Chase Pietila’s first full pro season gave the Penguins organization exactly what it wanted to see from a young defenseman trying to carve out a future: steady work, a heavy game, and enough flashes to keep the door open.
The 22-year-old blueliner, ranked No. 25 in PensBurgh’s Top 25 Under 25 countdown, spent the 2025-26 season with Wilkes-Barre/Scranton after signing his entry-level contract with Pittsburgh in March 2025. He arrived there after two seasons at Michigan Tech and a brief pro introduction at the end of the 2024-25 campaign, when he played 12 games split between the Wilkes-Barre/Scranton Penguins and Wheeling Nailers.
This past season, Pietila settled in with the Baby Pens and became a useful piece on the back end during their run to the Eastern Conference Final. He started out on the second defensive pair, then moved around as injuries and lineup needs shifted. He played both sides of the blue line, though the right side became his more regular home, including all 14 postseason games.
The offense was modest but present. Pietila finished the regular season with two goals and 14 assists, then added a goal and an assist in the Calder Cup playoffs.
The real calling card, though, was the physical side of his game. He piled up 85 penalty minutes, second-most on the team, and matched Boko Imama with five fighting majors, the most among Baby Penguins.
That kind of profile fits the scouting read on him. As Trib Live put it, “To be certain, he had a strong - if hardly spectacular - first professional season. But there’s still plenty of refinement needed if he is to reach the NHL.”
The same report described his game as one built on defense, penalty killing and toughness, with offense as a bonus. That’s the lane he’s in right now, and it’s the one he’ll need to keep owning if he wants to keep climbing.
Wilkes-Barre/Scranton coach Kirk MacDonald also singled him out during recent development camp remarks, even though Pietila didn’t take part in the camp itself. MacDonald said, “I can kind of say the same thing,” and added, “I think they (Pietila and Harding) were top-five in the league in plus/minus (as rookies).
… He competes really hard. Defends well.
Penalty kills. He provides some offense, but I think he knows for him to take the next step, he’s got to continue to defend hard and consistently do that.
When you can have guys like that, first-year guys, that you can lean on consistently every night on the back end, it’s great not only for our team but the organization.”
Pietila’s plus/minus backed that up. He finished at +27, one of the best marks in the AHL, and that kind of number tells you he was doing more right than wrong over the course of the season.
For now, the path to Pittsburgh remains crowded. Erik Karlsson and Kris Letang are still on the right side of the Penguins blue line, and Harrison Brunicke is in the mix as well. That makes a 2026-27 NHL debut unlikely for Pietila based on where he sits on the depth chart.
But another year in the AHL could be exactly what he needs. More ice time, more responsibility, more high-leverage minutes - that’s the kind of runway that can sharpen a defense-first prospect and give him a better shot when the lane to the NHL starts to open.
In Other News...
Kyle Dubas Just Put Penguins Fans Through The Same Wait Again
Kyle Dubas spent draft night trying to push the Penguins a little higher in the first round, but the market never really cooperated. Pittsburgh explored ways to move up, and there were obvious questions about whether a veteran piece could have been used to make it happen, yet the price quickly climbed to a point the team was not willing to meet. For a club trying to thread the needle between staying competitive and building for what comes next, it was another reminder that even a modest draft-night upgrade is not easy to buy.
The bigger picture in Pittsburgh still looks familiar: a roster with better forward depth than it had a year ago, enough talent to keep the playoff conversation alive, but not enough to be mistaken for a true Eastern Conference threat. The Penguins are in that awkward middle ground where progress is real but incomplete, and the next wave of help may matter as much as any trade idea that never got off the ground. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Prospect Owen Pickering Suddenly Has A Chance To Change Everything
Owen Pickering spent last season in Wilkes-Barre/Scranton looking more and more like a defenseman the Penguins can actually build around, not just a prospect to keep tabs on. The 2025-26 AHL campaign gave him a real foothold, with 28 points and a plus-16 rating in 68 games, production that suggests he is starting to translate his tools into something sturdier and more complete.
Now the path ahead looks different than it did a few months ago. With openings emerging on the left side of Pittsburgh's blue line, Pickering suddenly has a chance to push for a roster spot in 2026-27, and that is the kind of opportunity that can change a young player's trajectory fast. The Penguins do not have to decide anything yet, but the door is open in a way it wasn't before, and Pickering has put himself in position to make the conversation interesting. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Fans Are Fed Up With Another Wave Of NHL Noise
The NHL rumor mill has been spinning again, and Penguins fans have had plenty of reason to roll their eyes at the latest wave of noise. Between offseason chatter around the league and the constant churn of social media speculation, it has become harder to separate real movement from the kind of talk that fades as quickly as it appears.
For Pittsburgh, the bigger picture is familiar: every offseason brings a fresh round of evaluation, from roster changes to the moves that shape the organization beyond the NHL level. The Penguins have already spent time sorting through their own changes and decisions, and the latest batch of league-wide buzz is just another reminder that not every headline deserves equal weight. [Read more 🡒]