The Pittsburgh Penguins have built themselves into a strange shape: loaded at forward, thin on defense, and trying to make both sides of that equation work at once. On paper, it’s one of the NHL’s deepest groups up front and one of its weakest units on the blue line. That imbalance is at the heart of the team’s current problem.
General manager Kyle Dubas is trying to do two things at once - keep the Penguins competitive and carve out room for the next wave of young players. Those goals do not always fit neatly together, and the current roster makes that obvious. The Ville Koivunen extension adds another wrinkle, though it still does not guarantee him a place in the lineup.
If Pittsburgh carries 13 forwards, eight defensemen and two goaltenders, the club has somewhere between 16 and 18 real forward options for 13 spots. Sidney Crosby, Rickard Rakell Bryan Rust, Evgeni Malkin, Tommy Novak, Egor Chinakhov, Andrei Kuzmenko, Blake Lizotte and Nicholas Robertson are the names that look locked in right now.
Connor Dewar and Elmer Söderblom appear likely to take two fourth-line roles. That leaves two openings, and a crowded field behind them: Rutger McGroarty, Koivunen, Hendrix Lapierre, Justin Brazeau, Filip Hallander, Avery Hayes and Tristan Broz.
That is a tough squeeze for young players, especially McGroarty, Hayes and Broz. They were close last season, but there is a real chance they spend another long stretch in the AHL.
Camp will force the Penguins to answer a lot of questions. Who can be moved?
Who needs more time in the minors? Who has done enough to deserve a longer NHL look?
The more you study the roster, the more confusing the larger plan becomes. The Penguins do not look like a rebuilding team, but they also do not look fully committed to a retool. Maybe this is a final push with Crosby, Malkin and Kris Letang, and if that is the case, the pressure on the younger forwards rises even more.
McGroarty is a good example. He does not gain much from playing eight minutes a night in the NHL, but another year in the AHL would not do much for him either.
That leaves a hard question: is he actually a top-nine player for this team? Probably not, given the forward group as it stands.
For one of the Penguins’ most highly regarded prospects, that is a real issue.
Koivunen is in a similar spot. He has done plenty in the AHL, where he was better than a point-a-game player last season, but his NHL time told a different story.
In 39 games, he looked overmatched physically and finished with two goals and five assists. The Penguins know he needs to add a lot of muscle this summer, or he risks going the route of Conor Sheary, the former Penguins forward who was skilled and small but could get knocked off his game by the lightest contact.
Lapierre brings another layer to the logjam. Pittsburgh gave up two picks to get him from the Washington Capitals, and that move made sense then, but it looks more complicated now that the forward depth has grown.
He has shown flashes of being a top-nine NHL player, and that is what the Penguins want to find out this season. But if the numbers do not work in his favor, he could disappear into the crowd unless the team makes additional moves.
That is where the roster construction starts to feel upside down. The Penguins are carrying more forwards than they can comfortably play, while the defense - especially on the left side - still looks short.
They can expose players to waivers and hope for the best, but that seems like a risky path. Trading a forward makes more sense from an asset-management standpoint, though the next question is obvious: which one?
Brazeau and Hallander look like the most realistic candidates. Brazeau had a strong start last season before fading late, and his size and style could appeal to teams looking for a power forward on a tight budget.
Hallander also looked like an NHL forward before an injury ended his season. Neither player is a problem; both are simply caught in the numbers.
Dubas has repeatedly said internal competition matters, and there is logic to that. It can sharpen practices, deepen the lineup, push players to perform and keep everyone accountable.
It also gives younger players room to grow, even if there are bumps along the way, while giving the veterans support around them. But if that is the idea up front, the defense tells a different story.
Maybe Owen Pickering and Harrison Brunicke are ready for full-time NHL minutes. Maybe Dubas still has another move coming.
Either way, Pittsburgh is set to enter the 2026-27 season with an underwhelming defensive unit.
So the Penguins are left with one clear question heading into the season: can they give their next generation enough runway without shortchanging the final years of Crosby’s career? It is a delicate line, and Dubas appears determined to keep walking it.
In Other News...
Penguins Double Down On A Farm System Plan Fans Should Notice
The Penguins are making a point of continuity in the places where prospects are supposed to take their next steps. Pittsburgh announced the coaching staffs for Wilkes-Barre/Scranton and Florida for the 2026-27 season, keeping Kirk MacDonald in charge of the AHL affiliate and Brad Ralph at the helm of the ECHL club. Several assistant coaches and support staff were also confirmed or moved up, a sign the organization is leaning into a more stable development structure across both levels.
For a team trying to build better habits from the bottom up, these decisions matter almost as much as the moves at the NHL level. Wilkes-Barre/Scranton remains the critical bridge for players closest to Pittsburgh, while Florida continues to serve as a proving ground for younger prospects and depth pieces. The staff announcements do not grab the same attention as a trade or a draft pick, but they do tell you something about how the Penguins want their system to look in the years ahead. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Forward Logjam Is Fueling A Frustrating Debate About Youth
Ville Koivunens new eight-season extension has only sharpened the conversation around how the Penguins are handling their forward group and the next wave of talent. A player with limited NHL experience and production landing that kind of commitment is the sort of move that usually signals belief in a long runway, but it also lands at a time when the roster already feels crowded enough to make every opening feel precious. For a team trying to balance present-day competitiveness with a real look at the future, that is not a small question.
The debate gets even louder when the path for young forwards is already so narrow, because the Penguins are not the only club facing this kind of squeeze. Torontos crowded forward depth has become a cautionary example of how quickly prospects can get boxed out when veterans, proven middle-six pieces and contract decisions all pile up at once. For Pittsburgh, the issue is less about one player than the larger choice it keeps facing: how much patience to show with youth before the roster structure starts making that patience harder to sustain. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Fans Are Split On How Far This Rebuild Should Go
The Penguins are at the kind of crossroads that tends to stir up every version of the same debate all at once. With the roster aging in key spots and the trade and free-agent markets offering only so much help, the conversation has turned from simple tinkering to bigger questions about what the next phase should look like and how aggressively the front office should chase it.
That makes the hypothetical exercise around names like Harrison Brunicke, Shane Wright, Jason Robertson, Evgeni Malkin, Erik Karlsson and Sidney Crosby feel especially relevant, even if none of it is tied to a confirmed move. Some possibilities point toward a quicker retool, others toward a deeper reset, and the tension is in how far the Penguins should be willing to go before the roster finally starts to look different in a meaningful way. [Read more 🡒]