The Pittsburgh Penguins walk into Thursday night with something they haven’t had to confront in more than 20 years: real uncertainty about where this is headed.
That was the backdrop after general manager Kyle Dubas made the stakes plain Wednesday, telling players they need to improve their play or he’ll be willing to move pieces for draft picks and prospects. Now the Penguins (7-11-2) have to answer that message on the ice when they host the St. Louis Blues (10-9-2) at PPG Paints Arena.
The puck drops just after 7 p.m and Jeff Jimerson croons the National Anthem.
The Penguins are coming off another rough one, a 4-1 loss to the Ottawa Senators that followed a three-game West Coast trip in which they beat the LA Kings and San Jose Sharks. For a while against Ottawa, it looked like they might have something going.
They held a 1-0 lead and were playing well enough through the first half of the game, but that didn’t last long. Turnovers by Ben Kindel and Connor Dewar quickly ended up in the back of the Penguins’ net, and the whole thing unraveled from there.
Tommy Novak scored twice, though only one of those goals counted. His credited goal came on a clean two-on-one finished after a feed from Egor Chinakhov.
Sergei Murashov was solid again in goal, stopping 30 of 33 shots while making his third start in the last four games. Even so, the same old issue showed up again: too many odd-man rushes, breakaways and point-blank chances left him exposed.
There’s also a lineup wrinkle on Thursday. Coach Dan Muse is pairing Rutger McGroarty and Ville Koivunen with one of the Wilkes-Barre crew, a notable shift as the team tries to find something different.
McGroarty has been steady, but his NHL scoring has been limited. Koivunen, meanwhile, has had trouble finding his footing in his first full season.
On the other side, St. Louis arrives after an 8-6 win over the Anaheim Ducks on Tuesday.
Connor McMichael and Robert Thomas put the Blues up 2-1, and Dalibor Dvorsky added another before they opened things up. Jake Neighbours, Philip Broberg and Logan Mailloux scored in a 2:58 burst early in the third to push the lead to 7-3 before Anaheim made a furious push back.
Pavel Buchnevich’s empty-netter closed it out. Jordan Binnington made 25 saves in his first start since Nov. 5, even with Cutter Gauthier recording a hat trick for Anaheim.
Arturs Silovs is expected to start for the Penguins, while Joel Hoffer is likely to be in net for St. Louis. Both official starters will be announced after the morning skate, and PHN will update once that happens.
The Penguins should also get Trevor van Riemsdyk back Thursday, with the defenseman likely returning after missing 14 games because of injury. He played in the first six games of the season before getting sidelined. Bryan Rust and Elmer Soderblom remain on the IR.
Radio coverage is on 105.9 The X and the Penguins app.
Here’s how the lines are expected to look:
Evgeni Malkin-Sidney Crosby-Rickard Rakell
Tommy Novak-Ben Kindel-Egor Chinakhov
Rutger McGroarty-Hendrix Lapierre-Ville Koivunen
Connor Dewar-Blake Lizotte-Nicholas Robertson
Defense
Spencer Stastney-Erik Karlsson
Samuel Girard-Kaedan Korczak
Trevor van Riemsdyk- Kris Letang
Goalie: Arturs Silovs, expected.
Blues Lines
Jake Neighbours-Robert Thomas-Jimmy Snuggerud
Dylan Holloway-Mason McTavish-Connor McMichael
Aleksanteri Kaskimäki-Pavel Buchnevich-Jonatan Berggren
Alexey Toropchenko-Pius Suter-Dalibor Dvorsky
Defense
Philip Broberg-Logan Mailloux
Justin Barron-Colton Parayko
Cam Fowler-Brandon Carlo
Goalie: Joel Hofer, expected.
The special teams numbers are nearly identical on the power play, with both clubs sitting at 20.0% and tied for 19th. The edge goes to St.
Louis on the penalty kill, where the Blues are at 82.1% and rank ninth. Pittsburgh’s kill is at 79.6%, good for 14th.
There’s still some history on the Penguins’ side. They are 8-2-1 in their last 11 games against St.
Louis and have won six straight at PPG Paints Arena against the Blues dating back to Dec. 4, 2019.
Evgeni Malkin has 25 points (10-15-25) in 25 career games against St. Louis. Rutger McGroarty has three points (2-1-3) in two career games against the Blues, including a two-point performance (1-1-2) on April 3, 2025, his only career multi-point game.
Malkin also sits on a milestone. Since the start of the 2025-26 season, he has 78 points (25-53-78) in 74 games played, and one more point would move him into a tie with Bryan Trottier for 19th on the NHL’s all-time scoring list.
Erik Karlsson is close to a milestone of his own. He has 955 career points and needs three more to tie Larry Robinson for the ninth-most points in NHL history among defensemen.
As a team, the Penguins’ defensemen have combined for 56 points, which ranks fifth in the NHL.
In Other News...
Penguins Nearly Made A Franchise-Changing Swing Before Everything Shifted
Before the Penguins season turned into a reset, Kyle Dubas was at least exploring a much bigger swing. He had pursued a trade for Jason Robertson from the Dallas Stars, a move that would have brought one of the leagues most dynamic scorers to Pittsburgh and changed the conversation around the roster in a hurry.
Instead, the teams direction has since shifted toward selling veteran pieces and leaning into a rebuild after the rough start. Dallas kept Jason Robertson on a one-year contract, while Pittsburgh ended up with his younger brother, Nick Robertson, who has provided a useful spark with seven goals in 20 games this season. [Read more 🡒]
Senators Trade Push Suddenly Centers On A Familiar Name
The Ottawa Senators are again circling the Penguins roster as the trade market starts to take shape, and this time the focus has landed on a name Pittsburgh fans know well. Reports say Ottawa is looking to add help up front, with general manager Steve Staios exploring ways to bring in a top-six forward, and two of the Penguins who have surfaced in that conversation are Rickard Rakell and Bryan Rust.
There is also a familiar wrinkle to the discussion in Erik Karlsson, who remains a pending free agent and could become part of any broader deal. For now, nothing has been finalized, but the overlap between Ottawas needs and Pittsburghs veteran pieces makes this one worth watching closely as the market develops. [Read more 🡒]
Sidney Crosby Just Became The Biggest Question In Pittsburgh
The Penguins slow start has only sharpened the questions hanging over the franchise, with a 7-11-2 record leaving them near the bottom of the Eastern Conference standings. General manager Kyle Dubas has made it clear the organization is focused on getting younger and building for the future, a direction that could eventually put longtime core pieces like Evgenii Malkin, Kris Letang and Sidney Crosby into the center of trade chatter.
Crosbys future is the one that matters most in Pittsburgh, and his camp is not treating it like an urgent decision. His agent said Crosby is not rushing to sort out what comes next, while Dubas has indicated he will respect Crosbys wishes as the captain moves through the final years of his career. For a team trying to balance loyalty to its icons with the reality of a retool, that leaves the biggest question in Pittsburgh still very much open. [Read more 🡒]
