The Pittsburgh Pirates need more from their lineup, and the pressure is especially landing on Bryan Reynolds.
The veteran left fielder has gone cold since the All-Star break, and the numbers have turned sharply against him. In 24 second-half games in 2026, Reynolds is hitting .202/.279/.298 for an OPS of .577.
That slump included an 0-for-4 night in the Pirates’ 2-0 loss to the Miami Marlins at loanDepot Park on Aug. 11.
For a 31-year-old hitter the Pirates count on, that production simply isn’t enough. Reynolds has not brought much power during this stretch, with only one home run - one that came two weeks ago - after launching 14 in his first 97 games.
The issues go beyond power. His plate discipline, which was a strength earlier in the year, has slipped, dropping from 14.69% to 9.62%. His strikeout rate has also climbed, moving from 22.27% to 32.69%.
That downturn has come at the same time the Pirates’ offense as a whole has fallen off. The club hit .263/.342/.426 for an OPS of .768 in the first half, then slid to .226/.297/.344 for an OPS of .641 in the second half, a decline of 127 points.
Reynolds has felt that drag in his own stat line, too. He has only four RBI, and the lack of traffic around him has made it harder to cash in. When the rest of the order is struggling, his at-bats are affected as well.
It’s a stark change from what Reynolds gave Pittsburgh before the break. He was excellent in the first half, batting .283/.400/.477 for an OPS of .877, with 99 hits, 22 doubles, two triples, 14 home runs, 59 RBI and 62 walks to 94 strikeouts.
Those numbers put him among the best outfielders in baseball, even though he still didn’t make the All-Star team - which would have been the third All-Star selection of his career.
Reynolds opened the year strong, posting an .811 OPS in April, then .932 in May and .911 in June. The production fell off in July, when he had a .736 OPS, and it has dropped further in August, where he sits at .615.
Overall, 2026 has still been a better season for Reynolds than 2025, with improved contact and better plate discipline pointing toward one of his strongest years. But the Pirates need the version of him that was carrying the offense earlier in the season.
That means help from the rest of the lineup, too. Pittsburgh needs more from Brandon Lowe, Spencer Horwitz, Nick Gonzales, Esmerlyn Valdez and others. The Pirates would also benefit from getting center fielder Oneil Cruz back from injury this month and eventually adding both Konnor Griffin and Ryan O'Hearn in September.
Reynolds has to hit better than he has lately, but a stronger lineup around him would give him the best chance to do it.
In Other News...
Pirates Fans Face The Real Question Behind Pittsburghs Spending Debate
The Pirates long-running spending debate is about more than just how much money gets pushed into the roster. Since Ben Cherington took over as general manager in 2019, the club has piled up losing seasons and still hasnt reached the playoffs, which has only sharpened the frustration around a front office that has not turned payroll decisions into on-field progress. Recent roster moves have only added to the conversation, because they show how even a little more spending does not automatically translate into a better team.
A salary cap and floor would change the financial framework around the sport and give clubs like Pittsburgh a different set of constraints and opportunities, but it would not answer the bigger question facing Pirates fans. The real issue is whether better management can be trusted to make smarter choices with more resources, because increased payroll alone has already proven it does not guarantee success. [Read more 🡒]
Oneil Cruz Is Forcing A Tough Pirates Decision At The Worst Time
Oneil Cruz is back on the field with Double-A Altoona as he works his way back from fractures in his left hand, and the Pirates are keeping a close eye on every step. With Pittsburgh trying to find some offensive rhythm, the timing of his rehab assignment matters almost as much as the results, because Cruz is one of the few players on the roster who can change a game with his bat, his speed and his defense in center field.
The concern, of course, is that he has not yet looked fully in sync at the plate during this minor league tune-up, which leaves the Pirates weighing whether to rush him back into a lineup that badly needs a lift or give him more time to round into form. It is a delicate call at the worst possible moment for a club already searching for answers, and how they handle Cruz now could shape both their immediate offense and the bigger picture in center field. [Read more 🡒]