Ben Cherington walked into the GM meetings in Las Vegas and, whether he meant to or not, made the Pirates’ winter a lot more interesting.
The Pittsburgh general manager was asked a question that has followed this franchise for years: how much money does the club really have to work with? His answer was blunt enough to raise expectations.
“I don’t feel like we’re hamstrung or constrained,” Cherington told reporters, including Colin Beazley of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
He did add context. The Pirates are in a different financial spot than they were a year ago, with existing contracts and a bigger arbitration class shaping the way they approach the offseason. Cherington also pointed to the club’s priority.
“But that part’s not changing. That’s our priority,” he said.
That’s the part that matters. If Pittsburgh says it has flexibility, then the usual built-in excuse for a quiet winter starts to disappear. The front office can’t lean on payroll limitations as a shield if the GM is publicly saying money isn’t the roadblock.
There are real costs on the books, to be sure. Paul Skenes is entering his first year of arbitration eligibility.
Several other players are due raises. Bryan Reynolds and Mitch Keller are already on established contracts that count as meaningful commitments by Pirates standards.
Then there’s Brandon Lowe, whose future is still unsettled after Pittsburgh gave him a $23.15 million qualifying offer. He has until November 17 to accept or decline, and Cherington said conversations with Lowe’s representatives have continued since the season ended.
Those are fair factors to weigh when building a payroll. But paying more for players who are getting better is part of the job.
The Pirates went 82-80 in 2026 and finished with their first winning season since 2018. Skenes has become one of baseball’s most valuable young pitchers.
Konnor Griffin has emerged as a foundational piece. The club has more major league talent than it did a couple of years ago, and that naturally comes with a higher price tag.
What Pittsburgh can’t do is celebrate the development while treating the financial consequences of that development like a reason to stand still.
The roster still has obvious issues. The offense improved sharply from 2025, but its production tailed off badly in the second half. The team also continued to struggle against left-handed pitching, and the bullpen needed multiple midseason fixes.
Those problems won’t solve themselves because the Pirates finally posted a winning record. And simply bringing back familiar names shouldn’t be sold as a major offseason win.
Keeping Lowe would help, but it wouldn’t automatically make the 2027 club better than the 2026 version. If he leaves, Pittsburgh has an even bigger hole to fill while still trying to clean up the rest of the roster.
Cherington has said the Pirates aren’t locking themselves into one area of the roster, and that they’re open to upgrades through trades or free agency wherever the opportunities show up. He also said, “The only thing we’re focused on is improvement... we’ll pursue that through free agency and trade.”
He added another line about the front office’s approach: “Be urgent but not in a rush. Be ready.”
That’s sensible enough. But flexibility only means something if it turns into action. And with an MLB lockout expected to begin December 1, Pittsburgh’s window to make moves before everything potentially freezes is shrinking.
Cherington doesn’t control the labor situation, and he shouldn’t force a bad deal just to beat the calendar. Still, the uncertainty makes decisiveness more important, not less.
The bigger point is simple: there’s a difference between saying the Pirates aren’t financially boxed in and proving ownership is willing to pay for real upgrades. Cherington’s comments don’t mean Bob Nutting has opened the vault. They do, however, set a standard.
For years, Pirates fans have heard the same explanations about payroll, market size and the realities of small-market baseball. This time, the GM said the organization isn’t hamstrung.
Now the front office has to back that up.
In Other News...
Pirates Could Be Settling For Less Power At A Bad Time
The Pirates are being linked to a cheaper infield option as the market starts to sort itself out, with J.P. Crawford viewed as a possible fit if the club decides to shop for value rather than chase the top of the second-base market. Crawford brings a disciplined approach at the plate and enough defensive versatility to help in different spots, which makes him the kind of player front offices often circle when they want steadier production without a major financial commitment.
The catch is that this kind of move would come with a clear offensive tradeoff, especially at a time when Pittsburgh could use more punch in the lineup. Brandon Lowe is the bigger bat in the conversation and has been the more dangerous power threat, while Crawfords left-handed profile may not do much to solve the Pirates issues against left-handed pitching, leaving the club to weigh fit against firepower as the offseason unfolds. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Need To Fix A Pitching Problem Fast
The Pirates are heading into the offseason with a clear need to rebalance their pitching staff, and the focus has quickly turned to left-handed help. According to a report from The Athletic, the club is looking at both free agency and the trade market as it tries to add more balance before the winter really gets moving.
The timing matters because the front office wants to make some progress before the MLB lockout deadline complicates the calendar, and the list of possible fits is already taking shape. Among the names being discussed are Foster Griffin, Trevor Rogers, Robbie Ray, Alex Vesia and JoJo Romero, giving Pittsburgh a range of options as it tries to solve a problem that has become hard to ignore. [Read more 🡒]
Pirates Offseason Plans Just Got Tied To Mitch Kellers Status
Mitch Kellers season ended early, but the Pirates are now getting a much better read on what comes next for one of their most important arms. General manager Ben Cherington said Keller is basically recovered and has resumed throwing, which gives Pittsburgh a more stable starting point as it shapes an offseason that already figures to be influenced by the makeup of its rotation and the demands of its home park.
The bigger roster question is how the Pirates balance a staff that leans heavily right-handed. Adding left-handed pitching is on the table, and Kellers progress helps clarify how aggressive the club can be in addressing that need. For a team trying to build a more versatile staff, his status matters not just for next season, but for the way the entire pitching plan is being framed. [Read more 🡒]