Pitt Wasted Another Defensive Effort In A Loss Fans Know Too Well

After a tough defeat, the Pitt Panthers face scrutiny over offensive missteps and quarterback challenges in their clash against the Florida State Seminoles.

Pitt’s trip to Florida State turned into the kind of grinder that leaves you staring at the box score and still not finding much comfort. The Panthers managed only 10 points in a 16-10 loss, their lowest scoring output since they put up just seven in the regular-season finale against Miami last year.

It was ugly in the way low-scoring ACC games can be ugly. Pitt finished with 306 total yards, while Florida State had 260. The Panthers are now 6-4 overall and 3-4 in ACC play, which has an all-too-familiar feel after 2024, when Pitt got off to a strong start before injuries helped send the season sideways and ended up 3-5 in the league.

The defense did enough to keep Pitt in it. Florida State was held to 16 points, its lowest total of the season, and quarterback Ashton Daniels never really found a rhythm.

Daniels finished with 163 passing yards, 25 rushing yards and was sacked twice. His longest completion went for 46 yards, but Pitt largely kept the Seminoles from piling up explosive plays.

The numbers on third down and in the red zone tell the same story. Florida State went 3-of-13 on third down and 1-of-4 in the red zone. Pitt also recorded five tackles for loss and forced two fumbles, recovering one of them.

The problem was on the other side, where Pitt had to turn to freshman Corey Dailey for his second career start because Holden Geriner was dealing with an injury. Dailey had moments, but the night was a tough one overall. He threw for 157 yards, one touchdown and one interception, added 58 rushing yards and took two sacks.

There were flashes of something there, especially with his legs, but asking him to engineer a game-winning 98-yard drive in the fourth quarter was a heavy lift. He also had trouble getting on the same page with Malik Knight and Blue Hicks.

Some throws were there but not secured. Others were simply off target, forcing receivers to make difficult adjustments just to have a chance at the catch.

That’s part of why the staff had leaned on Geriner before this. He may not bring the same mobility, but he offers more veteran experience and better reads. Behind Dailey, Pitt’s quarterback depth is still made up of younger, even less experienced options, so staying with him made sense rather than turning to a fourth choice.

Still, the biggest head-scratcher was the play calling. Offensive coordinator Kade Bell and the staff kept asking Dailey to throw into tough situations, including several 10-plus-yard passes on short third and fourth downs. The final blow came when Dailey missed a 14-yard throw on fourth-and-four.

At other points, Pitt called screen passes or handoffs on second or third down when there was still too much ground to cover. That inconsistency stood out in a game where the Panthers needed every possession to count.

Pitt has now lost every one-possession game this season except the Virginia Tech game, when the Hokies missed a field goal at the end. The Panthers still haven’t shown they can finish a game with a winning drive or a two-minute drill, and they only got close here because of a roughing the passer call.

The regular season ends with road games at 7-3 Louisville and 3-7 California. At this point, Pitt needs to show it can still beat teams that aren’t sitting at the bottom of the conference.

In Other News...

Pitt Just Showed Why Early Deficits May Not Rattle This Team

Road wins rarely come easily, and Pittsburgh had to work through one of those familiar early-game tests at Butler before settling in and taking control. The Panthers answered with a much sharper second half, leaning on Jonathan Powells 17 points and a defense that tightened as the game wore on. Baye Ndongo and Chase Foster gave Pitt useful minutes in the frontcourt, helping steady the team after the opening stretch.

What stood out most was how little the deficit seemed to shake this group once it found its rhythm. Pitts energy on that end of the floor changed the tone of the game, with Jalil Bethea providing a noticeable defensive lift despite limited offense. For a team still trying to establish its identity in tough road spots, this was the kind of response that suggests an early hole does not have to become a bigger problem. [Read more 🡒]