As the Phillies weigh a new contract extension for Dave Dombrowski, they may be staring at a bigger loss than anything on the field: Sam Fuld.
Reports say Fuld is a candidate to head the Athletics’ baseball operations department, a move that would fit the former outfielder’s rise through front office ranks. And if that happens, the Phillies could be the ones letting a promising executive walk while doubling down on a 70-year-old president of baseball operations whose best years in Philadelphia may already be behind him.
Dombrowski has run the Phillies since the 2020-2021 offseason and has presided over one of the most successful stretches in team history, including five straight playoff appearances and a National League pennant. But the trajectory has changed. Since the club’s run to the World Series in 2022, the results have slipped each year, and this roster doesn’t look like a group ready to win it all right now.
Still, principal owner John Middleton appears fully committed to keeping Dombrowski in place. According to The Athletic’s Matt Gelb, an extension is imminent.
Gelb also suggested that if Dombrowski gets another deal, there should be a succession plan built around current general manager Preston Mattingly. In other words, the Phillies’ current power structure could be sticking around for a while.
That creates the obvious question: where does Fuld fit?
Fuld’s path has been steady and upward. After an eight-year major league career, he moved into player development and front office work, starting as major league player coordinator for Matt Klentak’s Phillies in 2017. Before the 2021 season, Dombrowski promoted him to general manager, and he held that role through the end of the 2024 season.
He then stepped away to attend the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School, where he earned a master’s degree. The 44-year-old returned to the Phillies this year in a business-side role, but apparently he isn’t finished with baseball operations. The future-Las Vegas Athletics are considering him for the top job in their front office.
That possibility makes sense. Fuld spent the final two seasons of his playing career, with a brief stop in between with the Minnesota Twins, in Oakland with the A’s, so there’s a natural connection there.
And while MLB teams usually don’t let front office employees leave for lateral moves, they often do not block promotions. If the A’s offer Fuld the lead role, the Phillies would almost certainly let him go.
That’s the part that stings. If Fuld is viewed as one of the sport’s rising minds, the Phillies may be losing him because Dombrowski’s presence leaves no room for him to move up in Philadelphia.
For a franchise that seems to value continuity above all else, maybe that’s not a surprise. The core of Kyle Schwarber, Bryce Harper, Zack Wheeler and Aaron Nola has been together for years and remains under contract for years to come, though Wheeler has mulled retiring after next season. Dombrowski’s timeline could end around the same time as that group’s run.
The bigger issue is whether that should be the plan. Dombrowski has spent most of the last 30 years leading front offices, and Middleton appears ready to keep him in charge for as long as he wants.
But the Phillies also need new ideas and a younger voice. Letting Fuld leave would be one more chance to add that kind of energy to the organization - and one more chance gone.
In Other News...
Bryce Harper Trade Talk Just Created A Phillies Offseason Debate
The Phillies early postseason exit has already pushed the offseason conversation into uncomfortable territory, and one of the biggest questions hanging over the front office involves a player who has defined the franchises modern era. Bryce Harper, the former NL MVP, has suddenly become part of the roster-changes debate as Philadelphia weighs how aggressively it wants to reshape a team that came up short again in October.
Among the clubs being mentioned as possible landing spots are the Red Sox, Cubs and Yankees, all teams with needs and the financial flexibility to at least make the discussion plausible. Nothing official has surfaced, and there is still a long way to go before any move becomes real, but the fact that Harper is even part of the offseason chatter shows how wide the Phillies reset could get. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Face A Painful Reset After Playoff Exit
After another playoff exit, the Phillies are already staring past the disappointment and into a harder question: what kind of core should they be building toward by 2027? The answer, at least in broad terms, starts with young talent. Alex McFarlane, Andrew Painter and Aidan Miller stand out as the kind of assets that can help shape the next version of this roster, giving the front office some much-needed direction as it weighs what still fits and what no longer does.
The harder part is the pruning, and that is where this winter could get uncomfortable. Brandon Marsh has been part of the conversation for a while, but his inconsistency leaves the Phillies with a tough evaluation, while Orion Kerkering also lands in the group the team may need to move on from if it is serious about resetting properly. For a club that still sees itself as a contender, the challenge is not just adding around the edges. It is deciding which names can survive the reset and which ones cannot. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Now Face A Tough Brandon Marsh Decision
The Phillies spent the summer looking like a team built for another deep October run, only to see the postseason end early against the Braves. One of the bigger reasons their season never fully found its footing was Brandon Marsh, who looked like an All-Star in the first half and a much different player after the break, leaving his overall impact far less steady than the club needed.
Now the front office has to weigh what comes next with an outfielder who still carries real value, but not quite the same kind it did a few months ago. Marshs uneven finish puts the Phillies in a tricky spot as they map out the offseason, balancing what it might take to keep him against the possibility that this may be the moment to listen if another team comes calling. [Read more 🡒]