The Pittsburgh Penguins spent too much of Saturday night in Montreal chasing their own mistakes.
They fell behind twice in rapid-fire fashion, dug into a hole they couldn’t fully escape, and left the Bell Centre with a 5-4 loss to the Canadiens despite a late push that made things interesting. Dan Muse’s club got a rare successful goaltender-interference challenge, but that was only one small win in a game packed with breakdowns.
Montreal struck quickly in both the first and second periods, and each time the Penguins looked disorganized getting back into shape. The Canadiens built a 5-2 lead before Pittsburgh finally steadied itself enough to make a game of it. Sidney Crosby’s rebound goal with the extra attacker at 16:49 of the third pulled the Penguins within one, but they couldn’t find the equalizer before time ran out.
Crosby finished with a goal and two assists, while Rickard Rakell, Tommy Novak and Erik Karlsson each posted a goal and an assist. No other Penguin recorded a point.
Muse’s team also had to navigate a rough night from Sergei Murashov, who made his first start since Oct. 17.
The 22-year-old rookie, coming in with an .883 save percentage and a 0-3-1 record, dropped to 0-4-1 on the season, the longest winless stretch of his professional career. He allowed a couple of goals that he’d probably want back, but he also came up with several strong stops in the third period, including a Philip Danault breakaway and a chance on Chris Kreider near the crease.
The shot totals tell part of the story, too. Pittsburgh had only nine shots through the first 33 minutes, then finished the second period with 14.
By the end of the night, the Penguins had outshot Montreal 29-27. Murashov stopped 22 of 27, and Jacob Fowler made 25 saves on 29 shots.
The Penguins did get some milestones out of the night. Karlsson’s two-point performance moved him into 10th place all-time among NHL defensemen in scoring with 951 points.
He sits one point ahead of Brent Burns and seven behind Larry Robinson for ninth. Crosby’s first-period assist pushed him past Ray Bourque for the most assists with one franchise at 1112, and he added another assist in the period to extend his all-time lead.
The game opened with a clean-looking power-play strike from Karlsson at 2:08 of the first period, a point shot that slipped through traffic and past Fowler for a 1-0 lead. But the advantage lasted only 33 seconds. After a turnover in the offensive zone, Montreal turned the Penguins around and Oliver Kapanen hammered home a one-timer from the left circle at 2:41.
Pittsburgh’s next mistake came almost immediately. Just 24 seconds after that tying goal, Sam Girard had nowhere to go under pressure and handed the puck off to Hendrix Lapierre, whose breakout pass was picked off by Chris Kreider. Kreider went top shelf over Murashov at 3:05 to put Montreal ahead 2-1.
The Penguins answered with a chaotic sequence of their own. Murashov nearly gave up an empty-net look to Cole Caufield, but instead made a quick save, poked the puck ahead to Crosby, and the Penguins turned it into a three-on-two rush. Crosby moved it to Rakell, Rakell found Novak, and Novak finished with a backhand deke through the fivehole at 7:28.
Muse also won a goaltender-interference challenge in the first period after Montreal defenseman Kaiden Guhle cut across the crease and made light contact with Murashov before the shot. The goal came off the board, and the game stayed tied.
The second period brought more of the same. Montreal scored twice in 27 seconds to stretch the lead to 4-2.
Alexandre Texier was left alone cutting to the net and beat Murashov at 1:54. Then Kreider was uncovered near the crease and scored again at 2:21 after Carlile chased the puck high and Lapierre failed to pick him up down low.
Muse used his timeout after that burst, and the Penguins responded with a better stretch. Karlsson picked off a breakout pass and fed Rakell in the slot, where Rakell beat Fowler with a hard wrister at 3:45 to make it 4-3.
Montreal answered once more before the period was over. Lane Hutson’s shot deflected off Josh Anderson in the slot, and the puck ended up in the net after it struck the back of Kris Letang’s legs. Anderson was credited with the goal at 5-3.
Pittsburgh’s final push came late, but it was too little too late. Crosby buried the rebound at 16:49, cutting the margin to one, yet the Penguins couldn’t get the tying goal and Montreal held on.
In Other News...
Penguins Loss Just Raised Bigger Questions About Where This Team Is Headed
The loss to the Canadiens left the Penguins with more than just another result to digest. It added weight to a stretch that has already been marked by uneven play, a coaching change in Dan Muse, and a roster that still has to answer basic questions about consistency. Even with Tristan Jarry coming off consecutive shutouts, the broader picture around Pittsburgh has not gotten any clearer, especially with trade chatter continuing to swirl around established names and the organization trying to sort out what comes next.
Muse now has a team that needs a reset as much as a response, and the next few days could tell a lot about how he plans to handle it. Lineup changes are on the table after the Montreal game, and the tone around the club has shifted from short-term fixes to something more fundamental about direction. For a Penguins team that has lived through plenty of eras already, the latest setback only sharpened the bigger question hanging over the season. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Just Created A New Opening For Rutger McGroarty
Rutger McGroarty is back with Wilkes-Barre/Scranton for now, and the move gives the Penguins a little more breathing room as they sort through the early part of their roster. Since making his NHL debut in the 2024-25 season, the young forward has already gotten into 34 games with Pittsburgh, scoring four goals and nine points, while also showing in the AHL that he can drive offense and hold his own over longer stretches.
For the Penguins, the assignment is less about closing the book on McGroarty than keeping him in the mix. He has been productive in the minors across two seasons, and his development remains one of the more interesting subplots on the roster. The open spot in Pittsburgh adds another layer to watch as the team continues to manage its forward group and decide when the next opportunity should come. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Got Caught In The Kind Of Game That Exposes Everything
The Penguins got dragged into exactly the kind of game that can make a team look brilliant and vulnerable in the same breath. Montreal kept pushing the pace and found offense from across the lineup, with Oliver Kapanen, Lane Hutson, Alexandre Texier and Chris Kreider all part of a night that kept the pressure on Pittsburgh from start to finish.
For the Canadiens, the road version of their game has looked more controlled than the looser, less disciplined style they have shown at home, and that showed up again in a result that tested Pittsburgh in every zone. The Penguins were left chasing a game that kept opening up, which is the sort of night that exposes defensive cracks and leaves a lot to sort through afterward. [Read more 🡒]