As the 2026 NHL Trade Deadline looms, the Pittsburgh Penguins find themselves at a crossroads. With the team currently holding a playoff spot, General Manager Kyle Dubas faces some crucial decisions that could shape the rest of their season. With several key players approaching unrestricted free agency, Dubas must weigh the potential benefits of trading them against the promise of a playoff push led by Sidney Crosby and the core group.
Potential Trade Chips
Anthony Mantha: After signing a one-year deal last summer, Mantha has been a solid contributor with 20 goals and 42 points across 56 games. While his performance has been noteworthy, the current market doesn't seem ripe for a trade centered solely around him.
If Dubas were to move Mantha, it would likely be in exchange for a younger asset. However, the smart money is on him staying put for now, with a deeper evaluation in the offseason.
Stuart Skinner: Acquired from the Edmonton Oilers in a trade for Tristan Jarry, Skinner has had a respectable showing in Pittsburgh, despite a .887 save percentage over 13 games. Having led the Oilers to back-to-back Stanley Cup Finals, his postseason experience could be invaluable. With promising talent like Arturs Silovs rising and depth in the AHL, Dubas might consider moving Skinner, though a trade seems more probable in the summer unless a compelling offer arises.
Noel Acciari: Known for his physical play and defensive prowess, Acciari's value is evident, especially during trade season when teams covet his skill set. While he could fetch a second- or third-round pick, his role on Pittsburgh’s fourth line might make him more valuable to keep, particularly with the playoffs in sight.
Looking Ahead
Regardless of how the season concludes, Dubas is preparing for an active offseason. Decisions loom not just for Mantha, Skinner, and Acciari, but also for players like Connor Dewar and Evgeni Malkin.
Dewar, with 13 goals and 24 points this season, may not have high trade value, making re-signing him a likely move. Meanwhile, Malkin, eager to return and willing to take a pay cut, leaves his future open for negotiation.
Thanks to Dubas's strategic approach, the Penguins are well-positioned in the standings coming out of the Winter Olympic break. His choices in the coming weeks will be pivotal in determining whether the Penguins make a deep playoff run or focus on retooling for next season.