Virginia Tech’s 35-33 loss to Pitt ended with a kick that still has people squinting at slow-motion replays.
With three seconds left Friday night at Lane Stadium, senior kicker John Love lined up for a 36-yard field goal from the right hash. The official stationed beneath the upright waved it no good, and ESPN’s broadcast never provided a clean look from below the post to settle the debate in real time.
But once the clip hit X, the argument took off fast. From ESPN’s end zone angle behind Love, the ball appears to sneak inside the left upright. Fans behind the end zone were already celebrating before the call stood, and Love himself believed he had drilled it.
One fan seated behind the goal post, Caden Mcleary, posted his own back-angle video and kept it simple: "It was in."
Other zoomed-in looks from beneath the post make the whole thing even messier, with the ball crossing right near the tip of the upright, where inside and outside are almost impossible to separate.
Former NFL linebacker Will Compton, who co-hosts the Bussin' With The Boys podcast, jumped into the discussion too, posting a video and demanding proof. "If he missed it, fine," Compton said.
"But I need confirmation. It felt like he could have possibly made that kick."
The reason the call could not be revisited comes straight from the rulebook. College football only allows replay review on a field goal when the ball passes lower than the top of the uprights.
If it goes above the posts as it crosses the end line, there’s no review available, and the official’s call under the upright stands. To count, the entire ball has to pass between the inside edges of the uprights.
If it sails over the top of a post, it’s no good.
Virginia Tech head coach James Franklin made his feelings clear after the game. He opened his press conference by praising his team before turning to the final kick.
"From our perspective, that ball appeared to go through the uprights, and for the game to come down to a call of that magnitude, I believe there needs to be absolute clarity about how that decision was made," Franklin said.
He added later, "We can accept losing a football game. What we need is confidence that the game was decided correctly."
Those comments could bring a reaction from the Atlantic Coast Conference. The league’s sportsmanship policy prohibits public criticism of officials, and it already fined Pitt head coach Pat Narduzzi $5,000 for criticizing referees after a win over West Virginia.
The call capped a brutal finish for Virginia Tech, which dropped to 4-1 after committing four turnovers. The loss was Franklin’s first in Blacksburg. Pitt improved to 5-0 and 2-0 in conference play, even after losing starting quarterback Mason Heintschel to an apparent right knee injury early in the second half.
In Other News...
Mason Heintschel Faces A Huge Pitt Test In Hostile Territory
Mason Heintschels season has already offered a little of everything for Pitt, with some games showing the sophomore quarterbacks big-play upside and others reminding everyone how uneven a young passer can be. Now he gets his next major proving ground as the Panthers head to Virginia Tech for their first road game of the season, a setting that will ask as much about poise and command as it does about arm talent.
Heintschel has been unbeaten away from home in his college career, which gives Pitt reason to believe he can handle a difficult night in a hostile stadium. Still, road games have a way of exposing even small cracks, and this one feels especially important for both the quarterback and the Panthers as they try to establish some consistency early in the season. [Read more 🡒]
Pitt Just Became A Much Bigger Problem For Miami
Pitts unbeaten start kept rolling in dramatic fashion Saturday, and the Panthers needed every bit of it. Virginia Tech lined up for a 36-yard field goal on the final play with a chance to steal the game, but John Love missed, sending Pitt home with a 35-33 win and another reminder that Pat Narduzzis team is not going away quietly. The victory pushed the Panthers to 5-0, a mark that has only fueled the frustration around how theyre being viewed nationally.
Narduzzi made clear afterward that he believes his team has earned more respect from AP poll voters, and the conversation around Pitt is only getting louder. It helps that the Panthers found a way to survive even after starting quarterback Mason Heintschel left with a knee injury, with backup Holden Geriner stepping in to help finish the job. For Miami, a ranked-checking week just got a lot more complicated, because Pitt keeps stacking wins and finding different ways to answer every challenge. [Read more 🡒]
Pitt Gets A Rare Chance To End The Doubts At Virginia Tech
Saturdays trip to Virginia Tech gives Pitt something it does not often get this deep into a season, a clean chance to sort out how real it is. The Panthers and Hokies both arrive at 4-0, both are tucked just outside the AP Poll, and the ACC meeting carries a bit of rarity with it as the first game between two unbeaten power-conference teams that are unranked.
For Pitt, that makes this more than just another road test. It is the kind of matchup that can settle the early doubts that linger around an undefeated team before league play fully starts to frame the race, especially with two programs that have looked sharp enough to keep their records intact but still need proof against a quality opponent. The stakes are simple enough, even if the larger picture is not: leave Blacksburg with the same record, and the conversation around the Panthers changes fast. [Read more 🡒]