The Phillies have spent the past five weeks trying to solve the same problem and still don’t have an answer.
After optioning Andrew Painter to Triple-A on June 17, Philadelphia went shopping for a better fifth starter. The move came after the rookie right-hander had been hit for more than seven earned runs per nine over his first 65 big league innings. Since then, the market hasn’t given them much to work with.
Around the league, the rotation movement has been light. The Mets sent David Peterson to the Cubs a week after Painter was demoted.
Milwaukee took a shot on Lance McCullers Jr. and added Colton Gordon by absorbing part of McCullers’ salary from Houston. Beyond that, there hasn’t been much action.
For the Phillies, the stopgap has been Alan Rangel. The 28-year-old rookie got the ball as the fifth starter over the last month, and in his first two outings he followed an opener, lefty Tim Mayza.
He started his last three appearances, but the results never stabilized. Rangel got through five innings only once, gave up 13 runs in 20 1/3 innings, and allowed 22 hits, 12 walks and two hit batters.
Philadelphia lost all five games he started. Before Painter was sent down, the Phillies had gone 2-12 in his outings.
That led to another change on Monday, when the club optioned Rangel back to Triple-A. Now the rotation picture gets even murkier for the weekend.
Cristopher Sánchez, Zack Wheeler and Aaron Nola worked against the Dodgers this week, the team was off Thursday, and Jesús Luzardo is lined up to open Friday’s series against the Yankees. The off day also lets Sánchez stay on five days’ rest for Sunday’s finale.
Saturday is the issue. The Phillies need either a bullpen game or another starter, and their probable pitcher has not been named.
Rangel cannot return unless he is replacing an injured pitcher. Painter pitched in Triple-A on Tuesday, which makes a quick recall unlikely; if the Phillies had been planning to bring him back, they probably would have pulled him from that start instead of asking him to come back on three days’ rest.
One possibility would be to move Sánchez up to Saturday and use Painter on Sunday, but that remains only a theoretical route. If the club reaches into Triple-A, the names that make the most sense are Tucker Davidson or 32-year-old Brian Keller.
Jim Salisbury of NBC Sports Philadelphia reported Monday that the Phillies were actively looking for a fifth starter on the trade market, but that kind of move is not going to be in place in time for Saturday. There’s no sign they’re close to a deal, and even if one came together by Friday, they wouldn’t rush a new arm to the mound within 24 hours. They may need one or two more temporary turns before they can add someone before the August 3 deadline.
There’s also a chance Philadelphia decides to swing bigger. Matt Gelb of The Athletic reported Thursday morning that the front office has recently considered adding a playoff-caliber starter. That would cost more in prospects and/or salary, and it would have to be weighed against other needs, including an everyday right fielder and possibly a high-leverage reliever to replace Brad Keller.
The appeal is obvious. Sánchez, Wheeler and Luzardo give the Phillies a top three that can stand with anyone.
In a three-game Wild Card Series, that might be all they need. Even in a five-game NLDS, they could potentially ride a three-man rotation.
The calculus changes if they reach a seven-game NLCS, where Nola would likely become the fourth starter. That’s why the original idea was to find a steady back-end arm, someone who could get them through the regular season without forcing them to punt every fifth game while they’re in a tight Wild Card race. A depth starter would then slide into long relief or disappear from the playoff roster.
A bigger addition would mean something else entirely. It would protect them if one of the top three got hurt, and it might also say something about how the club views Nola.
He has an ERA close to 6.00 over 21 appearances, his second straight season in that range. He’s not at risk of losing his regular-season rotation job, but if the Phillies land a significant upgrade, he would be pushed out of a fully healthy playoff rotation.
The names that could be in play include Clay Holmes, Robbie Ray, Foster Griffin, Kevin Gausman, Shane Bieber, Tyler Mahle, Nick Lodolo and Jack Flaherty.
Nola has still worked deep enough to cover innings, and his strikeout and walk numbers have held up. The problem has been the ball leaving the yard.
His home run rate has climbed to career-worst levels, and only Jeffrey Springs has surrendered more homers. Nola’s 25 home runs allowed are tied with Zack Littell for the most in the National League, and he has given up multiple homers in six of his last eight starts.
In Other News...
Phillies Just Got A Troubling Pitching Update Before The Deadline
The Phillies have spent much of the summer trying to patch together a roster that has been tested by injuries on the right side of the outfield and by some uneven pitching behind the front of the rotation. With the deadline approaching, the conversation inside the organization has only sharpened around how much help the staff actually has in reserve, especially when it comes to finding reliable innings beyond the starters who are already carrying the load.
Alex McFarlane and Gage Wood are part of the systems long-term picture, but neither is viewed as a quick fix for the kind of late-game pressure the Phillies need to solve right now. Wood is still being developed as a starter, while McFarlane remains a work in progress, which leaves the front office staring at a familiar deadline question: whether the answer has to come from outside the organization rather than from a prospect breakthrough at home. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Linked To Francisco Lindor In Trade Idea Mets Fans Need To See
With the trade deadline approaching, the Phillies are still searching for ways to sharpen a roster built to win now, with pitching and bullpen help sitting near the top of the list. A recent hypothetical idea put Francisco Lindor into the conversation, which is enough to get attention around the league, but it also comes with an obvious question for Philadelphia: where exactly would he fit on a team that already has Trea Turner locked in long term?
Lindors production this season has not exactly made the case for a major reshuffle, and the Phillies have reason to be cautious about forcing a move just because a big name is available. For all the intrigue attached to a star shortstop, the cleaner path may be to use the deadline to add a more natural fit, with an outfielder on an expiring contract looking like the kind of upgrade that would make more sense for what this roster actually needs. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Linked To A Trade Idea That Would Frustrate Fans Fast
The latest trade chatter around the Phillies has a familiar kind of frustration attached to it, because it asks them to chase help at a spot that already looks occupied. Bleacher Reports Zachary D. Rymer floated a deal that would send two pitching prospects to Minnesota in exchange for a catcher, but Philadelphias current setup makes the idea feel more like a detour than a solution. J.T. Realmuto is healthy and still entrenched as the starter, while the broader roster picture points elsewhere for upgrades.
Catcher has become a depth conversation in Philadelphia more than a true need, especially with Rafael Marchan sidelined for a while and Garrett Stubbs not viewed as a reliable emergency starter. Even so, the Phillies front office has more pressing holes to address, particularly in the search for a right-handed slugger and outfield help, which is why a move like this would likely test fans patience fast. The market may exist for a catcher, but for the Phillies, the fit looks awfully hard to justify. [Read more 🡒]