Avery Hayes’ rise has been one of the more interesting development stories in the Penguins’ system, and after last season, he’s suddenly on the radar as more than just an organizational depth piece.
The 23-year-old forward checks in at No. 13 in PensBurgh’s 2026 Top 25 Under 25, up from No. 18 a year ago. He was signed by the WB/S Penguins as an undrafted free agent before the 2023-24 season, and at 5-foot-10, 174 pounds, he has spent the last couple of years carving out a role the hard way.
His biggest breakthrough came in February 2026, when he was called up for his NHL debut against the Buffalo Sabres on Feb. 5 and scored two goals in the first period. That put him in rare air, making him just the seventh player in NHL history to score twice in his debut.
“I can’t really put it into words,” said the 23-year-old forward after his debut. “I’m just excited to see my family after they were able to make the trip. So, I have no words right now, but it was a ton of fun.”
The NHL scoring touch didn’t carry over in a straight line, though. After the Penguins sent him back to the AHL during the Olympic break, Hayes responded with a hat trick in his next game and then another three-goal outing 11 days later.
When he returned to the NHL after the Olympics, production came much harder. He went without a point from Feb. 26 through March 14, then scored his third career goal in the Penguins’ 8-3 win over the New York Islanders on March 30.
He closed the regular season with two goals in a 7-5 loss to the St. Louis Blues on April 14.
In all, Hayes appeared in 16 games for Pittsburgh last season and worked mostly in a bottom-six “energy guy” role. He scored five goals while averaging 11:10 of ice time per game.
That’s not a massive NHL sample, but it did offer a glimpse of something more than pure hustle. Hayes has enough finishing ability to make you wonder whether there’s a little more offense in there if he gets a longer look.
His AHL numbers are what really make him stand out. Hayes finished the 2025-26 season with 39 points in 42 games, plus 48 penalty minutes, and he added three more goals and 40 penalty minutes in 15 Calder Cup playoff games as Wilkes-Barre/Scranton reached the Eastern Conference Finals. His 24 goals led all WB/S forwards, even with the time he missed at the NHL level, and his 39 points made him one of the club’s most productive offensive threats.
Over 131 regular-season AHL games, Hayes has put up 53 goals, 90 points and 112 penalty minutes. That blend of scoring, edge and activity is exactly why he’s such an appealing call-up candidate.
He’s not one of the highest-ceiling names in the Penguins’ prospect pool, but his mix of NHL experience, AHL production and proximity to a regular job makes him stand out. He can fit into a bottom-six role with his speed, tenacity and ability to finish, and he brings the kind of pest-like game that can bother opponents while still creating chances through forechecking.
The question now is whether that offense can follow him up for good. With the Penguins’ forward depth chart crowded, Hayes doesn’t have much room for mistakes as he tries to lock down a steady NHL spot.
For now, he looks more like a top call-up option than a lock to stay. Even so, for an undrafted player who has already made it to the NHL at 23, that’s a pretty strong place to be.
In Other News...
Tristan Broz Faces A Tough Penguins Reality He Cant Control
Tristan Broz has already shown enough in the AHL to keep his name in the Penguins conversation, but his path to a steady NHL role has been anything but smooth. Injuries have interrupted his momentum, and with Pittsburgh already having depth at center, every missed stretch has made it harder for the young forward to turn a debut into something more permanent.
The latest wrinkle is Tommy Novaks arrival, which only tightens the competition for ice time down the middle. For Broz, the challenge is no longer just about proving he can play at the NHL level. It is about staying healthy long enough to force the Penguins to make room for him, and right now that part of the equation is still out of his control. [Read more 🡒]
Penguins Veterans Could Be Playing For Their Pittsburgh Future
The Penguins are heading into camp with a familiar tension hanging over the roster: a strong season behind them, but not much offseason change to build on it. With the core getting older and new ownership focused on long-term success, this fall feels less like a victory lap and more like a proving ground for veterans who still matter to the teams present, but may not fit neatly into its future plans.
That puts a spotlight on names such as Erik Karlsson and Evgeni Malkin, along with newer additions Samuel Girard, Justin Brazeau and Andrei Kuzmenko, as the front office weighs what comes next. Pittsburgh also has significant cap space available next offseason, which gives the club room to keep pieces in place or pivot if the season points it in another direction. [Read more 🡒]
Kyle Dubas Has Created A Penguins Camp Battle Fans Will Watch
A packed camp and a shortened preseason have turned the Penguins roster fight into one of the more interesting early storylines around the team, especially for younger forwards trying to break through. Justin Brazeau is part of that mix after a breakout season that saw him score 18 goals and 36 points, yet he still enters this stretch without a clear place to stand on the NHL roster.
Kyle Dubas has kept the board moving with a series of veteran and youth-related decisions, which has only made the picture messier for the players hoping to carve out room. The recent addition of Andrei Kuzmenko did not exactly open the door for the younger group, either, leaving names like Elmer Soderblom, Rutger McGroarty, Hendrix Lapierre, Avery Hayes and Nick Robertson all fighting for attention while the Penguins also face a trade market that looks unlikely to deliver a major fix. [Read more 🡒]