The Penguins’ 2026-27 roster picture already has a familiar Pittsburgh feel in one way: the big names are still there. But the mix around them is where things start to get messy.
There’s talent in this group, no question. There’s also a real sense that the lineup is crowded in some spots, thin in others, and still waiting for a few young players to force their way in.
With puck drop on Sept. 29 still ahead, this is only a projection. But even now, the shape of the roster tells a story.
Up front, the top line still carries weight. Crosby, Rust and Rakell weren’t as sharp together last season as they have been in the past, but they still put up their usual production. That trio remains a legitimate first line as long as regression doesn’t show up in a big way.
The second line was dynamite last season, and the third line has some real juice too, even if those players have never actually skated together. Lizotte and Dewar are already a known fit, and Söderblom made a strong first impression after arriving from the Detroit Red Wings. His size is real, and so might be his upside.
That said, the forward group comes with some obvious problems. A top line with an average age of 35 is asking for trouble.
Novak looks more like a fringe top-six player than a stable one. Malkin, who gets hurt a lot, is being asked to match last season’s level.
Chinakhov still has to prove he wasn’t just a one-off. And Kuzmenko and Robertson don’t bring much defensively, which is not ideal for third-line wingers.
The penalty kill is another issue. Lizotte and Dewar can handle it.
Kindel looks ready for that work, and Rust can do it too, though the Penguins probably don’t want him burning all his energy there. Beyond that, the depth is not exactly overflowing.
That leaves Justin Brazeau in a strange spot. It almost feels odd not to have him on one of the top four lines, but the fit isn’t clean.
Söderblom played at a higher level last season. Brazeau was a healthy scratch for the first time all year in the playoffs against the Flyers.
And with the Penguins’ top six looking pretty settled, it’s hard to imagine Robertson and Kuzmenko were brought in to sit in the press box, or that Lizotte and Dewar got new contracts to do that either.
The deeper problem is what that means for the younger forwards. If the top 13 includes the names above plus Brazeau, then Rutger McGroarty and Avery Hayes are on the outside looking in.
McGroarty started slowly last season, possibly because of health issues in September, and never really found the level the Penguins were hoping for. He’s still only 22, though, and he has plenty to offer.
Starting him in AHL Wilkes-Barre next season might not be the best answer. Hayes may not have a huge ceiling, but he has the profile of a bottom-six pest who can score in the NHL.
Then there’s 24-year-old Hendrix Lapierre. So how exactly do all of them fit?
That’s the tension here. Coaches are supposed to play the 12 best forwards, sure.
But the Penguins are also supposed to be getting younger, and Dan Muse was brought in to work with young NHL players. Those two ideas do not always line up neatly.
The blue line has its own split personality.
If Muse can unlock prime Karlsson, that changes everything. He’d be a joy to watch and a major boost to the team.
Carlile might have been Kyle Dubas’ best free-agent pickup, and with Korczak, he could form a very young and dependable pairing. Girard was playing hurt last season and may have more to give now that he’s had a full summer to settle into the system.
Van Riemsdyk is a dependable player.
But there’s plenty to worry about too. Letang and Girard flashed at times late in the postseason, but they generally weren’t good together.
Van Riemsdyk should not be getting top-pairing minutes, especially at 34 and on his off side. Letang probably shouldn’t be handling substantial minutes anymore, even if he likely will.
And the Penguins are also missing two of their better penalty-killing defensemen in Ryan Shea and Parker Wotherspoon.
The extra defense spots are unsettled as well. The Penguins don’t want Ryan Graves in the lineup, which makes sense.
Caleb Jones showed some early flashes last season and looks like the best bet to be the No. 7 defenseman if everyone is healthy. Owen Pickering shouldn’t be forgotten, either; he made some progress last season even while playing hurt.
Still, there’s not much evidence the current front office has huge plans for him.
Then there’s Harrison Brunicke, who may be the most important defenseman in the organization’s future. It wouldn’t be the end of the world if he starts next season in Wilkes-Barre.
He’s only 20 and has played just 34 AHL games. More seasoning there could make sense.
Even so, he looked a little too good for the AHL during most of Wilkes-Barre’s playoff run this spring.
In goal, the Penguins are betting on youth again. Sergei Murashov and Artūrs Šilovs are the current best guess, and there’s a lot to like there.
Murashov, 22, has been handled well and looks ready for prime time. His athleticism and overall talent are hard to miss.
Šilovs is 25 and still has room to grow.
The downside is obvious: that is a very inexperienced tandem. Youth is probably the right move, but it could bring some short-term pain. And the Penguins have a habit of splitting goalie time 50-50, which raises a fair question in a non-Olympic schedule: does that leave too much downtime for developing netminders?
Joel Blomqvist is still in the picture, too. He was nearly as good as Murashov in Wilkes-Barre last season and remains a legitimate NHL prospect. For now, the net looks like it will be his in Wilkes-Barre, which is fine, but he’ll be waiting for his NHL chance sooner rather than later.
The broader takeaway is pretty clear. Dubas has done solid work bringing in younger pieces like Chinakhov, Kindel, Söderblom, Robertson and Šilovs.
That matters. But the roster as it stands still feels uneven.
Four players in the top six are 33 or older, and that’s a major warning sign for a team trying to rebuild. Novak is another top-six name, but he turns 30 next spring and is fairly ordinary. The left side of the defense looks shaky, the right side looks too old, and not enough of the defensemen are strong defenders.
Could this group still push for a playoff spot next season? Yes, if Murashov turns out to be an upgrade.
That’s possible. It’s also a lot to ask from a rookie.
Right now, the Penguins look overcrowded in some places, short in others, and stuck between the very old and the very young. Another move or two before the season might be enough to make the whole thing look a lot more sensible.
In Other News...
Penguins Reunion Could Be Back In Play On The Blue Line
The Penguins have spent the offseason reshaping the roster, adding pieces while also watching a few defensemen depart through trades and free agency. That turnover has left the blue line with a little less certainty than the front office would like, and it has reopened the door to familiar names as Pittsburgh looks for ways to round out the back end.
One of those names is a former Penguins defenseman who just finished a career-best season in Pittsburgh before reaching unrestricted free agency. He would fit as a short-term depth addition, the kind of veteran who could push for a bottom-pairing job while also giving the club a steadier left-shot option as it sorts through the rest of its defense plans. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Blue Line Still Has One Problem Dubas Must Solve
The Penguins spent the offseason reshaping the blue line, and on paper the incoming group looks capable of handling the defensive side of the job. The deeper issue is balance, especially on the left, where the roster picture still feels unfinished even after the departures and additions that changed the look of the unit.
For now, Pittsburgh appears to have only one established NHL left-shot defenseman to lean on, which leaves Kyle Dubas with a real lineup puzzle before camp opens. There are internal candidates who could be asked to help, and there is always the possibility of a trade or a longer-term swing to fix it, but the current setup still leaves the defense looking less complete, and less balanced, than it did when last season ended. [Read more 🡒]