The Phillies have already made some moves to shore up their catching depth, but the job behind J.T. Realmuto still isn’t finished.
That’s the real issue Philadelphia is staring at this offseason. Realmuto is not going anywhere, even after the worst offensive season of his career, because no club is stepping in to take on the final two years and $45 million left on his deal. So the Phillies are looking for something more practical: a reliable partner who can lighten the load and keep him from having to grind through another everyday workload.
That was the same objective heading into 2026, but Garrett Stubbs and Rafael Marchan didn’t give the club enough to make that plan work. Their struggles pushed Realmuto into heavier usage than the Phillies wanted, and the team has spent this offseason trying to reshape the depth chart behind him.
The first change came when Stubbs was designated for assignment. Then, before the non-tender deadline, Marchan agreed to a contract that likely comes in a bit below the $1 million he was projected to earn in arbitration. He remains in the mix for the backup job, but Philadelphia is still searching for a real answer at the position.
So far, the additions have tilted more toward depth than impact. Brian Navarreto, who signed a minor league deal, brings 42 games of big league experience, but his .183/.221/.338 slash line and 55 OPS+ show how little he has produced at the plate. The Phillies have long valued defense at catcher, and Navarreto is seen as a solid glove-first option.
Blake Hunt adds a different look. The 28-year-old was a second-round pick in the 2018 MLB Draft and made his major league debut with the San Diego Padres in 2026, going 0-for-3 in two games. At Triple-A, though, he has shown more promise with a .258/.333/.465 line across 808 plate appearances, along with 32 home runs and 39 doubles.
That gives Philadelphia more usable depth in the minors, but it still leaves the big-league picture incomplete. The Phillies should keep pushing for a more established No. 2 catcher if they want to trim Realmuto’s workload and give the roster a better balance behind the plate.
Joey Bart is no longer available, but there are still names out there who would make sense as a complement to Realmuto, including Carson Kelly and James McCann.
In Other News...
Phillies Have An Obvious Low-Risk Reunion To Consider
The Phillies are heading into the offseason with a familiar checklist, and the outfield sits near the top of it. They need depth, they need versatility, and they could use a right-handed bat who can move around the diamond without forcing the roster into a corner. That is why Matt Vierling has surfaced as a sensible name to watch after being non-tendered by Detroit.
Vierling would not solve every issue, but he fits the kind of low-risk reunion Philadelphia can explore without overcommitting. He can handle the outfield and third base, and when healthy he showed enough production in 2024 with a .257 average, 16 homers and 57 RBIs to suggest there is still useful value there. For a Phillies club trying to patch multiple holes, a player like that makes sense as the sort of depth move that can quietly matter by the end of the season. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Face A Risky Trade Debate That Could Reshape The Lineup
The Phillies are again weighing whether to make a move to boost an offense that has left them looking for more balance, and one name that keeps surfacing is Zack Gelof. The Athletics infielder brings the kind of versatility front offices love, along with enough power potential to make him an intriguing fit for a lineup that could use another movable piece.
Gelofs appeal is obvious, but so is the cost. Philadelphia would likely have to part with meaningful talent, with prospect Gage Wood among the kinds of assets that could come up in a deal, and any real progress would hinge on talks with Oaklands new president of baseball operations, Taylor Smith. For the Phillies, the question is whether Gelofs upside and flexibility are worth paying a premium for a player whose track record still leaves some uncertainty. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Take A Low-Risk Flier On A Bat Worth Watching
The Phillies added another interesting name to their catching mix by signing Ricardo Olivar after he elected free agency following the 2026 season. A versatile outfielder and catcher, Olivar brings a profile that is easy to understand for a team looking for depth: there is some bat-to-ball intrigue, some power potential from his minor league work and enough positional flexibility to make him worth a look.
Olivar is expected to enter spring training in 2027 with a chance to compete for the backup catcher job, which gives the Phillies a low-risk evaluation of a player whose offensive upside has drawn attention. The question, as it has been for much of his professional career, is whether the bat can carry enough value to offset the defensive limitations that have left analysts divided on his Major League future. [Read more 🡒]
