The Pittsburgh Penguins are out of the offseason and into the part where the questions get real.
Over the next few days, they’ll start sorting out who belongs, who doesn’t, and who gets a chance to force the issue. Hendrix Lapierre is one of the names already hanging over camp, and the logic behind that move is part of the larger debate around this roster. Pittsburgh gave up a 2027 third-round pick and a 2028 fifth-round pick to get him, yet he looks like no better than the 13th forward at this stage.
There are other players in that same lane, hoping for an opening. The problem is timing.
The Penguins have only three full-squad practice days before preseason games and cuts begin, so the runway is short. Around the team Friday, there was already word that a few soft decisions had been made, though those could still change if somebody plays well enough to demand attention.
One of the bigger recurring questions is why free agents keep signing with Pittsburgh when the club has built a reputation for piling up similar players and crowding the depth chart. The answer, from the team’s side, is pretty direct: Dubas doesn’t worry about losing players on waivers.
He made that clear on Aug. 7, 2023, when he spoke after the Erik Karlsson trade.
“We’re not going to be afraid to use waivers to get flexibility or lose guys. I’ve never operated that way.
You never know. You have this fear that if you put a guy on waivers, he’s going to go elsewhere,” said Dubas that day.
“We’ll just put them on (waivers), and we’ll wish them well. If they go and show us they’re better elsewhere, we’ll be happy for them.”
That approach helps explain why the Penguins keep adding bodies even when the opportunity looks thin. Lapierre is one example.
David Gustafsson is another; he has 149 NHL games and came in a trade for Jack St. Ivany.
But with the roster still taking shape, there are expected to be very few tryouts or invites beyond the players already under contract.
The youth question is just as crowded. Asked which young player could break through the way Kindel did last season, one possibility is Jake Livanavage.
He has a left-handed shot and one game of NHL experience, and his skating stands out. He also spent a full college career at North Dakota, skating in the Ralph Engelstad Arena, which the source called the “Palace on the Prairie,” perhaps the most beautiful hockey rink in North America.
Still, at 5-foot-10 and 174 pounds, he likely needs AHL time.
Tommy Galvas is a different story. He has not stood out in development camp or on the first day of Prospects Challenge practice, and at 5-foot-10, 168 pounds, he is very light.
Scouts like the skating, but right now he looks like a player still processing the game in front of him. He is 20 and a late bloomer, which helps explain why he went undrafted in his first two drafts.
For now, he belongs on the long-range radar.
If anyone is going to grab that third-pairing left-side role, the source points to 2022 first-rounder Owen Pickering.
Then there’s the biggest-picture question: what does success even look like this season?
The clean answer is playoffs or a first-overall pick, but the real danger sits in the middle. A top-three pick would not be a disaster for a rebuilding club, and making the playoffs would hardly be a bad outcome. The problem would be finishing with something like the 15th overall pick - not bad enough to land a premium selection, not good enough to play in the spring.
That is the true worst-case scenario: keeping Erik Karlsson for a playoff push, missing the playoffs anyway, and hanging onto veterans such as Rickard Rakell only to end up stuck in the middle. That outcome, the source argues, would be regrettable.
Anything else, though, comes with upside.
And one final note for next June: top players such as Bo Byram and Brady Tkachuk were acquired in trade packages that included a top-10 pick, while multiple players including Jordan Kyrou and Pavel Dorofeyev were acquired for a top-16 pick that then required significant additional compensation.
In Other News...
Penguins Rebuild Is Stuck Waiting For One Trade That Matters
The Penguins spent much of the offseason trying to turn prospects and draft picks into younger NHL help, but the market never really cooperated. General manager Kyle Dubas said the team explored ways to make impactful trades, yet the price tag on those kinds of moves kept climbing, leaving Pittsburgh with only minor additions while the bigger rebuild conversations stayed unresolved.
As training camp approaches, that puts the Penguins in an awkward middle ground. They have made clear they want to get younger and reshape the roster, but for now they are still waiting on the kind of deal that could actually change the direction of the rebuild. Until that happens, the summers most important work may end up being the one trade they could not quite complete. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Prospects Suddenly Have A Real Chance To Shake Up Plans
The Penguins are giving a fresh batch of prospects a meaningful stage this week, and for a few of them, the timing matters almost as much as the competition itself. Pittsburghs tournament roster includes Liam Ruck, Harrison Brunicke, Bill Zonnon, Peyton Kettles, Markus Ruck and goalie Matvei Nikonovich, a group that gives the organization a good look at some of its more interesting young pieces before the real grind of the season begins.
There are also some notable names missing, which only adds to the sense that this event could shuffle a few internal rankings if the right players seize the moment. For prospects still trying to move from promising to priority, a strong showing here can change how the Penguins talk about them, how they track their development, and maybe how quickly they become part of future NHL roster conversations. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Enter A Telling Stretch As Roster Questions Start Growing
As the Penguins prepare for training camp and the Prospects Challenge, the organization is also stepping into a stretch that feels bigger than the usual preseason tune-up. There is a little celebration mixed in as Phil and Amanda Kessel are set for induction into the US Hockey Hall of Fame, a reminder of how much star power and history still orbit the franchise even as the roster picture begins to take shape.
At the same time, the broader league rumor mill is already picking up. Trade talk has been active around Alexander Nikishin and Kirill Marchenko, with Marchenko still drawing interest from two teams even after Columbus general manager Don Waddell said he will stay put. For Pittsburgh, it is the sort of backdrop that makes this time of year feel especially telling, when what happens next can say a lot about how aggressive teams are planning to be. [Read more 🡒]