Penguins Are Drifting Into The Rebuild Dubas Wanted To Avoid

Despite Dubas's careful planning, the Pittsburgh Penguins find themselves facing a rebuilding challenge that threatens to unravel their competitive edge.

Kyle Dubas spent the last couple of seasons trying to steer the Penguins around the kind of teardown that drags a franchise through years of pain. He pointed to teams like the Washington Capitals and LA Kings as proof that a quicker reset could work, and he made it clear he didn’t want the Detroit Red Wings or Chicago Blackhawks route.

That plan has run headfirst into reality anyway.

After another rough loss Saturday to the Ottawa Senators, the Penguins are staring at the exact kind of mess Dubas tried to avoid: an uncompetitive team, loud mistakes, frustrated fans and a roster that simply isn’t keeping up with good opponents. Through 20 games, Pittsburgh has only three regulation wins and seven total, sits double digits out of a wild-card spot and trails the New York Rangers by nine points for third in the Metro Division.

Dubas said in April of 2025, “Shortcuts cut long runs short,” and he also explained why he didn’t want a full-scale teardown. On April 21, 2025, he put it this way: “You can go into the mass teardown rebuild and hope you get lucky with the lottery and hope that all this happens,” Dubas said on April 21, 2025. “But you can hope in one hand and sh*t in the other, and see which one fills up first.”

He was still upbeat then, too. In that same presser, Dubas said, “I feel like we’re slightly better positioned (than last year) because of the young players here.

I’m more optimistic going into next year than I was organizationally. The results are going to be what they’re going to be, but I feel like we’re closer to where we want to get back to than last year.”

That optimism looks a long way off now. In November 2026, the Penguins are not closer.

The young players Dubas highlighted, including Rutger McGroarty and Ville Koivunen, have had a hard time getting into the lineup. Others have received more opportunity than they have, including Cody Glass, Philip Tomasino, Tommy Novak and Ryan Shea.

On Saturday, the lineup included only McGroarty and Sergei Murashov among those young pieces, while acquired young players on their second chance, Nick Robertson and Hendrix Lapierre, were also dressed. The rest of the group still leaned heavily on older veterans.

That’s part of what makes the current situation so frustrating for Pittsburgh. Dubas used his budget on veterans to fill spots and kept tradeable veterans in place, including Andrei Kuzmenko and Trevor van Riemsdyk, even as the organization tried to line up the next wave.

The idea was to bridge the gap. Instead, the bridge is wobbling.

It didn’t look this way a year ago. Dubas had a strong 2025 offseason, with Parker Wotherspoon, Anthony Mantha and Justin Brazeau all turning into notable free-agent wins.

He also moved Tristan Jarry and brought in Egor Chinakhov through trades. In the draft, the Penguins selected Ben Kindel and turned the 12th overall pick into extra picks that brought in Bill Zonnon and Will Horcoff.

That momentum vanished quickly in 2026.

The trade market shifted, and the kind of young talent Dubas hoped to target suddenly came with a premium. Buffalo dealt 25-year-old third-pairing defenseman Bo Byram to the Chicago Blackhawks for the fourth overall pick.

Ottawa captain Brady Tkachuk brought back the ninth overall selection, the 25th pick and a 2029 first-rounder from the Florida Panthers. Ottawa also landed William Eklund for that same ninth overall selection.

The message was clear: top-10 picks and elite young players were the currency, and Pittsburgh didn’t have enough to spend.

The Penguins have picked up a few wins against good teams this season, but the details matter. They beat a slumping Florida team on the second night of a back-to-back and caught a flat Dallas Stars group on an East Coast trip. Outside of those games, plus an opening-night rout of the Philadelphia Flyers, they haven’t put together many 60-minute efforts.

So here they are. The short-term fix never arrived, the window to jump ahead slammed shut, and the only path left is the one Dubas hoped to dodge: a long rebuild built on draft picks, development and a little luck. The Penguins are already out of it, and they look like a team that has blown it up without ever officially doing so.

To borrow Dubas’s own language, the only way forward now is to turn that into something useful. That means selling hope, collecting picks and building the next foundation before any bigger trades can happen.

In Other News...

Penguins Practice Sent A Clear Message About A Roster Shakeup

Dan Muses practice tweaks on Monday offered a pretty clear snapshot of where the Penguins are right now, with the coach shuffling his lines while the roster picture continues to settle. Rookie Sergei Murashov appears to have done enough to earn a place in the mix, and the days setup also reflected a team still sorting through health and availability as it tries to find the right combinations early.

Bryan Rust and Elmer Soderblom were both on injured ice before practice, with Rust skating but not at full intensity, which only adds to the sense that Pittsburgh is managing more than one moving part at once. Beyond the immediate lineup questions, the Penguins still have the larger backdrop of Erik Karlsson trade interest swirling around the league, along with broader NHL chatter that keeps the front office landscape from feeling settled for long. [Read more 🡒]

Erik Karlssons Place With The Penguins Suddenly Feels Less Certain

A positive week with two Penguins wins has briefly quieted some of the noise around the roster, but it has not made the bigger questions go away. Erik Karlsson remains one of the more complicated pieces in the picture, especially with trade interest from other teams hanging over him and his availability to the media becoming more limited as the conversation around his future grows louder.

The Penguins have also had to sort through the usual mix of on-ice growing pains and signs of progress, with Declan Carlile drawing scrutiny for recent mistakes before showing improvement and earning public backing from Dan Muse. For a team trying to stabilize itself while keeping an eye on what comes next, Karlssons situation is the one that still feels like it could shift the direction of the offseason. [Read more 🡒]

Penguins Lineup Shift Around Murashov Says Plenty About This Team

The Penguins are in a familiar stretch of juggling present needs with a little franchise nostalgia, with Saturday set to bring Marc-Andre Fleury, Larry Murphy, Jim Rutherford and Jack McGregor into the team Hall of Fame. On the ice, though, the focus stays on the here and now after Pittsburgh edged San Jose in a shootout and now turns to Ottawa at PPG Paints Arena with Sergei Murashov getting the start in goal.

The lineup movement around that game says plenty about where the Penguins are trying to keep things steady. Ilya Solovyov was sent to Wilkes-Barre/Scranton to clear room on the roster, while Trevor van Riemsdyk is back in the mix after practicing with the club, a small but telling reminder that every spot matters as Pittsburgh keeps sorting out its depth and trying to build on a win. [Read more 🡒]