After the Pittsburgh Penguins’ opening-night demolition of the Philadelphia Flyers, the season has gone sideways in a hurry. The 7-0 win looked like the start of something, but 19 games later the Penguins have only four regulation victories and seven total. The problems have piled up: the young players haven’t really been folded in, the veteran free agents have battled injuries and inconsistency, Sidney Crosby is producing below his usual level, and the trade chatter keeps humming even though nothing else has happened.
The only move so far turned out to help. Pittsburgh sent forward Filip Hallander to the Edmonton Oilers and got depth defenseman Spencer Stastney back, a swap that eased some of the issues on a blue line that had been built in a way that didn’t fit together cleanly.
What’s followed has been uglier than a few close losses. These aren’t the kind of defeats where the Penguins can point to a strong effort and say they were unlucky. The mistakes have been obvious and repeated, and the old line about “there was a lot to like” just doesn’t fit.
Sidney Crosby is the first place most people look, and the numbers do show a dip. He’s on pace for about 55 points, which sits well below his 21-year run of point-per-game production.
Through 20 games, he has 13 points, with six goals and seven assists. But the full picture is more complicated than the point total.
His shooting percentage is 9.6%, his lowest since the 2017-18 season. At the same time, his Corsi is 53%, right in line with his career norms, his expected goals-for is 57%, his best mark in eight years, and his scoring chance rate is 58%. All of those numbers come from NaturalStatTrick.com.
So what’s behind the drop? Age is part of it, but not in the simplest way.
Crosby isn’t defending as well because opponents are getting on their toes and turning the Penguins into a team that has to chase in transition. He still thrives in the battles along the walls and in the corners, but that’s not the same as chasing Logan Cooley up and down the ice.
There’s also the issue of who’s been around him. Crosby hasn’t had a puck-retrieving winger for most of the season, and the Penguins as a whole aren’t getting enough initial possession.
The roster has talent, but not much grit, and the team keeps leaning into a rush game that doesn’t really suit it. They’re a puck-possession team without enough players who can actually establish possession, and Crosby is one of the players paying for that mismatch.
The coaching has taken heat too, but that doesn’t hold up either. Dan Muse has been trying to piece together forward combinations and find some stability, but the roster keeps forcing him to patch holes.
When one setup starts to work, another line falls apart. Tommy Novak and Egor Chinakhov can create one problem; Bryan Rust returning to Crosby’s line can create another, and then Rust suffers a six-week, or more, lower-body injury.
Nick Robertson and Hendrix Lapierre have also cooled off. Robertson has been carrying a heavy load on his own, while Lapierre has tried to stay defensively responsible around mistake-prone linemates, often drifting into the high F3 role just to keep things from breaking down further. The result is more imbalance, not less.
Last season, the Penguins had a better mix of bigger bodies and puck-getters. That’s gone now, replaced by players who can work with the puck only after someone else hands it to them.
Muse is coaching a team that isn’t fast, isn’t physical, and isn’t good at either kind of attack. The blame on him, as the piece puts it, is simply off base.
If there’s been one clear bright spot, it’s in goal. Penguins goalie coach Andy Chiodo deserves credit for that. Sergei Murashov had a rough stretch, and Arturs Silovs’ raw numbers are not pretty, but the process has still been a positive.
Murashov has bounced back well and picked up a couple of wins. Silovs has been left to deal with a steady stream of high-danger chances that would test any goalie. The Penguins have given up breakaways, two-on-ones and point-blank looks because of turnovers and coverage breakdowns, and that has made life miserable in front of both netminders.
Silovs has allowed the third-most high-danger goals against in the league with 18, putting him alongside goalies from Toronto, Chicago, Vancouver and Winnipeg in the top five. Murashov has handled those chances a little better, with an .813 save percentage on high-danger looks compared with Silovs’ .700. Both goalies also rank highly in terms of short-distance shots faced.
One more note on Silovs: among the 40 goalies who have played at least 400 minutes, he is tied for the league lead in fewest rebound chances given up with 29. After the rough season he had last year, that stands out as another step forward, even if the team in front of him hasn’t done nearly enough.
In Other News...
Sidney Crosby Just Became Pittsburghs Biggest Offseason Question
The offseason conversation around Sidney Crosby has gone far beyond routine speculation, and it now sits at the center of Pittsburghs biggest question. Josh Yohe of The Athletic reported that the Penguins are willing to entertain the possibility of moving Crosby, Evgeni Malkin or Kris Letang if any of the three veteran stars want a change, a striking stance for a franchise built around that core for so long.
For Pittsburgh, the real tension is not just what the organization is open to, but how much uncertainty remains around the captain himself. Malkin is reportedly open to a trade, while Letang is viewed as less likely to move because of his contract and declining performance, leaving Crosby as the franchise-defining name hanging over everything the Penguins do this summer. Most inside the organization still expect him back, but the lack of clarity is what makes this story linger. [Read more 🡒]
Rickard Rakell Trade Talk Just Hit A Major Penguins Roadblock
Rickard Rakell has been one of the more intriguing names to watch as the Penguins look ahead to the March 1 trade deadline, and for good reason. He has produced six goals and five assists in 20 games this season, and with Pittsburgh expected to at least listen on several veterans, his name naturally surfaced in trade chatter.
One of the teams linked to him was Chicago, but the path to a deal ran into a built-in obstacle. Rakells contract runs through 2027-28, and his no-trade protection gives him control over where he can go, which complicates any move Pittsburgh might try to make as the deadline approaches. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Veterans Could Be Caught In A Tough Trade Market
The Penguins are still working through an uneven stretch on the ice, and that has naturally pushed attention toward which veteran pieces could be available if the front office decides to reshape the roster. Around the league, there is no shortage of noise, from Jaromir Jagr reportedly preparing to retire to the Maple Leafs sliding into a losing streak, but the more relevant backdrop for Pittsburgh is a trade market that has not exactly been moving quickly.
One reason is the uncertainty surrounding Dylan Larkin, after Minnesota reportedly put a substantial offer on the table and Detroit turned it down. With questions lingering about whether the Red Wings are willing to meet his demands, the ripple effect could matter for teams like the Penguins, who have players that might draw interest but may not find an eager market waiting for them. For a club already dealing with its own struggles, timing could end up being as important as the names on the block. [Read more 🡒]
