Connor Dewar didn’t arrive in Pittsburgh with much fanfare at the 2025 NHL trade deadline, but he left enough of a mark that the Penguins made sure he wasn’t going anywhere.
The Penguins picked up Dewar and defenseman Conor Timmins from the Toronto Maple Leafs for a fifth-round pick, a move that gave Pittsburgh a couple of bodies to evaluate down the stretch. Dewar, especially, turned that chance into something more. He had managed only three points in 31 games with Toronto, all assists, before landing with the Penguins, then suddenly looked like a different player in black and gold.
In 17 games with Pittsburgh, he put up four goals and seven points while bringing the kind of game that shows up in the dirty areas. He was a strong forechecker, he fought for space in front of the net, and he kept winning battles below the dots to extend possessions and create quality looks.
That stretch earned him a one-year extension in the offseason, and he responded in 2025-26 with the best season of his career. Dewar set personal bests with 14 goals, 16 assists and 30 points, while continuing to be one of the Penguins’ most reliable pressure players. On the fourth line, he was often the piece that made everything move.
Head coach Dan Muse leaned on that line when the Penguins needed a jolt, and Dewar was frequently the one setting the tone, whether it was with a hard hit or a productive offensive shift. At 5-on-5, Pittsburgh controlled 50.8% of the shot attempts, 51.2% of the expected goal share, 53.3% of the scoring chances and 51.8% of the high-danger chances with Dewar on the ice. The Penguins also outscored opponents by 11 goals in those minutes.
His value wasn’t limited to even strength, either. Dewar became a regular on the penalty kill alongside Blake Lizotte, logging a career-high 209:22 there. The two of them were dependable in the same ways: shot blocking, board work and clearing the puck.
Dewar also delivered in the playoffs against the Philadelphia Flyers, one of the few Penguins who had a strong series. He scored two goals and was all over the ice in every game, with Game 6 standing out as one of his best performances of the season even in a losing effort for Pittsburgh.
The Penguins could have let him hit unrestricted free agency in the summer, but instead they locked him up with a two-year extension carrying an average annual value of $2.25 million. Given his age, 27, and what he had already shown in Pittsburgh, it was an easy call.
For 2026-27, the expectation is pretty straightforward: keep him around that 15-goal range and keep him driving the fourth line. Dewar may not get the same minutes as some of the bigger names on the roster, but he makes his shifts matter. He’s also the kind of player a team can’t help but appreciate, and he could be a major reason the Penguins’ bottom six stays steady again.
In Other News...
Penguins Rebuild Now Hinges On One Big Dubas Prospect Question
Kyle Dubas spent the summer trying to speed up the Penguins rebuild, and the effort showed just how tricky the next phase in Pittsburgh has become. The organization has stockpiled a deep prospect pool, headlined by a 13-player 2025 draft class that includes first-rounders Bill Zonnon and Will Horcoff, giving the club a wave of young talent that should keep the pipeline busy for years.
The challenge now is less about finding enough promising players and more about figuring out how many can actually fit into the long-term picture. With several forwards and defensemen in the minors expected to develop into core pieces, the Penguins are staring at a possible surplus, which only sharpens the importance of every decision Dubas makes from here. The rebuild has talent coming in, but the real question is how much of that group can eventually turn into true impact players. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Core Faces A Brutal Reality Check Before 2026-27
The long view around the Penguins aging core is getting harder to ignore, even if Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, Kris Letang and Erik Karlsson still give the roster a very real competitive spine. Looking ahead to the 2026-27 season, the conversation is already shifting from what each of them has done to what kind of production still makes sense as time, health and workload start to matter more. Crosby remains the cleanest bet to keep piling up points, while Malkins value is tied as much to his usage and availability as it is to his finishing touch.
Letangs offensive expectations are also moving into a narrower lane, especially with goal production no longer the calling card it once was, and Karlssons point total will be judged against both his recent trend line and where the Penguins are by then. The projections for all four are rooted in recent performance and injury context, but the bigger picture is unavoidable: Pittsburghs veteran core is still productive enough to matter, yet each player now comes with a harder question about how much longer that level can hold. [Read more 🡒]