The Penguins’ October has started to look like a long list of the same problem.
After Pittsburgh’s loss to Montreal, Dan Muse pointed straight at the defensive breakdowns that keep showing up in bunches.
“Hockey is a game of mistakes, so mistakes are going to happen. But in terms of them being able to get two quick ones, or even sometimes just shifts with multiple chances back-to-back, we need to be better at just kind of controlling that,” Muse said.
He didn’t stop there.
”Guys are getting clean looks there at the net, and second opportunities around the net. Those things are preventable,” Muse said.
“So again, breakdowns, mistakes are going to happen, breakdowns are going to happen. It’s just happening too much.
Got to correct it.”
That’s the heart of the issue for Pittsburgh, and it’s becoming harder to believe this group can clean it up for long enough to matter. The Penguins have shown they can steady things for short stretches, including a three-game run from Oct. 22-29 when they allowed just six total goals.
But outside of that pocket, the goals against have piled up fast, with the team regularly surrendering four or five in a night. That’s a brutal way to survive in the NHL.
The standings reflect it. Pittsburgh was 14th out of 16 teams in the Eastern Conference after last night, and the trouble is that even a team with a .607 points percentage - Buffalo, with 17 points in 14 games - is still below the playoff line. The Penguins have 12 points in 14 games.
Around the Metropolitan Division, the week brought a mix of surges, survival acts and a few teams making life harder on themselves.
Carolina went 2-0-0, and that doesn’t even include today’s 7-0 rout of Winnipeg. The Hurricanes have now won 12 of their first 16 games and have only two regulation losses, with no sign of any Stanley Cup hangover.
New Jersey posted a 2-1-1 week, and Connor Hellebuyck was a major reason why. He won both of his starts for the Devils and allowed only three goals total. Goaltending has been a sore spot for this team for years, and right now it looks like that issue has finally been addressed.
Washington also went 2-0-0, and the Caps had a notable shift at the top of the goal-scoring chart. They have an Alex with 10 goals in 12 games, but it’s Alex Tuch now. Ovechkin has just one goal in his first 12 games and has settled into more of a supporting role in his final season while others carry the load.
The Islanders went 2-2-0, though the results came with a little smoke and mirrors. They were outscored 10-3 in their two losses, but still found a way to grab an overtime win and a shootout win in the tighter games.
That’s very much in line with how they operate: hanging around, then squeezing out points. Matthew Schaefer helped make that possible, playing a full five minutes of OT in one game and then scoring the game-winner in the other.
The Rangers had only one game, which turned out to be a blessing and a problem at the same time. They gave up six goals and lost, and now they’ve allowed five or more in four of their last six games while dealing with life without their franchise goalie. This week brings four games, and Connor McDavid surely has his eyes on them today.
Pittsburgh, meanwhile, went 0-1-1 and kept finding the same kind of chaotic game script. Both outings were fast, loose and packed with chances at both ends. But the Penguins aren’t scoring enough to cover for the leaks, and Muse’s comments made clear why that margin keeps disappearing.
Columbus finished 1-2-0. The Blue Jackets beat Philadelphia in overtime early in the week, then dropped a one-goal game to Carolina and fell by two to Dallas after an empty-netter.
Against those tougher opponents, the scoring dried up late, with only three combined goals in the two losses. That’s not a formula that leads to many wins.
In Other News...
Penguins Just Created A New Opening For Rutger McGroarty
Rutger McGroarty is back with Wilkes-Barre/Scranton after Pittsburgh reassigned the young forward, a move that trims the NHL roster but also keeps the door cracked open for him. Since breaking in during the 2024-25 season, McGroarty has appeared in 34 NHL games and put up four goals and nine points, while his work in the AHL has continued to show why the Penguins view him as a real part of their future.
For now, the assignment gives Pittsburgh a little more flexibility up front and keeps McGroarty in a place where he can keep building confidence and production. He has already shown he can handle the minors with scoring touch and strong underlying numbers over two seasons, so the next step may depend less on what he does in Wilkes-Barre/Scranton and more on how the Penguins manage the rest of their roster in the days ahead. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Loss Just Raised Bigger Questions About Where This Team Is Headed
The loss to the Canadiens did more than add another mark in the standings for Pittsburgh, it sharpened the sense that this season is drifting toward a tougher conversation about direction. There have been bright spots, including Tristan Jarrys consecutive shutouts, but the Penguins have also been living with the kind of uneven play that invites scrutiny from the coach and the front office alike.
Dan Muse now has a team that needs a reset in more ways than one, and the questions around the roster are only getting louder. Trade chatter keeps circling around names like Nikita Kucherov and Dylan Larkin, while the broader NHL landscape keeps moving around Pittsburgh, from Carolinas interest in Simon Edvinsson to the latest international hockey buzz, leaving the Penguins to decide what kind of next step they really want to take. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Got Caught In The Kind Of Game That Exposes Everything
The Penguins found themselves in the kind of game that can make a team look dangerous and vulnerable at the same time, with Montreal turning a loose, high-event night into another step in its recent surge. The Canadiens have been playing a more controlled brand of hockey away from home, and it showed in the way they managed the pace while still getting offense from a group that included Oliver Kapanen, Lane Hutson, Alexandre Texier and Chris Kreider.
For Pittsburgh, the result was a reminder of how quickly structure can disappear when the game opens up and the margin for mistakes shrinks. Montreal kept finding answers, and the Penguins were left dealing with a contest that exposed the edges of their game in a way that will linger beyond one loss, especially with the Canadiens continuing to build momentum on the road. [Read more 🡒]