The Phillies have enough going right to feel good about their pitching staff, but one bullpen spot has become impossible to gloss over.
Philadelphia’s starting rotation has been excellent, and the offense has been better lately than it was for most of the 2026 season. Jhoan Duran has also settled in as a strong closer. The issue comes before the ninth inning, where the Phillies still need someone they can trust to bridge the gap to Duran.
Right now, Orion Kerkering is making that job harder than it should be.
After another rough outing in a big game against the Atlanta Braves, Matt Gelb of The Athletic pointed to a problem that has clearly grown too large to ignore. As Gelb wrote, "It was hard not to think about October - and the inning that came before Kerkering's latest stumble," Gelb writes.
"... And Kerkering, the man who was once the shiny new bullpen toy like McFarlane is now, remains a symbol of past postseason bullpen failures."
The contrast with Alex McFarlane was hard to miss. One inning before Kerkering gave up a two-run homer that pushed the Braves well ahead, McFarlane worked a clean seventh. That kind of performance only sharpened the case for a bullpen change.
With Duran locked into the closer role and Jonathan Bowlan handling eighth-inning work for much of the season, McFarlane looks like the obvious candidate to move up into the next spot. Kerkering, at this point, does not.
The numbers back that up. Kerkering’s ERA is now 4.12, and the recent stretch has been brutal.
Over his last four appearances, he has posted a 12.27 ERA, with three walks and just two strikeouts. In his last 10 outings, that ERA is 7.71.
That simply is not the profile of a high-leverage reliever, especially when McFarlane keeps showing he can be counted on more often than not.
The Phillies are not going to cut ties with Kerkering, but they do not need to keep running him out there in important spots. Duran, Bowlan, and McFarlane have been Philadelphia’s three best relievers this season, and the hierarchy should reflect that.
That would push Kerkering into lower-leverage work alongside Jose Alvarado and Brooks Raley, which is where he belongs until he starts pitching better. The Phillies have a fix in front of them, and McFarlane’s recent run makes it an easy one to make.
In Other News...
Luis Arraez Is Forcing A Phillies Tradeoff Fans Can't Ignore
Since joining the Phillies on Aug. 4, Luis Arraez has given the club exactly what it expected in one respect and a little less in another. The contact-heavy infielder has settled into a .288/.302/.396 line in Philadelphia, a step down from what he was doing earlier with the Giants, but his value has never really been about loud power or eye-catching exit velocity. It has been about putting the ball in play, and the Phillies have kept him in the middle of their daily puzzle because of that.
The harder part is what Arraez has done to the rest of the lineup. His arrival has forced defensive reshuffling, with Alec Bohm and Bryson Stott among the players taking on new responsibilities, and that kind of tradeoff always puts a roster under a little more strain. Arraezs production still carries the kind of profile that can swing with BABIP and the kind of luck that tends to even out over time, which leaves the Phillies weighing present fit against the version of him they believe is still in there. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Prospects Sudden Health Fight Put Baseball In Perspective
Gabriel Barbosas rise through the Phillies system had been one of those quieter prospect stories that starts far from the spotlight and builds one level at a time. The right-hander came up from Brazil, advanced through the minor league ladder in Philadelphias organization and was beginning to look like another arm worth tracking, the kind of development path teams and fans follow closely when the long season starts to thin the herd.
Now baseball has been shoved far into the background. Barbosa was diagnosed with Stage 3 colon cancer in 2026 while expecting his first child, and a GoFundMe has been set up to help cover medical and family expenses, organized by the Rockies scout who first signed him. It is the sort of news that turns a prospect report into something much more human, a reminder that the games next call-up can be fighting a far bigger battle away from the field. [Read more 🡒]
Andrew Painter Just Forced A Real Phillies October Debate
Andrew Painters season has turned into one of the more interesting subplots on the Phillies roster, because the version of him theyre getting now looks a lot different from the one that got knocked around early and wound up in Triple-A. After that rough start, he went back to work, sharpened his pitching and, most notably, improved his changeup before returning to the big league club with more bite and better results in his recent outings.
Even with the rebound, the October conversation is not really about whether Painter has helped himself. It is about where the Phillies can best use him if the roster is built for a deep run, and the expectation right now is that he will not crack the primary postseason starting rotation. The more likely path is a role in the middle innings, which says plenty about how far he has come and how much value the Phillies think he could still provide in a shorter burst when the games get bigger. [Read more 🡒]