The Penguins are deep enough into the season now that the picture is hard to ignore: this is a team headed toward a sell-off.
After 20 games, Pittsburgh sits at 7-11-2, which leaves Dan Muse’s club 15th in the Eastern Conference and clinging to a spot ahead of only the Columbus Blue Jackets, who have two fewer points and two fewer games played. The Penguins are tracking toward 67 points, and their three regulation wins are better than just two teams, Columbus and the Vancouver Canucks.
Strip away the 7-0 season-opening win, and the goal differential drops to the NHL’s fifth-worst. Dom Luszczyszyn’s projections put their postseason odds at 11 percent.
So the real questions are no longer whether Kyle Dubas will sell, but who goes, when they go, and what he gets back.
Erik Karlsson is the clearest name on the board, and probably the biggest one too. Before the season, Dubas and Karlsson talked, and it became clear that Karlsson would not sign a new contract before reaching free agency next summer.
The Penguins like him, and he likes Pittsburgh. From conversations with Karlsson, it’s clear he and his family have settled in, he enjoys playing for the team, and he has built close friendships with the Penguins’ core players.
Still, the fit is only going to last so long. Karlsson turns 37 in May, making him the fourth-oldest player on a roster that already leans heavily on Sidney Crosby (39), Evgeni Malkin (40) and Kris Letang (39).
Pittsburgh needs to get younger, not older, and it is not built to chase a championship right now. Dubas could bring back a strong return for the three-time Norris Trophy winner, but there is one major wrinkle: Karlsson has a full no-movement clause, so he controls the process.
There will be teams he’d consider and teams he wouldn’t. He is not expected to balk at going to Canada, where he has already made a massive amount of money and still owns a home in Ottawa.
He has a reputation for loving his money, his lifestyle and his Norris trophies, and for not being overly consumed by winning. But that picture is incomplete.
The more I get to know him, the more I realize how badly he wants to win a championship. It means far more to him than people realize.
If Dubas lines up a deal with a real Stanley Cup contender, Karlsson would likely go along with it. He knows he is not coming back next season anyway.
That is not how he imagined this ending. He wanted the Penguins to make one last push while he was here, and he has said he fits “like a glove” with the organization.
In a lot of ways, that has been true. Pittsburgh has always valued offense, star power and the kind of wild, high-scoring hockey that ends 7-5 instead of 2-1.
That is Karlsson’s game too. But the Penguins’ Cup window is closed, and it is not opening again anytime soon.
Karlsson knows that, and when the time comes, he is not expected to make Dubas’ job especially difficult.
Even with some looseness in his game this season, he is still producing at a point-per-game pace and looks physically strong. That should create a healthy market for him.
Bryan Rust and Rickard Rakell remain in the same bucket they were in before Rust’s injury, which will keep him out for a few more weeks. Dubas is open to moving both players and has been for a while, but he is not going to give them away.
From the Penguins’ perspective, both are useful players on good contracts, and neither is a rental. Each is signed through the end of the 2027-28 season.
Rust has no trade protection. Rakell can block a move to eight of the NHL’s 31 other teams. At least one of them should be moved by the March 1 deadline, and I would be surprised if both are dealt, especially if Crosby is back next season and the Penguins still want someone to skate with him.
Crosby, as always, is the biggest variable. Everything is in his hands.
If he wants to stay, the Penguins will make it work. If he wants to retire, he will retire.
If he wants out, Dubas will trade him.
Crosby has always said he wants to play only for Pittsburgh, and until he says otherwise, there is no reason to doubt that. What is clear is that he has never been on a team this bad, at least not since his rookie year, and he has never had this much trouble producing. He is on pace for 55 points.
People inside the organization believe he will be back next season, but nobody really knows, because Crosby himself does not seem fully sure what he wants to do. Those inside views, like the others in this story, were shared on condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the subject.
Malkin is in a similar place in the sense that the Penguins are willing to let him finish the season in Pittsburgh, but if he wants a move, Dubas would do it. Unlike Crosby, Malkin does not have a lifetime arrangement with the team.
Letang is a different case. I have long thought Dubas would trade him if he could, but there does not appear to be any real market for him because of his age, contract, injury history and declining play.
There are also a few prospect notes worth watching. Several team sources are puzzled that Dubas has not brought 24-year-old forward Avery Hayes up to Pittsburgh full time, and there are plenty of believers in him inside the organization.
The Penguins understand that 22-year-old goaltender Sergei Murashov is going to allow the occasional rough goal, like he did in Chicago and late against the Ottawa Senators on Saturday, but they believe those mistakes will become less frequent over time. Owen Pickering could surface in Pittsburgh at some point, though the sense is that he will not end up with a major role in the future.
This regime did not draft him, and his 4 points in 12 games with Wilkes-Barre this season have not exactly forced the issue. Harrison Brunicke has been uneven while dealing with an injury, but the Penguins remain high on the 20-year-old defenseman and simply do not want to rush him.
In Other News...
Sidney Crosby Just Became Pittsburghs Biggest Offseason Question
The offseason conversation around Sidney Crosby has gone far beyond routine speculation, and it now sits at the center of Pittsburghs biggest question. Josh Yohe of The Athletic reported that the Penguins are willing to entertain the possibility of moving Crosby, Evgeni Malkin or Kris Letang if any of the three veteran stars want a change, a striking stance for a franchise built around that core for so long.
For Pittsburgh, the real tension is not just what the organization is open to, but how much uncertainty remains around the captain himself. Malkin is reportedly open to a trade, while Letang is viewed as less likely to move because of his contract and declining performance, leaving Crosby as the franchise-defining name hanging over everything the Penguins do this summer. Most inside the organization still expect him back, but the lack of clarity is what makes this story linger. [Read more 🡒]
Rickard Rakell Trade Talk Just Hit A Major Penguins Roadblock
Rickard Rakell has been one of the more intriguing names to watch as the Penguins look ahead to the March 1 trade deadline, and for good reason. He has produced six goals and five assists in 20 games this season, and with Pittsburgh expected to at least listen on several veterans, his name naturally surfaced in trade chatter.
One of the teams linked to him was Chicago, but the path to a deal ran into a built-in obstacle. Rakells contract runs through 2027-28, and his no-trade protection gives him control over where he can go, which complicates any move Pittsburgh might try to make as the deadline approaches. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Are Making Crosby Look Older Than He Really Is
The Penguins uneven start since that opening-night win has left Sidney Crosby carrying more of the conversation than usual, and not in the way this franchise is accustomed to. Pittsburgh has managed only four regulation wins in 19 games, a skid that has made even a familiar captain look a little more mortal as the club searches for answers around him.
Crosbys scoring has dipped below his usual standard, but the bigger issue is the environment around him, with injuries and lineup shuffling making it harder for Dan Muse to get the kind of consistency the team needs. There are still signs the offense is functioning better than the results suggest, which is why the Penguins problem feels less like a decline in Crosby himself and more like a roster that is asking him to do too much while the rest of the structure catches up. [Read more 🡒]
