do not fully tell the same story. [Read more 🡒]