With pitchers and catchers set to report to Clearwater on February 11, the Philadelphia Phillies' roster is largely in place as they gear up for another run. And while the front office has pushed back on the idea that they’re simply “running it back,” the reality is this: the core of this team remains intact.
That’s not necessarily a bad thing, considering how close they’ve come in recent seasons. But if there’s one area that still feels like it could use a little more certainty, it’s the outfield.
Right now, the Phillies are rolling into spring training with a mix of youth, upside, and question marks in the outfield. And while they’ve made it clear they’re comfortable with where things stand, there’s still one name on the free-agent market who could shift the balance: Harrison Bader.
A Potential Bader Reunion Makes Sense-If the Price Is Right
Bader, who spent part of last season in Philly, remains the top outfield option left in free agency. And while there’s no clear indication the Phillies are actively pursuing a reunion, the fit is hard to ignore.
MLB insider Mark Feinsand recently listed the Phillies as a potential landing spot, noting that other teams like the Mets, Diamondbacks, and Cardinals are also in the mix. So while a return to Philadelphia might not be the most likely scenario, it’s certainly not off the table.
If the Phillies do decide to bring Bader back, it would go a long way in solidifying a group that currently includes Brandon Marsh, Adolis García, Otto Kemp, and top prospect Justin Crawford. There’s also Johan Rojas and Gabriel Rincones Jr., both of whom could factor in as depth options. And of course, Kyle Schwarber-whose days as a full-time outfielder are behind him-will primarily serve as the designated hitter.
Bader’s second-half stint in Philly last year was nothing short of impressive. In 50 games, he slashed .305/.361/.463 with five home runs and 16 RBIs, posting an .824 OPS. He also filled in admirably as the leadoff hitter when Trea Turner landed on the injured list, giving the lineup some much-needed spark at the top.
The Outfield Picture Without Bader
The current plan appears to hinge on a few key developments. First, there’s the emergence of Justin Crawford.
The Phillies are high on the 20-year-old, and for good reason-his speed and athleticism jump off the page. But asking a rookie to carry a significant load in a pennant-chasing season is always a gamble.
Then there’s the left field situation, where the team seems poised to platoon Brandon Marsh and Otto Kemp. Marsh has shown flashes, especially against right-handed pitching, but consistency has been an issue.
Kemp, entering his second season, remains a bit of a wild card. The Phillies are hoping he takes a step forward, but there’s no guarantee.
Add it all up, and it’s clear why a player like Bader-who brings elite defense, postseason experience, and a solid bat-would be a valuable addition. He’s also still just 31, with enough athleticism to cover center field and allow the Phillies to be more flexible with their defensive alignments.
What’s the Hold-Up?
The holdup might be contract-related. Bader is reportedly eyeing a deal similar to the two-year, $23 million contract Mike Yastrzemski signed with the Braves, which includes a $7 million club option for 2028. That kind of deal might be more than the Phillies are willing to commit, especially with their current payroll structure and long-term planning in mind.
But if Bader doesn’t land a multi-year contract elsewhere, a one-year reunion with the Phillies could make a lot of sense-for both sides. It would give Bader a chance to re-establish his market value in a familiar environment, and it would give the Phillies a proven outfielder to bolster their depth heading into what they hope will be another deep October run.
Final Thoughts
President of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski recently said he feels “great” about where the team stands heading into spring training. And to be fair, this is still one of the most talented rosters in the National League. But the outfield remains their biggest question mark, and with spring training just weeks away, there’s still time to address it.
Whether or not that means a reunion with Harrison Bader remains to be seen. But if the Phillies want to shore up their weakest link and give themselves the best shot at a championship, adding one more proven piece to the outfield puzzle wouldn’t be the worst idea.