Kyle Dubas came into the summer trying to speed up the Penguins’ rebuild, but the big swing never landed. The result is a Pittsburgh roster that looks mostly unchanged, only older by a few months, while the prospect stockpile keeps getting deeper.
That’s the tension hanging over this team right now. The Penguins did not land the kind of trade that would have jolted the rebuild forward, even after reliable national reporting said they had gained traction in their pursuit of Jason Robertson. But the asking price kept climbing around the league, with other teams paying out top-10 picks and other premium pieces, and Dubas simply did not have enough to get it done.
A video released by the Ottawa Senators added another detail to the picture: the Penguins offered a roster player for the 25th overall pick. Ottawa GM Steve Staois was tempted, but not enough to move the pick the Senators had acquired in the Brady Tkachuk trade.
So Pittsburgh was left holding the same basic big-league group, while the future load kept growing. The 2025 draft class alone became a massive 13-player haul, and that group now joins an already busy pipeline of younger talent that is moving quickly.
At the top of that prospect conversation are first-rounders Bill Zonnon and Will Horcoff, plus 2025 11th overall pick Ben Kindel, who already has a Pittsburgh address. Beyond them, the class includes a handful of intriguing late-round bets that Penguins fans have already attached their hopes to, from seventh-rounder Kale Dach to fifth-rounders Travis Hayes and Ryan Miller, and third-rounders Charlie Trethewey and goalie Gabriel D’Aigle.
The numbers are starting to pile up in a way that creates its own problem. An unofficial count, not including current prospects Ville Koivunen, Rutger McGroarty, or Owen Pickering, puts as many as 22 prospects in the minor league system next year. That is more than a full team, even before any veterans are accounted for.
And that raises a practical question about what the organization will even do with all of them. After the Wheeling Nailers situation this offseason, it would be a strange twist if the Penguins eventually needed a second AHL or ECHL partner just to make room for everyone.
The most important part, though, is that the prospect group is better than a lot of Penguins fans seem to think. The forward pool does not yet feature a sure thing at the top line, but Horcoff and Zonnon have real upside, and so do Liam Ruck and Markus Ruck if they develop the way Pittsburgh hopes. Those four, along with Kindel, Egor Chinakhov, and Koivunen, shape the future of the forward group, even if history says only some of them will hit and only one or two may fully become what their talent suggests.
The blue line has its own timeline. Harrison Brunicke, Kaedan Korczak, and Pickering are the immediate names to watch, while Peyton Kettles, Brady Peddle, and Charlie Trethewey are the next wave. The expectation is that the second wave starts reaching the NHL in 2027-28, with more coming later in 2029.
Brunicke stands out as the closest thing the Penguins have to a ready-made rookie defenseman, looking more prepared than any Pittsburgh blue-liner since John Marino in 2020. Korczak, now 25, has already shown he can play in the NHL. The rest still have work ahead of them, because defense prospects can take a long time to sort themselves out.
The organization has been through that kind of development path before. Kris Letang, for instance, had his own bumps before becoming a full-time, unquestioned lineup fixture in 2009-10, four years after being drafted. He played a full season in 2007-08, then went back to Wilkes-Barre for 10 games, and was also a healthy scratch for several games in February 2009.
That history matters because the Penguins are clearly headed for more roster movement. Veterans are likely to go out, younger players are likely to come in, and more prospects or picks could still be added over the next 12 months.
But there is a catch to building around youth: you have to live through the rough patches that come with it. Pittsburgh seems to be postponing that part of the process, and that delay could end up feeding the very frustration the organization is trying to avoid.
That’s why Dubas’s summer looks so strange from the outside. On one hand, he has built a tidal wave of talent that should arrive over the next couple of years. On the other, he signed 30-year-old Andrei Kumenko on July 1, a move that looks even more out of place next to Koivunen’s eight-year deal.
Kumenko and Evgeni Malkin are set to occupy two of the six winger spots in the top nine, even though neither is likely to still be around in 2027-28. That leaves a crowded fight for the rest of the openings, with 25-and-under players Nick Robertson, Hendrix Lapierre, Elmer Soderblom, McGroarty, Koivunen, and Avery Hayes all chasing one top-nine spot and one fourth-line role. Veteran Justin Brazeau, who scored 18 goals last season, is in that mix too.
That’s where the contradiction becomes hard to ignore. Malkin may not have been blocking any one player in particular, but he was still blocking somebody. And it would be quite the sight to see Koivunen, with his $32 million deal, pushed to WBS.
For all the talent on the way, the Penguins may also be setting up a waiver-wire opportunity for other teams near the top of the claim order. Training camp is close, and Dubas has managed to do two things at once: build a prospect wave that could change the organization in 24 months, and create immediate roster congestion that makes the next few weeks look unnecessarily messy.
In Other News...
Penguins Core Faces A Brutal Reality Check Before 2026-27
The long view around the Penguins aging core is getting harder to ignore, even if Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, Kris Letang and Erik Karlsson still give the roster a very real competitive spine. Looking ahead to the 2026-27 season, the conversation is already shifting from what each of them has done to what kind of production still makes sense as time, health and workload start to matter more. Crosby remains the cleanest bet to keep piling up points, while Malkins value is tied as much to his usage and availability as it is to his finishing touch.
Letangs offensive expectations are also moving into a narrower lane, especially with goal production no longer the calling card it once was, and Karlssons point total will be judged against both his recent trend line and where the Penguins are by then. The projections for all four are rooted in recent performance and injury context, but the bigger picture is unavoidable: Pittsburghs veteran core is still productive enough to matter, yet each player now comes with a harder question about how much longer that level can hold. [Read more 🡒]
Connor Dewar Gives Penguins Depth They Can Actually Count On
When Pittsburgh picked up Connor Dewar from Toronto at the 2025 NHL trade deadline, the move looked like the kind of depth add that can fade into the background by spring. Instead, Dewar settled in quickly and gave the Penguins exactly what teams are always searching for in the bottom six: reliable shifts, penalty-kill minutes and the sort of steady two-way work that makes a coach trust him in tighter games.
His value only grew from there. After the trade, Dewars improved play earned him a one-year extension, and later the Penguins doubled down again with a two-year contract extension. By the 2025-26 season and into the playoffs, he had carved out a real role on the fourth line and the penalty kill, turning what started as a deadline flyer into a depth piece Pittsburgh could actually count on. [Read more 🡒]