Penguins Fans Still Can't Escape The Jake Guentzel Trade Debate

As the aftermath of the Jake Guentzel trade continues to unfold, the Pittsburgh Penguins navigate a complex landscape with high stakes for their future success.

More than two and a half years after Pittsburgh sent Jake Guentzel out the door, the Penguins are still feeling the ripple effects of that move - and the trade tree keeps growing.

What started as Kyle Dubas’ first major swing as general manager has turned into a long chain of players and picks, with Pittsburgh trying to turn one star winger into a collection of younger pieces. The result has not been kind to the Penguins so far. They moved on from Guentzel to recoup assets after refusing to sign him, and the deal has only reinforced how hard it is to replace a player of that caliber.

The Penguins did come away with some pieces from Carolina’s system, plus a journeyman NHL player and two conditional picks that eventually became a second-round selection in 2026. But unless some of the prospects tied to this tree take a real step forward, this is the kind of trade that will linger over the franchise. Guentzel has kept producing elsewhere, and Pittsburgh has yet to find enough value to balance that out.

Here’s where the tree stands now for the Penguins:

Penguins received: Villie Koivunen, Harrison Brunicke, Tommy Novak, Markus Ruck, 2027 4th Round Pick

Penguins traded away/lost: Michael Bunting, Luke Schenn, Ty Smith, Jake Guentzel, Vasily Ponomarev, Cruz Lucius

Tommy Novak may be the most useful piece in the mix at the moment. He isn’t a flashy player, but he gives the Penguins something steady, and he can handle multiple positions. That kind of versatility matters, even if it doesn’t exactly scream headline-grabber.

Koivunen was the centerpiece of the return, but the early returns have been rough. Pittsburgh has tried to push him toward a breakout season, and he still hasn’t delivered in a way that suggests he’s ready to become a reliable NHL forward. At this point, there’s even a real concern that he could end up as a fringe player who doesn’t stick around long-term.

Brunicke offers a more encouraging path. The second-round pick from Carolina is still developing in the minors, but he remains one of the more intriguing long-term possibilities from the deal. He may not become a star, but the Penguins are hoping he can grow into a solid defenseman over the next year or two.

And the tree still isn’t finished. Markus Ruck is part of the expanding web of assets that came out of the Guentzel deal, and Pittsburgh was able to line him up with his twin thanks to the extra second-round pick in 2026. Ruck is still a long way from making anyone excited, but he’s another reminder that this trade keeps branching out.

Even now, there’s one more piece still to come: a 2027 fourth-round pick. So yes, the Jake Guentzel trade tree is still alive, still sprawling, and still refusing to stop.

In Other News...

Penguins Nearly Made A Franchise-Changing Swing Before Everything Shifted

Before the Penguins season turned into a reset, Kyle Dubas was at least exploring a much bigger swing. He had pursued a trade for Jason Robertson from the Dallas Stars, a move that would have brought one of the leagues most dynamic scorers to Pittsburgh and changed the conversation around the roster in a hurry.

Instead, the teams direction has since shifted toward selling veteran pieces and leaning into a rebuild after the rough start. Dallas kept Jason Robertson on a one-year contract, while Pittsburgh ended up with his younger brother, Nick Robertson, who has provided a useful spark with seven goals in 20 games this season. [Read more 🡒]

Senators Trade Push Suddenly Centers On A Familiar Name

The Ottawa Senators are again circling the Penguins roster as the trade market starts to take shape, and this time the focus has landed on a name Pittsburgh fans know well. Reports say Ottawa is looking to add help up front, with general manager Steve Staios exploring ways to bring in a top-six forward, and two of the Penguins who have surfaced in that conversation are Rickard Rakell and Bryan Rust.

There is also a familiar wrinkle to the discussion in Erik Karlsson, who remains a pending free agent and could become part of any broader deal. For now, nothing has been finalized, but the overlap between Ottawas needs and Pittsburghs veteran pieces makes this one worth watching closely as the market develops. [Read more 🡒]

Sidney Crosby Just Became The Biggest Question In Pittsburgh

The Penguins slow start has only sharpened the questions hanging over the franchise, with a 7-11-2 record leaving them near the bottom of the Eastern Conference standings. General manager Kyle Dubas has made it clear the organization is focused on getting younger and building for the future, a direction that could eventually put longtime core pieces like Evgenii Malkin, Kris Letang and Sidney Crosby into the center of trade chatter.

Crosbys future is the one that matters most in Pittsburgh, and his camp is not treating it like an urgent decision. His agent said Crosby is not rushing to sort out what comes next, while Dubas has indicated he will respect Crosbys wishes as the captain moves through the final years of his career. For a team trying to balance loyalty to its icons with the reality of a retool, that leaves the biggest question in Pittsburgh still very much open. [Read more 🡒]