Penguins Fans Just Got Another Painful Reminder About Dubas

Amidst Kyle Dubas's conservative draft strategy, Jason Robertson commits to a high-stakes deal with the Dallas Stars, leaving the Penguins in the lurch for roster reinforcements.

Jason Robertson is staying in Dallas, and the price tag is a big one.

The Stars forward has agreed to a one-year deal with a $12,000,000 cap hit/AAV, pushing him to unrestricted free agency at the end of the contract. He will be eligible on January 1, 2027 to sign a long-term extension with Dallas.

His arbitration date had been set for July 25, but that no longer matters after the deal came together. Robertson’s agent had said his preference was to remain in Dallas, and that is exactly how this played out.

For Pittsburgh, it is another missed opportunity in a summer that has already carried that theme. Kyle Dubas made the swing, but the trade never got over the line. The source of the stall appears to have been draft-pick value, with Dallas seeking picks and Dubas unwilling to move high-end ones.

That approach has drawn criticism because the Penguins are trying to contend now, while holding onto picks that may not help for several years. The roster still has obvious holes on defense, too many forwards, and dead weight that needs to be moved out.

Names such as Elias Pettersson and Shane Wright are being floated as examples of the kind of players Pittsburgh could still pursue if it decides to actually upgrade the roster.

As for Robertson, the expectation is that this could still end in a much longer Dallas commitment down the road. A seven-year extension on January 1, 2027 or later in the season is the likeliest path, and Dallas should have the money to make that kind of payday happen. If Robertson becomes available again, Pittsburgh may take another run at him, but the odds of that happening are slim.

What Dallas could not do this time was lock him up long term, even though the plan and pitch were apparently clear in the final talks.

In Other News...

Kyle Dubas Just Made The Penguins Direction Hard To Ignore

Kyle Dubas has spent the offseason making the Penguins direction easier to read, even as the roster keeps taking shape. The front office has mixed a veteran anchor in Evgeni Malkin with a clear push toward younger talent, adding Andrei Kuzmenko, bringing in Nick Robertson and Kaedan Korczak, drafting twins and dealing for Hendrix Lapierre as part of a broader reset around development and upside.

What stands out is how little ambiguity remains about the plan. Pittsburgh is not pretending this is a quick patch job or a one-off swing at relevance, and the moves around the edges keep pointing in the same direction: younger, faster, more flexible. The only real question now is how much more Dubas wants to change before the offseason is officially closed. [Read more 🡒]

Penguins Are Making Another Risky Bet Fans Know Too Well

The Penguins are heading into another season with the kind of blue-line and goaltending uncertainty that has become all too familiar in recent years. After moving on from Parker Wotherspoon, Ryan Shea and Stuart Skinner, the team is leaning on a mix of established names and younger options to stabilize a group that still features Erik Karlsson, Kris Letang and Kaedan Korczak, with Trevor van Riemsdyk also in the picture.

Samuel Girard and Owen Pickering are among the players expected to help fill the left-side void, while the depth chart behind them remains a work in progress. Pittsburgh also has prospects pushing for larger roles and limited NHL experience sprinkled into the mix, which leaves the back end with more questions than answers as the season approaches. [Read more 🡒]