The first year of the Dan Muse era in Pittsburgh came with a new tone, a faster pace and a roster that seemed to respond from the jump. The Penguins were clearly going to look different in 2025-26 after Mike Sullivan was replaced and a rookie NHL coach took over, and that showed immediately in Muse’s first practice, when assistants banged sticks on the glass and the whole session carried a high-energy, up-tempo feel. Veterans bought in quickly, praising the organization, the intention and the tone set by the new staff.
The results followed. Pittsburgh piled up 98 points, finished second in the division and snapped a three-year playoff drought. Muse was rewarded with a spot as a Jack Adams finalist, and the Penguins once again looked like a team trending back toward the top of the Metropolitan Division.
Now comes the harder part: doing it again.
History says that’s no easy task in Pittsburgh. Of the last four Penguins coaches who stayed on for a full second season, three saw their point total drop in Year 2.
Per Dave Molinari, Kevin Constantine went from 98 to 90, Michael Therrien from 105 to 102 and Mike Sullivan from 111 to 100, while Dan Bylsma was the lone exception, improving from 101 to 106. That group was playing 82-game seasons, while Muse will work with the expanded 84-game schedule this year - a little more runway, but also a little more grind for everyone else in the league chasing playoff spots.
There are also some obvious pressure points for Muse to clean up. His goalie-interference challenges became a running theme last season: nine attempts, nine losses.
GM Kyle Dubas told Muse in March to keep using his challenge “ by the book ,” but the issue was that Muse’s read clearly didn’t match what the officials saw. Some of those challenges were justified, but the volume stood out even more - Muse challenged nearly twice as often as any other team.
Each miss meant another penalty kill, and it’s worth watching whether that part of his game settles down in Year 2.
At the same time, Muse’s first season was loaded with players turning in career years. Justin Brazeau, Anthony Mantha, Parker Wotherspoon and Ryan Shea all took meaningful steps.
Egor Chinakhov broke out, Ben Kindel did too, and Erik Karlsson looked like one of the best defensemen in the world again. Even depth pieces such as Connor Dewar and Noel Acciari produced at a high level relative to expectations.
The challenge now is obvious: that kind of across-the-board surge is hard to repeat.
Development will matter just as much. The Penguins are still an older team overall, but the next layer is coming into view.
Kindel, Chinakhov, Nick Robertson, Elmer Soderblom, Kaeden Korczak, Declan Carlile, Hendrix Lapierre and Sergei Murashov are all names that need real roles and continued growth. Then there’s the next wave: Harrison Brunicke, Rutger McGroarty and the $4 million dollar man Ville Koivunen, all trying to climb in a crowded room.
Muse already showed he’s willing to move pieces around to find the right mix. His lineups were fluid from the start, with Koivunen on the first line on opening night after Bryan Rust landed on IR.
Phil Tomasino opened in the lineup, then was replaced the next game by Filip Hallander even though the Penguins had just won by shutout. Arturs Silovs got the opening-night start in goal in an unconventional decision, and even after that shutout, he was sent to the bench for the second game.
Muse also kept shuffling players like Tommy Novak and Rickard Rakell between lines while trying to find the best spots for Kindel, Mantha and Brazeau.
Those moves generally worked. They helped produce strong individual performances and gave the Penguins a structure that clicked. The question now is whether Muse can keep squeezing that kind of value out of a roster that will keep changing around him.
In Other News...
Penguins Still Carry One Unsettling Problem Into This Season
Jonathan Huberdeaus offseason has taken an unwelcome turn, with the winger now facing a setback after surgery and set to miss training camp. For a team trying to get its legs under it before the pace of the new season starts, any delay in a players ramp-up matters, especially when camp is where new lines, roles and expectations begin to take shape.
The Penguins also have to sort through the usual swirl of roster chatter, with trade rumors around Kirill Marchenko and reported interest in a free-agent winger adding another layer of uncertainty. None of that is unusual this time of year, but it does leave Pittsburgh with a familiar question hanging over the roster picture: whether the next move will add clarity or just create another decision that has to wait. [Read more 🡒]