The Phillies have an offseason need that’s hard to ignore: infield help. The free-agent market doesn’t offer a ton of clean answers, which is why a reunion with J.P.
Crawford starts to make sense. Add in the chance for Crawford to play next to his cousin, Justin, and this idea checks more than one box.
Crawford is no stranger to Philadelphia. The Phillies took him in the first round of the 2013 draft under the Ruben Amaro Jr. administration, and he reached the majors in 2017.
In two seasons with the club, he played in 72 games and hit .214/.333/.358 with 17 extra-base hits. The numbers weren’t eye-popping, but at 23, he still looked like a player with something ahead of him.
That upside eventually drew Seattle in. In December 2018, the Mariners landed Crawford and Carlos Santana from the Phillies in a trade that sent Jean Segura, Juan Nicasio, and James Pazos the other way. Segura later became a key part of the Phillies’ 2022 pennant run, while Crawford needed time to settle in with the Mariners before becoming a regular fixture.
Once he found his footing, he became a steady part of Seattle’s lineup. Over eight seasons there, the 31-year-old put up a .247/.340/.367 line with 265 extra-base hits in 974 games.
Most of that work came at shortstop, and he even won a Gold Glove Award in 2020. But the glove has slipped in recent years, enough that the Mariners gave him some time at third base this past season.
That matters for Philadelphia. The Phillies are likely to lose Alec Bohm in free agency this winter, and Crawford’s ability to handle third gives them a possible bridge until top prospect Aidan Miller is ready. He also brings shortstop experience if they need it.
Offensively, though, this wouldn’t be a splash move. Crawford has never been a big power bat, though he has settled in as a roughly league-average hitter over time. He posted an .818 OPS in 145 games in 2023, followed by a .722 mark in 2025, but he slipped to a .687 OPS over 116 games this past season.
So no, Crawford isn’t the kind of signing that transforms the Phillies’ 2027 outlook on its own. If he’s the only offensive move they make, that’s a problem.
But that’s also not really the point. Coming off a down year and with his defense trending the wrong way, he probably won’t command a pricey multi-year deal.
A low-cost one-year contract would give the Phillies a chance to see whether there’s still something left there.
And if it works, the storyline writes itself: a former top prospect back in Philadelphia, this time with a family connection on the roster too.
In Other News...
Phillies Rumors Are Ignoring One Big Reality Dombrowski Can't Escape
The Phillies are headed into what should be a busy offseason before the December 1 lockout, and the rumor mill is already doing what it always does this time of year. Philadelphia has the kind of roster that invites speculation, especially when a front office led by Dave Dombrowski has a history of staying aggressive, but the early read is that some of the biggest names floating around the market do not fit the clubs longer-term picture.
Ronald Acuna Jr., Ryan Jeffers and other headline possibilities may be fun to discuss, yet the reality is that contract situations and roster constraints make several of those paths unlikely for 2027. The rotation is already viewed as set for that season, which also takes some of the air out of the usual pitching chatter and narrows the field for long-term free-agent deals. Dombrowski could still surprise, but the more interesting question may be which big swings the Phillies simply cannot afford to take. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Are Quietly Building Infield Depth For A Bigger Roster Squeeze
The Phillies have spent the past few days quietly adding to their infield mix, claiming Brett Harris and Shay Whitcomb off waivers from the Giants as they look to shore up organizational depth. It is the kind of move that does not grab headlines on its own, but it matters for a club trying to keep enough versatile bodies in the pipeline as the season moves deeper into roster-management season.
Harris and Whitcomb both bring Triple-A production and limited major league experience, which gives Philadelphia a pair of low-cost options to evaluate without much downside. The wrinkle is that Harris has no minor league options left, while Whitcomb still does, a detail that could make one of the two easier to keep around as the Phillies sort through a crowded roster picture. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies Linked To Costly Outfield Fix Fans Will Debate
The Phillies are already being pushed toward a busy offseason, and the outfield is shaping up as one of the clearest areas for change. With free agency departures looming, the front office is being linked to outside help, and Randy Arozarena has emerged as a name that fits the kind of impact addition Philadelphia could chase if it wants to reshape the lineup quickly.
Arozarena also comes with the kind of price tag that guarantees debate in Philadelphia. Some analysts have projected a five-year, $140 million deal, a commitment that would not only be expensive on its own but could also carry draft-pick costs and add pressure to the clubs long-term payroll planning. For a team trying to stay aggressive without boxing itself in, the question is whether a splashy fix in the outfield is worth the risk. [Read more 🡒]