The Penguins may have left training camp with more questions than answers, and the biggest one sits right at the heart of their roster construction: what happens when the kids look ready, but the jobs are still clogged by veterans?
That tension ran through three quick days of camp and now hangs over Pittsburgh as preseason games begin Monday. The club has one open forward spot, a need on the left side of defense, and a pile of depth options trying to sort themselves out. At the same time, several prospects are showing enough to make the organization’s delay feel harder to justify.
The names at the center of it are the ones fans have been waiting on: Rutger McGroarty, Owen Pickering, Harrison Brunicke, Avery Hayes, and Tristan Broz. They’ve already spent time in Wilkes-Barre/Scranton, and the sense around camp is that they are past the point of simply collecting more AHL reps. An NHL executive told PHN the decision point comes when a player has done all he can at that level.
“I mean once he’s accomplished everything he can there, then you definitely have to graduate him. Then he’s not developing any more. He has to get new challenges.”
That’s the bind for Pittsburgh. The prospects are not just waiting anymore, and the camp itself only sharpened that reality. The veterans they’re competing with have not exactly made the path easy, while the younger players kept showing enough to suggest they may already be beyond the lower level.
McGroarty, for his part, took the shortened camp as a chance rather than a setback.
“Yeah, I mean, it’s nice (to have a shortened preseason) because then you don’t get as many chances, and if you do well at the chances you get, and then it makes their decision tougher,” McGroarty told PHN.
That optimism is one way to frame it. Another is that the Penguins have built themselves into a corner. Assistant general manager Jason Spezza, speaking Thursday, made it clear the opening-night roster is not likely to be the final version.
“We know we want to inject youth into the lineup. We know we have to,” said Spezza. “We have to make sure we do it when the guys are ready and when they’re going to help the team, so I think it’ll be - we’re all interested, just as you are, to kind of watch and see where everybody’s at with young players.”
That leaves the organization balancing two truths at once: the best path for the future may involve getting these players into the lineup now, while the current roster still leans toward older options. Pickering turned in a strong camp.
McGroarty was sturdy throughout. Brunicke also fits the group of waiver-exempt young players who look like they belong in the conversation.
The issue is that the most obvious answers may not be the ones the Penguins can immediately use.
The camp itself moved fast. By the end of the third day, the work was essentially done, and the team shifts into preseason mode before a more pared-down practice group on Friday. The result was a camp packed with storylines, but without the kind of clean resolution that usually clarifies a roster battle.
There were other notes worth filing away, starting with Olivier Okuliar. The 26-year-old was injured Saturday, and it appeared to be more than a minor day-to-day issue.
Before that, he had looked the part. His hard hit on defenseman Declan Carlile on Day 1 set a tone, and in another camp he might have been in real position to push for a fourth-line role.
Not every young player left camp with the same momentum. Ville Koivunen still looked hesitant against NHL competition and has yet to fully assert himself. The preseason games now loom as a major test for him and for the organization’s patience.
The same pressure applies to Kaedan Korczak and Carlile. Neither new defenseman separated himself in practice, and both will need a stronger showing in games if they want to avoid sliding into the category of just another option, behind Parker Wotherspoon and Ryan Shea. That leads to the obvious follow-up: what was the point of trading Wotherspoon and letting Shea walk if the answer is now Trevor van Riemsdyk at $8 million?
There was one clear upward arrow in camp, though. Ben Kindel kept taking noticeable steps.
He looks bigger, stronger, and more confident, and his skating has come a long way since July 2025. PHN said it has never seen a player progress so quickly over the course of a year.
The top nine could still become interesting if Nick Robertson can mesh with Sidney Crosby, and there are a few combinations that could give the Penguins a different look up front.
Andrei Kuzmenko-Ben Kindel-Bryan Rust
Egor Chinakhov-Tommy Novak-Evgeni Malkin
On the blue line, Erik Karlsson appears to be in line for the version of himself the Penguins saw in the second half of last season. The talent stood out in camp the way great players usually do: no deep dive required, no explanation needed.
The goaltending battle remains unsettled. Sergei Murashov has a slight edge over Joel Blomqvist, but it’s far too early to call that race.
In Other News...
Penguins Next Wave Is Already Pushing For Bigger Camp Roles
Three days into Penguins training camp, the early shape of this roster is starting to reveal itself, and it is not just the veterans drawing attention. Liam Ruck has already moved up into the NHL group, a small but telling sign that the next wave of players is pressing to be seen in a bigger role. For a team still sorting out its depth and internal competition, those practice group shifts matter as much as any preseason headline.
The larger league chatter around the Penguins has also been busy, with trade talk swirling elsewhere and familiar names like Tristan Jarry part of the broader conversation about how teams are recalibrating for the season ahead. But the most relevant story in Pittsburgh is still the one unfolding on the ice every day at camp, where younger players are forcing the staff to notice them and making each lineup decision feel a little less settled. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins First Preseason Lineup Opens A Big Opportunity For Camp Players
The Penguins have their first preseason lineup in place for the opener against the Sabres at PPG Paints Arena, and it gives a good early look at how the camp battles are shaping up. The roster blends forwards, defensemen and goaltenders, with the staff set to trim two skaters before puck drop, a reminder that even in September, every shift carries some weight for players trying to carve out a longer stay.
For a group still trying to make an impression, this is the kind of game that can matter beyond the score. It is also the first chance for fans to see the new camp mix in a live setting, with SportsNet Pittsburgh carrying the broadcast and the Penguins official radio station providing the call, as the preseason begins to sort out who gets more runway and who is suddenly watching from the sideline. [Read more 🡒]
Sabres Hit Serious Hellebuyck Trade Roadblock Over One Roster Concern
While Buffalo was running into a roadblock in its pursuit of Connor Hellebuyck, the Penguins kept a very different focus as they work through their own future business. Pittsburgh is taking a patient approach on contract extensions for Sidney Crosby and Erik Karlsson, and for now there are no negotiations underway even as the team keeps the lines of communication open.
For a franchise balancing an older core with the need to map out what comes next, that slower pace is hardly surprising. The Penguins have made clear they are not forcing the issue at the moment, which leaves both extensions in a holding pattern while the broader goalie and roster chatter around the league continues to swirl. [Read more 🡒]