Wake up the Penguins in September, and history suggests you’ll find a whole lot of nothing.
That’s the hard truth behind Pittsburgh’s trade record in the month before the season starts. Since 1984, the Penguins have almost never made a September move that changed much of anything, and most of the ones they did make barely registered.
The early list is full of quick swings and modest returns. On Sept. 10, 1985, the Penguins landed Dave Simpson from the New York Islanders, a former third-round pick who never reached the NHL.
The next day, Eddie Johnston sent Marty McSorley, Tim Hrynewich, and future considerations to the Edmonton Oilers for goalie Gilles Meloche. Meloche spent a few seasons in the Penguins’ goalie platoon, while McSorley went on to become a major figure in Edmonton as Wayne Gretzky’s tough protector, and later did the same in Los Angeles.
Johnston kept going six days later, sending cash to the Buffalo Sabres for Ted Nolan, who retired a year later after playing only 18 games for Pittsburgh. Nolan later moved into coaching in the 1990s.
Tony Esposito, who had the challenge of handling the Penguins’ fishbowl and building around Mario Lemieux, made a September move in 1988 when he acquired Wendell Young from the Philadelphia Flyers for a seventh-round pick.
The pattern didn’t improve much as the years rolled on. In 1997, Craig Patrick traded Jason Woolley to Buffalo for a fifth-round pick and fan favorite Francois Leroux to Colorado for a third-rounder. Woolley then played nine more NHL seasons, six with the Sabres and three with Detroit, which only made Pittsburgh’s decision look worse in hindsight.
Two years later, in 1999, the Penguins moved Kevin Hatcher to the New York Rangers for Peter Popovic. Popovic played 54 games for Pittsburgh and put up six points, 1-5-6, before leaving in free agency after the season.
The next September trade came in 2005, when the Penguins dealt Kris Beech to the Nashville Predators for a fourth-round pick. Beech had been part of the Jaromir Jagr deal, though the real centerpiece of that transaction was the cash from the Washington Capitals that helped keep the Penguins afloat.
Then came a long gap. Pittsburgh didn’t make another September trade for 15 years.
When Jim Rutherford finally broke that stretch in 2020, the first move was a salary dump: Nick Bjugstad went to the Minnesota Wild for a conditional seventh-round pick, but the conditions weren’t met, so the Penguins got nothing back.
Nine days later, though, Rutherford finally delivered a September trade that worked out. He sent Patric Hornqvist to the Florida Panthers for defenseman Mike Matheson and Colton Sceviour.
Hornqvist became a key piece in Florida’s rise, while Matheson revived his career in Pittsburgh. His speed stood out immediately on a Penguins roster that was slowing down, and the defensive issues that had followed him seemed to fade in black and gold.
That run ended when Ron Hextall traded Matheson to Montreal for Jeff Petry in July 2022, but the Penguins still got two solid seasons out of Matheson.
So that’s the record: an awful September trade history, with only a couple of deals producing players who lasted more than a few seasons, and several others sending out players who went on to better careers somewhere else.
In Other News...
Mario Lemieux's Penguins Era Just Reached A Stunning Turning Point
Mario Lemieuxs long formal run with the Penguins has come to an end after he and Ron Burkle sold their minority ownership stakes, closing the book on nearly 40 years of direct association with the franchise. It is a significant shift for a team that has long carried Lemieuxs influence not just from his Hall of Fame playing days, but through years of stewardship behind the scenes.
The Penguins recent purchase by the Hoffmann Family of Companies adds another layer to the transition, especially with the new ownership group signaling it would be open to Lemieux remaining involved in some capacity. Even without an ownership stake, Lemieuxs presence still matters in Pittsburgh, and the next chapter will hinge on how that relationship is defined under new control. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Fans Just Got A Reminder Of One Frustrating September Trend
The Penguins have spent enough Septembers reminding their fans that the calendar can be its own source of anxiety, especially when the conversation turns to roster moves and front-office decisions. Now the team is drawing a different kind of attention, with a new rinkside reporter in place as the season edges closer and the hockey news cycle starts to tilt from summer speculation toward real business.
Around the league, the broader landscape is shifting too, from uncertainty around Hockey Night in Canada personnel to the Dallas Stars preparing to move local broadcasts to Amazon. For Pittsburgh, though, the familiar concern is less about the television side and more about how this month has historically gone when the Penguins have tried to make their biggest trade calls, a track record that has left fans waiting for the next shoe to drop. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins May Have A Goalie Prospect Worth Watching Very Closely
The Penguins are part of a small but intriguing group of teams that could be leaning on a rookie goaltender in 2026-27, and Sergei Murashov keeps showing up in that conversation. Around the league, the discussion is centered on a handful of young netminders expected to have meaningful roles, with the Boston Bruins Michael DiPietro, the Montreal Canadiens Jacob Fowler and the Toronto Maple Leafs Dennis Hildeby also drawing attention for where they sit in their development.
For Pittsburgh, Murashov is the name worth filing away because the outlook is about more than just who gets a camp look. The broader read on this crop of rookies is that some carry past NHL experience that rules them out of Calder consideration, but the real point for the Penguins is simpler than awards talk: if Murashov takes the next step, he could become a very relevant part of their goaltending picture before long, even if no roster decision is settled yet. [Read more 🡒]