The Carolina Hurricanes are one of the teams keeping a close eye on Erik Karlsson, and Pierre LeBrun of TSN says they’re still very much in the mix if Pittsburgh decides to open up shop.
LeBrun laid it out on TSN’s Early Trading, noting that the Penguins are headed toward seller mode and that Karlsson’s full no-move clause means any move would have to go through him and his camp. He said the plan is for Karlsson’s side to meet with Kyle Dubas, the Penguins’ GM, in the new year to sort out where things go from here. And if the door opens, Carolina is expected to be right there.
"They were the runners-up for Karlsson back in the summer of 23… had a ton of interest in him. I’m told they still do, and why wouldn’t they? They tried to sign John Carlson on July 1, Tampa swooped in and got him instead, but it tells you about maybe the one need that the Stanley Cup champions field, maybe they still have similar players… I expect the Hurricanes to be bidders if and when the Penguins open up.”
For Carolina, the fit is easy to understand. The Hurricanes have already shown they were serious about adding a defenseman of Karlsson’s type, and LeBrun’s reporting suggests that appetite hasn’t gone anywhere. They also have a little above $8MM in cap space, which gives them room to make a move work financially.
Karlsson, 36, is in the final season of his eight-year, $92MM contract, which carries an $11.5MM annual price tag. Even with Pittsburgh struggling, he’s still producing at a high level. He leads the Penguins with 19 points and is on pace for 71 assists, which would top his previous career best of 66 from 2015-16.
The Penguins, though, are in rough shape. They’re 7-10-2 and sitting at the bottom of the Eastern Conference, with little sign of a quick turnaround. That’s why the idea of moving a veteran like Karlsson is even on the table, especially if Pittsburgh wants to get younger.
Karlsson’s career path makes him one of the league’s most established blueliners. He was drafted 15th overall by Ottawa in 2008 and spent his early years with the Senators before being dealt to San Jose in 2018-19. In his final season with Ottawa, he had 62 points in 71 games and led the team in points, or tied for the lead, in each of the previous five seasons.
His run with the Sharks included a Norris Trophy in 2022-23, when he put up 25 goals and 76 assists for 101 points in 82 games, a career high. That season helped remind everyone just how dangerous he can still be when he’s rolling.
He’s also coming off his best year in Pittsburgh, finishing with 66 points in 75 games last season. He was one of the Penguins’ best players and helped carry the team for a long stretch after the Milan Olympics, when Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin were out. Across his four seasons in Pennsylvania, Karlsson has averaged more than 60 points per year.
The challenge, of course, is the contract. Because Karlsson has a full no-movement clause, he controls where this goes. Pittsburgh is also retaining nearly 87% of the deal, with San Jose holding back $1.5MM of the total AAV, so any trade would have to be carefully structured.
If the two sides ever got serious, Alexander Nikishin could be part of the conversation. The 24-year-old defenseman signed a one-year, $3MM deal after holding out all summer with a trade request.
He scored 11 goals and 33 points in his rookie NHL season last year while averaging a little over 18 minutes a night. He also won a Stanley Cup, and in his first game back with Carolina this season, he scored a goal and finished with three points against the Blackhawks while logging a little more than 20 minutes.
In Other News...
Penguins Trade Plans Just Hit A Rickard Rakell Roadblock
The Penguins offseason direction has already been clear enough: if theyre going to retool, the front office may have to turn some of its established veterans into draft capital and younger pieces. Rickard Rakell has been among the names floating around in that conversation, alongside Bryan Rust, as Pittsburgh weighs whether to keep leaning on older core players or start cashing in value for the future.
A new wrinkle surfaced this week when a rumor on the Spittin Chiclets Podcast suggested Rakell was part of a potential deal that never got off the ground. With the limited no-trade clause in play, the situation underscores how complicated these moves can get for a team trying to reshape its roster, and it leaves the Penguins still searching for a workable path if they want to move forward with their rebuild plans. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Defensive Depth Takes Another Turn With One Young Blueliner
Wilkes-Barre/Scrantons defensive shuffle continued with another move involving a young blueliner, as David Breazeale was sent back to the Florida Everblades. Breazeale had already logged four games with Florida this season, and his time in the Penguins organization has included a brief but useful look at the AHL level, where he has appeared in 11 regular-season games and picked up four points.
The timing comes as the Penguins head into a busy stretch with games against Hershey and Hamilton, along with special Veterans Day Celebration events on the calendar. For a club trying to manage its blue line depth while keeping an eye on development, Breazeales latest assignment is another reminder that the back end remains a fluid part of the roster picture. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Suddenly Have A Goalie Question Fans Will Want To Debate
The Penguins left San Jose with a win, but it was not the kind that settled much beyond the standings. Pittsburgh needed a shootout to get past the Sharks, and the night came with the sort of uneven team effort that tends to sharpen the conversation around the crease. In the middle of it, rookie Sergei Murashov gave the Penguins a performance that stood out enough to make the goaltending picture feel a little less simple than it looked a week ago.
For a club trying to sort out its next steps, those kinds of nights matter. A young goalie can change the tone of a room quickly, especially when the rest of the roster is still searching for consistency, and Pittsburgh now has a fresh debate on its hands about how much weight to give one strong outing. The result helps in the standings, but the bigger question is whether this was just a useful snapshot or the start of something more interesting in net. [Read more 🡒]