The Penguins were closer than most people realized to landing Jason Robertson.
On the 32 Thoughts podcast, Elliotte Friedman said Pittsburgh went “pretty far down the line” with Dallas on a Robertson trade around the Draft last year, and that the talks came shortly after the Seattle deal collapsed. Friedman added, “I've never gotten a cogent explanation for why that deal didn't occur. Again, there were people who thought that one was going to happen and it didn't.”
That stands out now because the Penguins are heading in a completely different direction. Kyle Dubas has made it clear that it’s time to sell and move veterans, a sharp turn from the path Pittsburgh was considering just a few months ago.
Friedman put it bluntly: “It is amazing when you think just a few months later-like, they were pretty close, I think, to getting Robertson-and now they're going in the almost opposite direction. It's amazing how things change.”
At the time, the Penguins were coming off a much better season than expected, finishing 41-25-16 and getting back to the playoffs for the first time in four years. But this season has gone the other way. Pittsburgh is off to a 7-11-2 start, and that has pushed Dubas toward a full reset.
Robertson’s situation in Dallas was already tense this summer. He had turned down a possible move to Seattle and the Kraken’s 8-year, $15M AAV offer before the Penguins got involved, and Friedman said Pittsburgh came “pretty close” to getting him.
Robertson eventually settled on a one-year, $12M deal with the Stars, keeping the issue alive for later this season.
The Penguins, meanwhile, ended up with Robertson’s younger brother, Nick, instead. Nick Robertson has seven goals and no assists in 20 games this season. Jason Robertson has kept rolling in Dallas, with 10 goals and 24 points in 21 games.
In Other News...
Senators Trade Push Suddenly Centers On A Familiar Name
The Ottawa Senators are again circling the Penguins roster as the trade market starts to take shape, and this time the focus has landed on a name Pittsburgh fans know well. Reports say Ottawa is looking to add help up front, with general manager Steve Staios exploring ways to bring in a top-six forward, and two of the Penguins who have surfaced in that conversation are Rickard Rakell and Bryan Rust.
There is also a familiar wrinkle to the discussion in Erik Karlsson, who remains a pending free agent and could become part of any broader deal. For now, nothing has been finalized, but the overlap between Ottawas needs and Pittsburghs veteran pieces makes this one worth watching closely as the market develops. [Read more 🡒]
Sidney Crosby Just Became The Biggest Question In Pittsburgh
The Penguins slow start has only sharpened the questions hanging over the franchise, with a 7-11-2 record leaving them near the bottom of the Eastern Conference standings. General manager Kyle Dubas has made it clear the organization is focused on getting younger and building for the future, a direction that could eventually put longtime core pieces like Evgenii Malkin, Kris Letang and Sidney Crosby into the center of trade chatter.
Crosbys future is the one that matters most in Pittsburgh, and his camp is not treating it like an urgent decision. His agent said Crosby is not rushing to sort out what comes next, while Dubas has indicated he will respect Crosbys wishes as the captain moves through the final years of his career. For a team trying to balance loyalty to its icons with the reality of a retool, that leaves the biggest question in Pittsburgh still very much open. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Fans Still Can't Escape The Jake Guentzel Trade Debate
More than two and a half years after Jake Guentzel was moved as part of Kyle Dubas rebuilding push, the trade still hangs over the Penguins every time the conversation turns to what Pittsburgh gave up and what it got back. The deal brought in a package of prospects and picks, including Villie Koivunen, Harrison Brunicke, Tommy Novak, Markus Ruck and a 2027 fourth-round selection, but the return has not done much to quiet the noise around one of the franchises most debated recent moves.
There are reasons for optimism in the group, with Novak and Brunicke showing some promise, but the broader picture has not tilted in Pittsburghs favor so far. Koivunen, in particular, has not yet lived up to the kind of expectations that would help soften the loss of Guentzel, which is why the discussion keeps resurfacing whenever Penguins fans revisit the rebuild and ask whether this was the right price to pay. [Read more 🡒]
