Phillies Old Pitching Bet Just Got A Lot Tougher To Defend

With Hao-Yu Lee making MLB history for Taiwan, the Phillies' trade decisions come under scrutiny as their reliance on strategic trades is juxtaposed with the missed potential of homegrown talent.

The Phillies didn’t keep Hao-Yu Lee long enough to benefit from what he’s doing now, and that’s starting to sting a little more by the day.

Lee, who once ranked fifth among Phillies prospects before being shipped to Detroit in the 2023 trade for Michael Lorenzen, just made MLB history for Taiwan. On Friday, he hit his 10th home run of the season in the Tigers’ game against the Chicago White Sox, becoming the first Taiwanese-born player in MLB history to reach double digits in homers in a season.

That’s a notable milestone on its own, but Lee’s path to it makes the story even more interesting. Philadelphia signed him as an international free agent in 2021 out of Taiwan, a country that has produced 19 major leaguers. Over three seasons in the Phillies’ system, he carved out a reputation as a polished hitter with enough feel to handle multiple infield spots.

By the time the Phillies dealt him, Lee had climbed near the top of their prospect list. Detroit kept him moving, too. He was still among the Tigers’ top 10 prospects in 2025 before making his big league debut in April of this year.

Now 23, Lee has settled in nicely during his first MLB season. He’s played 107 games split between second and third base and has posted a .753 OPS. His 10 home runs also put him halfway to Yu Chang’s career total of 20, which is the most by any Taiwanese player in the majors.

The Phillies, meanwhile, are left to think about the trade that sent him away. Lorenzen came in at the 2023 deadline after Philadelphia had already added Trea Turner and Taijuan Walker in free agency and was trying to push back to the World Series after a run to the National League pennant.

The right-hander gave them a flash of brilliance with a no-hitter in his second start, but the rest of the stint was much rougher. He finished with 47 ⅓ innings and a 5.51 ERA before working two postseason games in mop-up duty.

That deal may have helped steady the rotation in the moment, and maybe that mattered. But the bigger picture is harder to ignore now.

The Phillies have spent the past few years trying to patch together production from the right side, both in the infield and at utility spots, and Lee looks like the kind of player they’ve been searching for. Josh Harrison and Whit Merrifield didn’t work.

Otto Kemp and Felix Reyes were both out of the big league picture before the end of May.

There’s also the question of what comes next. Alec Bohm is set to hit free agency after the season, and Aidan Miller has missed almost all of this year with an injury. If Bryson Stott moves back to second, the Phillies don’t have many internal answers at third base.

That’s why Lee’s emergence matters beyond the history-making home run. He might not be Shohei Ohtani, but he is showing he can be a useful right-handed bat who can move around the field. And for a Phillies club that could use exactly that, his timing couldn’t be more frustrating.

In Other News...

Ricky Bottalico Shares Emotional Message With Phillies Fans After Family Loss

Ricky Bottalico has stepped away from his usual Phillies media work after the death of his brother, Jeffrey, following a brief illness. The former Phillies pitcher has been a familiar presence around the team through his roles with NBC Sports Philadelphia, so his absence was felt quickly, and the tributes that followed reflected just how connected he remains to the Philadelphia baseball community.

Support poured in from across the city once word spread of the familys loss, with fans and members of the local sports scene reaching out to Bottalico and his loved ones. In a market that tends to hold onto its former players, the response was a reminder of how much respect Bottalico still carries, even as he takes time away to be with family. [Read more 🡒]

Phillies Just Spotlighted Two Rising Names Fans Need To Know

The Phillies used their annual Paul Owens Award announcement to shine a light on two prospects who have helped keep the organizations pipeline looking healthy. Alex McFarlane earned the pitcher honor, while Bryan Rincon was recognized as the top hitter, a reminder that the clubs future is not built on one level alone but across a farm system that has started to produce real names worth tracking.

McFarlane has put together a strong run in both the minors and the majors, while Rincon has taken notable steps forward at Double-A Reading with his bat and overall game. For a Phillies system that is always under pressure to feed the big club, those kinds of developments matter, and this latest recognition suggests both players have moved themselves closer to the center of the conversation. [Read more 🡒]

Phillies Suddenly Have A Bigger Orion Kerkering Problem Than Expected

Orion Kerkerings quick rise earlier this season had given the Phillies a promising young arm to lean on in the bullpen, but the conversation around him has shifted sharply after his latest rough outing against the Mets. The club sent him to Triple-A Lehigh Valley, a move that reflects how quickly the margins tighten for relievers, especially when the stuff is there but the results are not.

Don Mattinglys concern after the game centered not just on the performance, but on Kerkerings confidence, which has become part of the bigger picture after a strong first half gave way to real struggles after the All-Star break. For a Phillies bullpen trying to steady itself for the stretch run, the question now is less about whether Kerkering can help, and more about how soon the organization believes he can regain the form that made him such an important part of the plan in the first place. [Read more 🡒]