The Pittsburgh Penguins are staring at a familiar kind of uncomfortable question this season: what comes next, and who stays for it?
A 7-11-2 start has left Pittsburgh second last in the Eastern Conference, and after the club reached the playoffs for the first time in three seasons last year, general manager Kyle Dubas is talking openly about a younger future. That naturally puts some of the franchise’s biggest names in the conversation, including Evgenii Malkin, Kris Letang and Sidney Crosby.
Dubas said Wednesday that the three veterans can’t be treated like ordinary roster decisions.
“I think with the three of them, it’s such a unique circumstance in terms of all that they’ve done for the organization and for the team,” Dubas said at his press conference on Wednesday. “I think that because of that, they have to be handled, just very openly, differently than you would handle almost any other veteran that you came in contact with. I don’t know that there will ever be a circumstance like that in the league again.”
He also made clear that Crosby’s wishes will matter as the Penguins navigate the final stretch of the captain’s career. Crosby, 39, is in the last season of a two-year, $17.4 million deal and can become an unrestricted free agent after the 2026-27 season. He also holds a full no-movement clause, giving him control over any trade destination if that ever becomes part of the discussion.
For now, though, Crosby is not moving quickly on any decision about his future in Pittsburgh.
“Sidney has been in Pittsburgh for over 20 years, and he isn’t in any rush to make a decision,” Crosby’s agent Pat Brisson told TSN Hockey Insider Pierre LeBrun on Thursday. “Kyle will do what he feels is best for the organization in the meantime.”
Crosby’s production remains strong, even if the pace is down from his usual standard. The 5-foot-11 centre has six goals and 13 points in 20 games this season, putting him on track for 25 goals and 54 points. That would be his lowest output in a full season since 2011-12, when concussion and neck injuries cost him significant time.
Even so, he keeps adding to a resume that already has him past Mario Lemieux on the Penguins’ all-time scoring list. Crosby has 660 goals and 1,774 points in 1,440 games, and he is still trying to extend an NHL record by remaining a point-per-game player for a 22nd straight season.
After Dubas’ comments, Crosby’s response was brief and steady.
“I mean, that’ not really any different than it’s been,” Crosby said of Dubas’ plans on Wednesday. “I don’t think that changes anything.”
The Penguins are set to face the St. Louis Blues on Thursday night.
In Other News...
Penguins Nearly Made A Franchise-Changing Swing Before Everything Shifted
Before the Penguins season turned into a reset, Kyle Dubas was at least exploring a much bigger swing. He had pursued a trade for Jason Robertson from the Dallas Stars, a move that would have brought one of the leagues most dynamic scorers to Pittsburgh and changed the conversation around the roster in a hurry.
Instead, the teams direction has since shifted toward selling veteran pieces and leaning into a rebuild after the rough start. Dallas kept Jason Robertson on a one-year contract, while Pittsburgh ended up with his younger brother, Nick Robertson, who has provided a useful spark with seven goals in 20 games this season. [Read more 🡒]
Senators Trade Push Suddenly Centers On A Familiar Name
The Ottawa Senators are again circling the Penguins roster as the trade market starts to take shape, and this time the focus has landed on a name Pittsburgh fans know well. Reports say Ottawa is looking to add help up front, with general manager Steve Staios exploring ways to bring in a top-six forward, and two of the Penguins who have surfaced in that conversation are Rickard Rakell and Bryan Rust.
There is also a familiar wrinkle to the discussion in Erik Karlsson, who remains a pending free agent and could become part of any broader deal. For now, nothing has been finalized, but the overlap between Ottawas needs and Pittsburghs veteran pieces makes this one worth watching closely as the market develops. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Fans Still Can't Escape The Jake Guentzel Trade Debate
More than two and a half years after Jake Guentzel was moved as part of Kyle Dubas rebuilding push, the trade still hangs over the Penguins every time the conversation turns to what Pittsburgh gave up and what it got back. The deal brought in a package of prospects and picks, including Villie Koivunen, Harrison Brunicke, Tommy Novak, Markus Ruck and a 2027 fourth-round selection, but the return has not done much to quiet the noise around one of the franchises most debated recent moves.
There are reasons for optimism in the group, with Novak and Brunicke showing some promise, but the broader picture has not tilted in Pittsburghs favor so far. Koivunen, in particular, has not yet lived up to the kind of expectations that would help soften the loss of Guentzel, which is why the discussion keeps resurfacing whenever Penguins fans revisit the rebuild and ask whether this was the right price to pay. [Read more 🡒]
