Senators Trade Push Suddenly Centers On A Familiar Name

Could Erik Karlsson be on his way back to Ottawa as the Senators and Penguins explore a blockbuster trade involving top talent?

The Ottawa Senators are expected to be buyers, and the Pittsburgh Penguins may have exactly the kind of pieces they’re willing to move. Multiple reports have tied the two clubs to a possible in-season trade, with Erik Karlsson emerging as the name that could send things back to Ottawa.

Karlsson is a pending free agent, and the Penguins’ direction makes the fit easy to read. With his age and contract status, Pittsburgh is said to be ready to rebuild and looking to move the mobile defenceman for future considerations. There’s also a personal wrinkle: Karlsson’s wife is from the area, and although he has a no-movement clause, word is he’s open to heading back north to Ottawa.

TSN’s Pierre LeBrun addressed the situation on Thursday and pointed to the Senators’ search for offense:

According to my information, Senators general manager Steve Staios continues to make calls around the league, gauging how the market is shaping up for a top-six forward-an elite player to bolster the offense. [...]

Rickard Rakell and Bryan Rust are two such players. Both have one year remaining on their contracts beyond this season.

They are among several names the Senators are keeping an eye on-in fact, they have quite an extensive list.

That leaves Ottawa with more than one possible route. Karlsson could be part of the discussion, but so could one of Pittsburgh’s wingers, since the Senators are shopping for a top-six scoring winger and help on the blue line. On paper, the two teams line up well as trade partners.

Rakell already turned down a move to the Chicago Blackhawks, who were on his eight-team no-trade list, so Ottawa would have to see whether it even qualifies as a destination. Rust, meanwhile, has been dealing with injuries for much of the season and appears likely to be moved before the deadline.

For now, the connection between Ottawa and Pittsburgh is one to watch closely. The ingredients are there for a deal with real potential.

In Other News...

Penguins Nearly Made A Franchise-Changing Swing Before Everything Shifted

Before the Penguins season turned into a reset, Kyle Dubas was at least exploring a much bigger swing. He had pursued a trade for Jason Robertson from the Dallas Stars, a move that would have brought one of the leagues most dynamic scorers to Pittsburgh and changed the conversation around the roster in a hurry.

Instead, the teams direction has since shifted toward selling veteran pieces and leaning into a rebuild after the rough start. Dallas kept Jason Robertson on a one-year contract, while Pittsburgh ended up with his younger brother, Nick Robertson, who has provided a useful spark with seven goals in 20 games this season. [Read more 🡒]

Sidney Crosby Just Became The Biggest Question In Pittsburgh

The Penguins slow start has only sharpened the questions hanging over the franchise, with a 7-11-2 record leaving them near the bottom of the Eastern Conference standings. General manager Kyle Dubas has made it clear the organization is focused on getting younger and building for the future, a direction that could eventually put longtime core pieces like Evgenii Malkin, Kris Letang and Sidney Crosby into the center of trade chatter.

Crosbys future is the one that matters most in Pittsburgh, and his camp is not treating it like an urgent decision. His agent said Crosby is not rushing to sort out what comes next, while Dubas has indicated he will respect Crosbys wishes as the captain moves through the final years of his career. For a team trying to balance loyalty to its icons with the reality of a retool, that leaves the biggest question in Pittsburgh still very much open. [Read more 🡒]

Penguins Fans Still Can't Escape The Jake Guentzel Trade Debate

More than two and a half years after Jake Guentzel was moved as part of Kyle Dubas rebuilding push, the trade still hangs over the Penguins every time the conversation turns to what Pittsburgh gave up and what it got back. The deal brought in a package of prospects and picks, including Villie Koivunen, Harrison Brunicke, Tommy Novak, Markus Ruck and a 2027 fourth-round selection, but the return has not done much to quiet the noise around one of the franchises most debated recent moves.

There are reasons for optimism in the group, with Novak and Brunicke showing some promise, but the broader picture has not tilted in Pittsburghs favor so far. Koivunen, in particular, has not yet lived up to the kind of expectations that would help soften the loss of Guentzel, which is why the discussion keeps resurfacing whenever Penguins fans revisit the rebuild and ask whether this was the right price to pay. [Read more 🡒]