Pete Rose’s Hall of Fame case is back in the spotlight after President Trump announced a posthumous pardon for the late Cincinnati Reds icon on Thursday.
“I have just given a Complete and Total Pardon to the Late, Great Pete Rose, a true Baseball SUPERSTAR & LEGEND,” Trump posted on Truth Social.
The pardon is unlikely to change much when it comes to the Hall of Fame vote itself, but it does wipe away the two counts of filing false tax returns Rose admitted to in 1990.
Rose’s road to Cooperstown already took a major turn in May of 2025, when Major League Baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred posthumously removed him from the permanently ineligible list. That move made Rose eligible for election into the National Baseball Hall of Fame.
Even with that opening, the debate around Rose has stayed as loud as ever. Plenty of Reds fans - and a good chunk of baseball fans beyond them - believe his work on the field should have been enough to get him in long ago.
But the decision won’t be made by the public. It will come from a 12-person panel that meets next year.
Reds fans will have to wait until next December to learn whether the Classic Baseball Committee decides Rose belongs in Cooperstown.
There’s no argument about what Rose did as a player. He remains baseball’s all-time hits leader, and his 4,192nd hit, a base knock on September 11, 1985 against the San Diego Padres, stands as one of the defining moments in Reds history.
What complicates everything is the gambling scandal that led to his permanent ban from baseball in 1989. For some fans, that’s the end of the discussion. For others, MLB’s embrace of sports books and betting apps only makes Rose’s exclusion look more contradictory - and strengthens the case for the 17-time All-Star.
In Other News...
Phillies Just Got Another Reminder Their Pitching Pipeline Is Turning Heads
The Phillies pitching development work keeps drawing outside attention, and the latest example is Casey Weathers landing a job with the Athletics as their Major League pitching coach. Weathers had been Philadelphias director of pitching development, where he played a role in helping shape several pitchers as the organization continued to build one of the more respected arms pipelines in the game.
Felix Reyes is another reminder that the system is still producing names worth watching. After a demotion to Triple-A, he has turned in strong work in the Dominican Winter League, giving the Phillies another player whose progress bears monitoring as the winter unfolds. For an organization that has leaned hard into pitching depth, those are the kinds of developments that keep the front office and player development staff in the spotlight. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Linked To Costly Outfield Fix With Real Roster Risk
The Phillies outfield remains one of the clearest pressure points on the roster, and Brandon Marshs name has already surfaced as a possible trade chip as the front office weighs ways to fix it. One of the more aggressive ideas floating around is a run at Randy Arozarena, with ESPNs Davis Schoenfield projecting Philadelphia could be willing to chase the free agent on a deal that would land near $100 million.
Arozarena would bring name value and upside, but the fit comes with real roster risk. His defense has been a concern, and signing him would also mean giving up draft picks because of the qualifying offer attached to him, a cost that makes the decision more complicated for a club trying to improve without weakening its long-term pipeline. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies May Need A Bigger Catcher Upgrade Than Fans Expected
As the Phillies sort through their offseason priorities, catcher has quietly become one of the more interesting spots on the board. The front office is weighing upgrades in the bullpen and outfield too, but the search behind the plate has taken on extra weight because the offense there has lagged, and the team is looking at ways to add more impact without losing flexibility elsewhere.
Hunter Goodman has surfaced as one possible answer, and the appeal is obvious. The Rockies catcher brings a younger bat and enough offensive production to make him more than just a depth piece, while his ability to help in the outfield adds another layer to the fit. Even with J.T. Realmuto still under contract, the Phillies appear to be considering whether a bigger move at catcher could give them a more complete lineup going into next season. [Read more 🡒]
