The Penguins are not walking into 2026-27 with the kind of sky-is-falling outlook they carried a year ago. But they are also not being treated like a team that just posted 98 points and earned a playoff spot.
That’s the strange middle ground here: respect, but not much belief.
BetMGM has Pittsburgh at +10000 to win the Stanley Cup, which puts them 22nd in the NHL. Their Eastern Conference number sits at +4000, good for 13th in the conference and behind the Columbus Blue Jackets, Ottawa Senators, Toronto Maple Leafs and New Jersey Devils. The first three of those teams missed the playoffs last season, and outside of Toronto, none of them has done much to change its roster this offseason.
The market is also leaning against Pittsburgh making another run. The Penguins are +210 to reach the playoffs and -275 to miss them. Their projected point total is sitting between 88.5 and 91.5, depending on the sportsbook.
That’s the betting world’s way of saying regression is coming.
And from a more eyeball-test perspective, that feeling is out there too. Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, Kris Letang, Bryan Rust and Erik Karlsson are all another year older.
A few of them showed signs of wearing down in the playoffs, and at some point the slide for some of these veterans is going to get sharper. Letang, in particular, already looks like he’s started to feel it.
Still, this is not a team without a path to surprising people again.
The simplest route is the one Pittsburgh still has sitting in front of it: $16.9 million in cap space and a couple of months to use it. Maybe that turns into Jason Robertson.
Maybe it turns into someone else. The Robertson idea feels less likely by the day, but the opportunity to swing for something major is still there.
Even if the Penguins stand pat, though, the forward group gives them a real chance to beat the projections.
Losing Anthony Mantha and Noel Accairi does not change the basic shape of the unit all that much. This still looks like a deep group that can roll four lines, stay dangerous all night and score enough to matter. Down in Wilkes-Barre/Scranton, there are legitimately 17 or 18 forwards who could handle meaningful NHL minutes this season and hold up well enough to compete.
Crosby remains the anchor. He is still a top-line player, and just having him on the ice gives Pittsburgh a shot most nights over an 82-game season.
Then come the variables that could really move the needle. Ben Kindel is the obvious one.
He was 19 last season and already proved he could be an NHL player - and a very good one - right away. What does a full season of that look like?
If there’s a real breakout coming, the whole equation changes.
Egor Chinakhov is another swing factor. He arrives in Pittsburgh on a three-year, $18 million contract, which says the front office believes in him. The talent is there, and if he pops in a full season, that changes the math too.
There’s also the chance that someone like Nicholas Robertson or Elmer Soderblom follows the kind of path Chinakhov did. The underlying numbers leave at least some room for that kind of jump.
That same idea extends to the back end, where Kaedan Korczak could be part of the story after spending the last few years thriving in a smaller role with the Vegas Golden Knights. He may get a larger opportunity here, and that opens another possible ceiling.
Pittsburgh has turned over half of its defense, with Korczak, Declan Carlile and Trevor van Riemsdyk all joining the roster, plus a full season of Sam Girard. Girard still has some appeal as a player who might benefit from a fresh start to the season, especially if he can be separated from Letang. And the new additions at least make sense on paper. van Riemsdyk is a steady defender, and the fact that he was the first player signed in free agency, right when the market opened, suggests he was a clear target.
That overhaul matters because defense was the biggest problem for the Penguins last season. They finished the regular season 20th in expected goals per 60 minutes at 5-on-5, 23rd in scoring chances against and 22nd in high-danger scoring chances against.
The new faces could help there, and so could a couple of internal options. Harrison Brunicke seemed to improve across the board as the season went on, and Owen Pickering could also get a chance.
But the biggest swing factor of all is in net.
Nothing on this roster may affect Pittsburgh’s floor and ceiling more than the goaltending. Last season, the Penguins finished 24th in the league in all-situations save percentage, though they were a little better in goals saved above expected at plus 10.
This year, they appear to be all-in on Sergei Murashov and Arturs Silovs as a tandem, and that makes the position the biggest mystery on the team. The upside is real.
So is the risk. Young goalies can go in any direction, and doing it behind a defense that still has questions only adds to the uncertainty.
That’s why the Penguins could be a playoff team again. It’s also why they could end up much closer to the lottery than anyone in Pittsburgh wants to think about.
In Other News...
Penguins Reunion Could Be Back In Play On The Blue Line
The Penguins have spent the offseason reshaping the roster, adding pieces while also watching a few defensemen depart through trades and free agency. That turnover has left the blue line with a little less certainty than the front office would like, and it has reopened the door to familiar names as Pittsburgh looks for ways to round out the back end.
One of those names is a former Penguins defenseman who just finished a career-best season in Pittsburgh before reaching unrestricted free agency. He would fit as a short-term depth addition, the kind of veteran who could push for a bottom-pairing job while also giving the club a steadier left-shot option as it sorts through the rest of its defense plans. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Blue Line Still Has One Problem Dubas Must Solve
The Penguins spent the offseason reshaping the blue line, and on paper the incoming group looks capable of handling the defensive side of the job. The deeper issue is balance, especially on the left, where the roster picture still feels unfinished even after the departures and additions that changed the look of the unit.
For now, Pittsburgh appears to have only one established NHL left-shot defenseman to lean on, which leaves Kyle Dubas with a real lineup puzzle before camp opens. There are internal candidates who could be asked to help, and there is always the possibility of a trade or a longer-term swing to fix it, but the current setup still leaves the defense looking less complete, and less balanced, than it did when last season ended. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Face A Defining Offseason Choice They Can't Delay
The Penguins are heading into the offseason with a roster puzzle that looks straightforward in a few places and murky everywhere else. Their top six up front appears mostly settled, but there is still real uncertainty about where Justin Brazeau fits and whether one of the current forwards gets nudged out to make room. Behind that, the organization has to decide how aggressively it wants to push younger options into the mix, with Rutger McGroarty, Avery Hayes and Hendrix Lapierre all sitting in that uneasy space between future piece and roster squeeze.
On defense, the questions are just as pointed, especially when it comes to how much the coaching staff can lean on certain pairings and whether the group is actually built to handle the heavier minutes it will be asked to absorb. The bigger issue may be philosophical as much as tactical: for all the talk about getting younger under Dan Muse, the lineup still carries a lot of age and a thin margin for error in the areas that usually decide close games. The Penguins can talk about depth and competition, but until they sort out the forward logjam and the back end, the roster still feels like one that needs answers more than optimism. [Read more 🡒]