Andrew Painter has given the Phillies enough to keep him in the conversation. He has not, however, given them enough to start dreaming about him as a postseason safety net.
That’s the lesson from Tuesday night, when the 23-year-old right-hander got knocked around by the Houston Astros in a 2022 World Series rematch. Painter allowed five earned runs on 10 hits, including two homers, and two walks. Christian Walker’s three-run shot set the tone as Houston jumped out fast and left the Phillies trying to dig out of a hole.
To Painter’s credit, he kept going and got through five innings, which spared an overworked bullpen from having to cover even more ground. But the damage was already done, and the outing looked a lot like the kind of rough start that pushed him down to Lehigh Valley earlier this season.
That’s what makes this whole Painter conversation tricky for the Phillies. He’s been a long, messy project.
The Florida high schooler went 13th overall in 2021, dominated minor league hitters early in his pro career, then lost all of 2023 and 2024 to Tommy John surgery. When he returned to Triple-A in 2025, he posted a 5.40 ERA.
The Phillies still handed him an Opening Day rotation spot this year, and it blew up. In 14 appearances before his demotion, he put up a 7.06 ERA in 65 innings.
Then came the second chance. Philadelphia brought him back up just before the trade deadline, and for more than a month he looked like a different pitcher.
Entering Tuesday, Painter had thrown 40 ⅓ innings with a 3.12 ERA since the promotion. That stretch was enough to show real progress.
It was not enough to rewrite who he is right now.
And that matters when the calendar turns to October.
The Phillies do not need a five-man rotation in the playoffs, and they already have four starters who look better suited for that setting. Zack Wheeler, Cristopher Sánchez and Jesús Luzardo form a fearsome top three, and a resurgent Aaron Nola should be able to handle Game 4 when needed. That leaves Painter on the outside looking in if Philadelphia trims the rotation the way most teams do in the postseason.
A move to the bullpen seems likely. The Phillies’ relief corps leaves them little choice, and Painter’s arm could still matter there. But that does not mean he should be dropped into the biggest moments.
For one thing, he has almost no relief experience. In his entire professional career, he has appeared in only two games that he didn’t start, and both came earlier this season as a bulk arm behind an opener. He has never worked as a true reliever.
More important, the Phillies still do not have enough reason to trust him with the season hanging in the balance. The turnaround has been real, and it’s been encouraging to see him inch toward becoming a useful big leaguer. But a few strong starts over a little more than a month do not suddenly make him the guy you hand the ball to in a close October game.
That’s asking too much of a pitcher who has already been through plenty. The Phillies need their established core to carry them if they want to avoid being remembered as a talented team that couldn’t finish the job.
Painter can help them. He has earned a postseason roster spot, and he can absorb innings if needed.
But using him in high-leverage situations would be a mistake.
In Other News...
Phillies Face A Real Center Field Debate Before October
The Phillies have spent much of the summer looking like a club built for October, but the final weeks have still left a few lineup questions hanging over them. Center field is one of the most interesting ones, with Justin Crawford bringing speed, range and a steady glove even as his offensive production has stayed modest enough to invite outside debate about whether the Phillies should chase more punch in the lineup.
For a team trying to win its first World Series since 2008, the choice says as much about playoff construction as it does about any one player. Crawford has remained the likely option in center field heading into the postseason, which suggests the Phillies value the balance he brings even if the bat has not fully matched the demands of an October lineup. [Read more 🡒]
Derek Hill Is Becoming A Phillies Folk Hero For More Than One Reason
Derek Hill arrived in Philadelphia in early June and has spent the months since looking like the kind of depth piece fans quickly adopt. He has come through with clutch hits, including multiple pinch-hit home runs, and he has given the Phillies a jolt in the field as well, making several notable defensive plays on balls with high catch probabilities. For a team that values every edge in a tight race, Hill has managed to provide a little bit of everything.
Hill has also started to build a reputation around town that goes beyond box scores. After games, he has been spotted helping local Philadelphians with everyday problems, including changing flat tires, which only adds to the sense that he has become a genuine favorite in a hurry. In a city that embraces players who show up when it matters, Hills appeal is growing for reasons that have just as much to do with character as production. [Read more 🡒]
Cubs Face A Tough Seiya Suzuki Decision As Interest Builds
The Phillies have made no secret of their hunt for a right-handed hitting outfielder, and Seiya Suzuki has quickly emerged as a name worth watching. For a club looking to add more balance to its lineup, Suzuki checks the obvious boxes, especially after the strong stretch he has put together and the broader sense that Philadelphia could use another established bat to help anchor the corner-outfield mix.
Chicago, of course, still has a say in how this plays out, and that is where the intrigue starts to build for Phillies fans. Suzuki is drawing interest for a reason, but whether he stays with the Cubs or becomes part of Philadelphias offseason push is still very much unsettled, leaving the Phillies to watch a market that could shape how their lineup looks next year. [Read more 🡒]