Mitch Keller’s season ended the way too many bad stretches in baseball do: abruptly, on a rainy Sunday in Cincinnati, with his body telling him enough was enough.
By then, the veteran right-hander was already fighting through a year that never really felt right. He labored through the first four months, admitted he was fatigued, and still thought there might be a path to a strong finish.
Instead, in his 22nd start, he felt tightness that got worse as the afternoon wore on. That was it.
His day was done, and so was his season.
Keller wound up on the 60-day injured list on Aug. 3 with a right arm teres major muscle injury and finished the year with a 5.29 ERA. The longest-tenured Pirate then spent the final two months watching from the dugout as Pittsburgh finished off its best season since 2018.
“It was kind of a weird year, honestly. I didn't really feel like myself or feel 100% the whole year,” Keller said. “So I was just not trying to be too hard on myself, just because I didn't feel like myself or the best I could.”
“I think there was definitely some positives throughout the year, early in the year, and then just some learning things to go through. Health-wise and stuff hindered my ability to be the best I could be out there. So I'm just looking forward to next year being 100% healthy and just being on a confident track.”
The injury itself is one of those uncommon pitcher ailments that usually comes with a lot of mystery and not much comfort. Keller said the pain felt like cramping or tightness in the armpit area.
The teres major, sometimes called the “lat's little brother,” helps rotate the shoulder and ties into the mechanics a pitcher needs to stay strong and repeatable. Keller is believed to have suffered a Grade 3 strain, meaning the muscle tore off the humerus.
He didn’t have surgery. He shut it down for the year instead, and by the end of the season he said he felt completely healthy and was moving in the right direction strength-wise.
Even before the injury, though, Keller knew the year wasn’t trending well. He said he couldn’t identify one exact moment when the problem hit, but when he looked back on the season, he saw mechanical spots he had reached before and didn’t have in 2026.
For the Pirates, Keller’s story now stretches beyond one lost season. He has been part of the organization for a decade after being taken in the second round in 2014 out of Xavier High School in Cedar Rapids, Iowa. He debuted at 23 in 2019, then reached a career-high 194 1/3 innings and an All-Star nod in 2023.
Ahead of his second straight Opening Day start in 2024, Keller signed a five-year, $77 million extension, the biggest contract the Pirates have ever given a pitcher. The deal climbs as it goes, from $16.9 million in 2026 to $18.4 million in 2027 and $20.4 million in 2028.
That matters because Pittsburgh’s rotation is getting more expensive around him, too. Paul Skenes and Jared Jones are both arbitration-eligible for the first time, and each had strong seasons alongside Braxton Ashcraft and Bubba Chandler.
So Keller remains important for more than just innings. He’s a veteran presence in the rotation and in the clubhouse, and the Pirates need a sharper version of him moving forward.
“First and foremost is just getting healthy and being in a spot where I feel like I can make some good improvements out there,” Keller said. “It was a grind of a season for me in a lot of ways, but just trying to find the positives in it and then getting healthy and just being strong for next year.”
In Other News...
Pirates Suddenly Have A Shortstop Puzzle They Can't Ignore
The Pirates suddenly find themselves with a good problem on the infield side: a wave of shortstop talent that gives the organization real depth, but also a looming question about where everyone is going to play. Johan De Los Santos, Konnor Griffin, Wyatt Sanford and Aiden Ruiz all sit in that pipeline, giving Pittsburgh multiple young options at a position where development is usually as much about opportunity as it is about skill.
De Los Santos added to his stock with a strong 2026 season that earned him Rookie-Level Player of the Year honors, and the organization now has to map out how to keep his progress moving without clogging the path for the others. For a club trying to build toward the majors, the challenge is no longer finding shortstops - it is making sure there are enough innings, at-bats and defensive reps to go around. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers And Rays Just Put A Harsh Spotlight On The Pirates
Major League Baseballs latest economic proposal has put clubs like the Pirates under an even brighter spotlight. The idea on the table includes a salary floor for the leagues lower spenders, a reminder that Pittsburgh is among the teams that would need to push payroll higher if the system changes. But the uncomfortable part for the Pirates is that this conversation is no longer only about how much they spend. It is also about what they have done with the money they already have on hand.
The Brewers and Rays have shown that a tight budget does not have to mean a dead end, with both organizations getting all the way to the 2026 World Series. Pittsburgh has not come close to matching that kind of progress, and that is what makes the franchises place in this debate so stark. The gap is not just financial, it is organizational, and until the Pirates prove they can build a winner with the resources they control, the payroll argument will keep sounding like an excuse rather than an explanation. [Read more 🡒]
Paul Skenes May Have One Fix That Changes Everything For Pirates
Paul Skenes went from Cy Young winner to a pitcher looking for answers in 2026, and the clues point to something more specific than just a rough stretch. His fastball sat a little differently, his changeup lost some of its bite, and the overall package did not look like the one that made him one of baseballs most overpowering arms in 2025. Skenes has already pointed to fatigue and the World Baseball Classic as possible reasons, but the sharper evidence suggests the problem may have started with the way he was delivering the ball.
The most intriguing part is how one subtle adjustment could ripple through everything else he throws. A slightly higher arm slot may have changed the movement on his changeup enough to make it far less effective, especially when left-handed hitters were in the box, which helps explain why the pitch no longer played like a true weapon. For the Pirates, the idea that a mechanical fix could restore that edge makes this one of the more important storylines around their ace heading into his next turn. [Read more 🡒]